Headlines, Human Rights, North America

RIGHTS-CANADA: Anti-Terrorism Legislation Scored as Repressive

Mark Bourrie

OTTAWA, Oct 17 2001 (IPS) - The Canadian government is pressing ahead with plans to enact a sweeping new anti-terrorism law by the end of November, despite civil libertarians’ warnings that the legislation poses a threat to legitimate dissent.

Critics maintain the complex legislation would suspend several civil liberties including protection against self-incrimination and arrest without charges, and would give the government too much power not only to strip legal protection from anyone suspected of terrorism, but to define who terrorists are in the first place.

On one hand, critics say this power is so sweeping that anti- globalisation protesters and Native activists could be labeled as “terrorists”. On the other hand, they predict that, precisely because the legislation is so broad, it faces an almost inevitable challenge in court under the country’s Charter of Rights and Freedoms.

“The protesters at (April’s Summit of the Americas in) Quebec City and in other parts of the world could be caught in this kind of language. I’m not suggesting that it was intended to do that, but their language is too sweeping and their definition is too broad,” says Maude Barlow, an anti-globalisation activist who heads the non-governmental Council of Canadians.

“I actually fear that they’ll put democracy to sleep and, in doing so, end up with a nightmare worse than we’ve had,” she adds. “The legislation goes too far.”

The law “will end up being used against peaceful protests and demonstrations,” says Toronto civil rights lawyer Clayton Ruby. “It will wind up being used to suppress political opposition. The problem with these laws is that they come in as emergency measures, temporary measures that are only supposed to last for a short time. But they are never temporary. They are always permanent. You can never roll them back.”

Justice Minister Anne McLellan says the law is needed to give the police powers to stop terrorist acts, break up conspiracies, and prevent fundraising. The law makes it illegal to train potential terrorists, administer their funds, or to know about potential terrorist conspiracies.

It allows for suspects to be brought before a judge in secret for interrogation. Questions from the judge must be answered or the suspect could be jailed indefinitely for contempt of court. The law also allows the government to increase the size of the Federal Court of Canada by one-third to deal with these interrogations and with applications for warrants. The court does not conduct criminal trials.

The bill defines acts of terrorism as those threatening Canadian lives or property, that instill fear in society, damage the economy, or that are targeted against political institutions and the general welfare of the country. McLellan says it has three main objectives: suppress existing terrorist groups, provide police with new investigative tools, and toughen prison sentences for terrorists.

Legislation normally takes months to pass through Parliament but the government is expected to use its majority to push the bill through with minimal debate.

Three opposition parties say they support the bill in principle. Two conservative parties are demanding even more draconian laws.

The social democratic New Democratic Party (NDP) is the only legislative group that opposes important aspects of the bill. Member of Parliament Bill Blaikie, the party’s justice critic, says the NDP wants to be sure that the right to peaceful dissent is not removed, or even limited.

“We believe that people everywhere are entitled to live in peace and security,” McLellan told legislators. “We’ve kept individual rights of Canadians in mind while developing this legislation.”

In addition to facilitating secret interrogations and proceedings against suspects, the new measures would grant police wide powers of arrest without warrants; impose long consecutive sentences for terrorist crimes; and make it easier for police to obtain warrants for wiretaps, which they could maintain for as long as three years.

It also would allow for the assets of alleged terrorists and their supporters to be frozen or seized; increase the power of Canadian intelligence agencies to intercept electronic communications from abroad; and expand the government’s powers to keep information secret.

New categories of offence would be created to counter espionage and also to deter vandalism of religious property and other hate crimes.

“The legitimate war on terrorism doesn’t require measures as broad as that,” says Alan Borovoy, president of the Canadian Civil Liberties Association.

The Canadian Bar Association also has issued a similar note of caution, saying that just because police may want the extra powers does not necessarily mean they should have them. “It may be that people are going too far down the road in wanting to clamp on freedoms which we now take for granted,” says Bar Association executive member Simon Potter.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags