Economy & Trade, Environment, Headlines, North America

ENVIRONMENT: U.S. Trade Representative Sued Over Secrecy

Danielle Knight

WASHINGTON, Nov 9 2001 (IPS) - U.S.-based advocacy groups filed suit against the office of the U.S. Trade Representative (USTR) in U.S. District Court here Friday, charging the agency broke the law by failing to respond to their request for documents on the government’s negotiating position in trade talks with Chile.

U.S. and Chilean environmental and public-interest groups had sought the documents, they said, for fear that a free-trade agreement being hammered out by their governments could weaken environmental and health regulations in both countries.

Their complaint, which named Trade Representative Robert Zoellick as defendant, stated that the USTR had been required by law to comply by Jul. 25 with their request, which had been submitted under the Freedom of Information Act.

The USTR was unavailable for comment, a staff member said, because most of its staff was in Doha, Qatar at the World Trade Organisation ministerial conference, where Western governments hope to launch a new round of multilateral trade negotiations.

Friday’s suit was brought by California-based Earthjustice on its own behalf and for the Washington-based Centre for International Environmental Law, Friends of the Earth, and Public Citizen.

The groups were among those that asked the USTR to disclose documents it provided to Chilean negotiators at meetings over the past two years, on provisions of the proposed trade pact.

In the past, the USTR has argued that trade negotiations were exempt from the Freedom of Information Act because the law does not require them to release information contained in internal communications among government agencies. The plaintiffs countered that the documents do not qualify for this exemption because the USTR already had shared them with a foreign government.

“If citizens are kept in the dark until negotiations are completed, they will never be able to provide useful advice concerning rules that would directly affect their lives and health,” said Martin Wagner, director of international programmes at Earthjustice.

Environmentalists long have charged that trade agreements can have enormous environmental consequences but too often have been worked out behind closed doors with no public oversight or participation.

The groups said they worried that the bilateral agreement would include investment protection rules like those in the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA), which allow corporations to sue countries over environmental and health laws on the grounds that these inhibit trade. In a number of cases, critics noted, corporations have used the provision as a strategic weapon against environmental, public safety, and health regulations.

“The public should be able to find out whether negotiators intend to give even more foreign investors the right to challenge environmental and public interest protections,” said David Waskow, trade and investment policy coordinator with Friends of the Earth.

Concerns over the NAFTA provision intensified when a three-judge panel under the trade agreement found last year that Mexico violated the rules and ordered it to pay 16 million dollars to a U.S. waste-handling company, Metalclad.

In the early 1990s, Metalclad received approval from the Mexican government to build a disposal plant capable of handling up to 360,000 tons of hazardous waste a year. When an environmental impact assessment revealed that the site lies atop an ecologically sensitive underground stream, the governor declared the site part of an ecological reserve and refused to allow Metalclad to open the facility, despite federal support for the project.

This, the NAFTA tribunal ruled, amounted to expropriation of the company’s profits. The Mexican government paid the award late last month.

In another NAFTA case, the Canadian-based Methanex Corporation filed suit against the United States, claiming the state of California’s decision to phase out use of its gasoline additive methyl tertiary butyl ether (MTBE) cost the company 970 million dollars.

California’s governor, Gray Davis, ordered the additive banned by the end of 2002 after studies revealed unusually high – and potentially harmful – levels of MTBE in California’s drinking water supply. Methanex’s claim against the state is still pending.

These cases have bolstered environmentalists’ opposition to providing President George W. Bush with “fast-track” authority to negotiate new trade agreements. Labour unions and conservation groups have demanded that any such authorisation include strong and enforceable provisions for protecting workers’ rights and the environment.

In March, environmentalists launched a similar lawsuit against the USTR to disclose written proposals it made to other governments concerning the Free Trade Area of the Americas (FTAA) agreement, which seeks integrate the hemisphere’s 34 nations in a common trade and investment zone.

Critics have dubbed the FTAA the “little WTO” and the “bigger and meaner NAFTA” and argue it could further weaken the ability of governments to pass and maintain conservation and public health laws.

As with the Chile trade talks, the FTAA negotiations have been kept secret and organisations have been left to wonder if U.S. trade officials are including the investment protection provision.

“One can only suspect that our trade negotiators are busily spreading NAFTA’s problems to the rest of the hemisphere,” said Mary Bottari, director of a trade project at Public Citizen, a Washington-based group founded by consumer advocate Ralph Nader and Green Party presidential candidate.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags