Thursday, November 19, 2026
Danielle Knight
- Conservationists are grappling with how best to use limited financial resources to protect threatened flora and fauna worldwide.
Most scientists agree that many species are at risk but disagree over which conservation strategies should be prioritised.
The issue, some anticipate, will gain more attention if environmental budgets fall as governments shift their focus to anti-terrorism and reconstruction efforts, or if prolonged recession results in a sustained downswing in charitable contributions to conservation groups.
Researchers at the World Conservation Union (IUCN) and Future Harvest, a Washington-based agricultural research organisation, argue that instead of focussing on protected areas and reserves, funds should be directed at transforming the way farmers around the world grow their crops.
“Many people believe that biodiversity can be preserved simply by fencing it off,” says Jeffery McNeely, chief scientist at Switzerland-based IUCN. But to avert widespread extinctions, biological preservation must be integrated into all methods of agriculture – from the management of grazing lands to the design of coffee plantations and rice paddies.
McNeely is co-author of a new report, “Common Ground, Common Future,” which argues that tropical parks and reserves have been unable to protect the biological resources within their boundaries because of growing development needs in surrounding areas.
Agriculture as currently practiced is a chief cause of the destruction of valuable habitats, pushing species towards extinction, the report says. It notes that more than 1.1 billion people live within the world’s 25 biodiversity “hot spots”, a term used by ecologists to describe threatened areas that are rich in flora and fauna.
Almost half of the world’s current protected areas, argues McNeely, are in regions where agriculture is a major form of land use and where food production will need to increase in coming decades to keep up with population growth.
“Unless agricultural practices are improved, habitats and species will continue to disappear at an alarming rate,” he says.
The solution, according to his report, is “eco-agriculture”, farming methods that protect wild species and conserve habitat while increasing agricultural production.
Sara Scherr, a fellow at Washington-based Forest Trends and co- author of the report, says increasing crop yields on lands already being farmed, as opposed to bringing more land under cultivation, will be key to preserving biodiversity.
In the Philippine province of Palawan, she notes, the Philippine National Irrigation Administration constructed numerous small- scale communal irrigation systems and upgraded others to supply the lowland farms with a regular supply of water.
The lowland farms were then able to produce more food, while employing many workers who had previously been involved in lower- paying farming and hunting, charcoal making, and resin collection in the environmentally-sensitive upcountry.
“As a result, annual forest clearing by upland households declined by 48 percent,” she says.
An eco-agriculture strategy, says Scherr, also would involve protecting wildlife habitat on unused land within farms and establishing “corridors” on farmland that link uncultivated areas
In the mountainous region of northeast Costa Rica, she says, the Conservation League of Monteverde worked with farmers to plant a mix of indigenous and exotic tree species that acted as windbreaks. The wind had limited diary productivity and increased calf mortality.
While serving as a biological corridor connecting patches of forest, the trees also provided habitat for wild parakeets that had been damaging farmers’ coffee trees.
“One study found seeds of 174 different plant species in the windbreaks,” she says.
“Shade coffee” plantations, in which coffee plants grow in the shade of a wide variety of native tropical trees, also serve to protect biodiversity. In Central America, researchers are looking for ways to help shade coffee plantations compete economically with the more common coffee crops that grow in direct sunlight, says Scherr.
Other researchers, however, say shifting the conservation focus to eco-agriculture will divert funds needed for protected areas and wildlife parks.
“Eco-agriculture is an important concept, but the need to invest in eco-agriculture instead of parks is overstated,” says Richard Rice, chief economist at the Centre for Applied Biodiversity Science at the non-governmental Conservation International.
Eco-agriculture is a compromise, not a solution, says Rice, because ecosystems are still disturbed. Often, he adds, eco- agriculture lacks a financial incentive and therefore its sustainability in the long term is questionable.
Rice says his research, contrary to that of McNeely and Scherr, shows that many tropical parks are successfully protecting the ecosystems and species within their borders against major threats such as land-clearing and logging.
Having surveyed 93 parks across the tropics, Rice has found that most were in significantly better condition than their surroundings in terms of area cleared, populations of game and timber species, and other factors.
Parks, Rice says, also have been highly effective in preventing illegal agricultural clearing.
Nearly 85 percent of the parks studied permitted no net clearing since they were founded, and on balance, more land was actually reforested within them than was cleared.
Rice acknowledges that protected areas are not perfect and many of the parks studied suffered significant damage from hunting, logging, grazing, or fire. The problem, he says, is that very little money – in some cases, as little as one dollar per hectare – is spent on maintaining and patrolling protected areas.
“Parks, if anything, deserve our redoubled attention,” he says, adding that conservationists should focus on strategies that protect existing parks and establish new nature preserves.
One such strategy, he says, is to set up “conservation concessions,” under which payments are made directly to the government or citizens to compensate for revenue or employment lost by agreeing not to exploit a given natural resource, such as timber.
“A ‘conservation concession’ is a means to compensate local resource owners and users for conservation and is a source of dependable funding,” says Rice.
In September 2000, Conservation International, working with the government of Guyana, helped establish the world’s first conservation concession covering about 80,000 hectares of tropical rainforest.