Thursday, November 19, 2026
Danielle Knight
- The nuclear power lobby won a major victory Tuesday, when the House of Representatives renewed a disputed law limiting industry liability in nuclear accidents.
Extending the so-called Price-Anderson Act was a top priority for the industry, which argued it stood to lose billions of dollars in increased insurance premiums if the law was not re-authorised.
The law also is seen as vital to President George W. Bush’s goal of expanding nuclear power as part of his bid to reduce U.S. reliance on foreign sources of energy. In May, Vice President Dick Cheney was quoted as saying that without the bill, “nobody’s going to invest in nuclear power plants.”
Critics, however, maintained that the law props up an unsafe industry that would not be viable without massive government support.
Price-Anderson enables nuclear power companies to keep insurance costs down by capping liability coverage at 200 million dollars per reactor and nine billion dollars for the industry as a whole. Without these limits, industry lobbyists argued, the price of insurance would be prohibitive.
Lawmakers in the House extended the law for 15 years under special rules that allowed them to conduct a voice vote. This ensured that votes would remain anonymous and pre-empted any attempt to amend the law. The procedure normally is reserved for bills considered not controversial.
The Senate also must re-authorise the law for it to remain in effect. It has been extended four times since being introduced in 1957.
“Price-Anderson is a proven framework that has worked for nearly 45 years,” said Marvin Fertel, senior vice president of the Nuclear Energy Institute, a Washington-based industry group. Fertel has called on Congress to renew the law indefinitely.
The legislation originally was passed as a temporary measure to support what then was a fledgling industry. It has since turned into a permanent corporate subsidy, said Jill Lancelot, legislative director with Taxpayers for Commonsense, a government- spending watchdog.
No other industry has ever been as thoroughly insulated from financial risks, she said, adding that normally, high-liability businesses are expected to be financially responsible for their actions.
“If the private insurance industry – the professional risk assessors – refuses to insure an activity or requires such high premiums that the activity is prohibitively expensive, this is the market mechanism for limiting that activity,” said Lancelot.
Price-Anderson liability limits fall far below the potential cost of a nuclear accident, according to Wenonah Hauter, director of an energy and environment campaign at Public Citizen, a Washington- based group founded by consumer advocate Ralph Nader. As a result, taxpayers could end up paying billions of dollars if a meltdown occurred or a reactor were attacked by terrorists.
The cost of cleaning up the Chernobyl nuclear disaster was more than 300 billion dollars. The Sandia National Laboratory, a government research facility, estimated in 1982 that an accident at a single nuclear power facility would cost hundreds of billions of dollars.
Critics also have argued that Price-Anderson came on top of already hefty handouts for the nuclear energy industry. Between 1948 and 1998, the sector received 66 billion dollars in subsidies for research and development, according to the Congressional Research Service.
Industry officials said the chances of a nuclear accident were remote but environmental groups denounced lawmakers for limiting liability amid heightened concerns about attacks on nuclear facilities since the Sep. 11 terrorist attacks on the United States.
Following the attacks, the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) tightened security at nuclear plants and began reviewing its own security regulations and procedures.
The government commission acknowledged that nuclear reactors had not been designed to withstand aerial attacks like the ones that killed thousands on Sep. 11. It also found that 27 out of 57 nuclear power plants evaluated in February 1999 had “significant” security deficiencies and were vulnerable to terrorist attacks.
“Current nuclear security requirements do not adequately reflect the risks that we now know to be possible,” environmental and public-interest groups said last month in a letter to House lawmakers. Signatories included Friends of the Earth, Greenpeace, and the Natural Resources Defense Council.
Critics also voiced alarm that the bill included concessions for new “pebble bed modular” nuclear reactors. Critics argued that this new design cuts costs by eliminating the traditional containment measures that protect the reactor from explosions and other disturbances.
“There is no excuse for such blatant disregard of the safety risks that a new generation of nuclear plants would pose,” said Hauter.