Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines, Population

POPULATION-NEPAL: Citizenship Row Festers after Govt Drops Bill

Suman Pradhan

KATHMANDU, Oct 18 2001 (IPS) - A divisive row over citizenship is flaring up again in the Himalayan kingdom of Nepal, after the abrupt scrapping of a controversial bill that aimed to simplify citizenship procedures for more than 3 million southerners of Indian origin.

Prime Minister Sher Bahadur Deuba early this week told parliament that his centrist Nepali Congress government had withdrawn the bill introduced by his predecessor early this year, and will soon replace it with a “more comprehensive and less controversial legislation”.

While the announcement has been welcomed by most opposition parties and legal experts, it has not gone down well in Nepal’s southern Terai plains, where 3.4 million people of Indian origin are awaiting citizenship certificates.

Without these document in this impoverished nation, no one can buy or sell property, get a government job and even pursue higher education. For these reasons, critics have long decried the second-class status of the ‘Madhesis’, or southerners of Indian origin, and have demanded prompt action to defuse the citizenship crisis.

According to the latest census carried out early this year, Nepal’s population has boomed to 23 million. A third of those reside in the southern plains bordering India, where the ethnic makeup is largely of Indian origin.

Terai-based political parties, notably the Nepal Sadbhavana Party (NSP), has long pressured the government to immediately address the citizenship issue.

It was partly to address the problems that former Prime Minister Girija Prasad Koirala introduced the legislation early this year.

The bill was passed by the Lower House, but met stiff resistance in the Upper House where the opposition communists are in a majority. Koirala simply railroaded the bill through the Lower House again and sent it to Late King Birendra for his approval.

But instead, the monarch -û who was murdered in June by his own son -û sought the advice of the Supreme Court on the bill’s constitutionality. The Court ruled the bill unconstitutional. Matters rested there until last week, when Deuba formally withdrew the failed bill and promised to introduce a new piece of legislation “after consultation with the opposition”.

Many ‘Madhesis’ in Nepal see the maneuvering over the bill as discriminatory, proof of the bias against them. “This is proof of the hills people’s bias against ‘madhesis’,” says U. K. Chaudhary, a legislator who represents a southern district. “This issue should not be politicised, but rather resolved without delay.”

A constitutional expert, former speaker of parliament Daman Nath Dhungana, says that the government did the right thing by withdrawing the dead bill. “Now they should ensure that the new bill is not as controversial,” he said.

The controversy over the bill clearly underscores the hills- plains divide in Nepal. About two-thirds of the Himalayan kingdom comprises hills inhabited by ethnic hill tribes and the ruling Brahmin-Chhettri- Newar castes. The rest comprises of southern plains bordering India’s northern states, and the ethnic make-up there reflects that reality.

Many thousands of ethnic Indian families have settled in Nepal for generations -û borders between Nepal and India are open — even acquiring citizenship over the years. But many of the newer arrivals have not, kicking up an explosive political issue.

Past governments tried to settle the issue by forming two separate commissions in the late 1990s to look into the matter.

Both the commissions recommended speedy citizenship distribution to 3.4 million such ‘madhesis’, but the implementation has been patchy at best. Besides, the courts in Nepal have been quite conservative in dealing with citizenship cases.

The centrist Nepali Congress, which has been in power for most of Nepal’s 11 years of democracy, argues that it has been trying to resolve the issue once and for all. But no one, not even the ‘madhesis’, are satisfied with the Congress government’s attempts. Many see it as a vote-catching gimmick targetted more toward elections.

Tellingly, the NSP, the party that represents ‘madhesi’ interests, abstained from voting on the controversial bill when it was passed by the House of Representatives early this year. NSP leader Hridayesh Tripathi claims the bill was not as progressive as the party wanted.

But progressive it was. At present, a child can obtain hereditary citizenship in Nepal only if the father has one. The mother’s citizenship does not count, another example of gender discrimination in this heavily paternalistic society. But the just-scrapped bill contained provisions that made it possible to gain citizenship if the person could prove birth in Nepal. Also, the mother’s citizenship could also count, not just the father.

It was these provisions that were decried by other political parties. They feared the provisions could be misused by unscrupulous local officials and politicians, opening the floodgates to countless “undeserving foreigners”.

The main opposition party, the Communist Party of Nepal (Unified Marxist-Leninist), first supported the bill but later turned against it as opposition in the hill districts, including in the capital Kathmandu, began to mount. Today, the party is staunchly opposed to the bill, but also asserts that it too wants to defuse the citizenship crisis.

“Our opposition is mainly against certain provisions which make it possible to misuse the law,” argues Subash Nembang, a communist legislator. “But if the government incorporates our suggestions in the new bill, we will support it to pass the legislation. We also want the citizenship issue to be dealt with effectively.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags