Headlines, Latin America & the Caribbean

POLITICS-CHILE: 1931 Navy Mutiny Still Making Waves

Gustavo González

SANTIAGO, Nov 30 2001 (IPS) - The re-release of Patricio Manns’ book “La revolución de la escuadra” (The Revolution of the Fleet) has returned Chile’s attention to an incident occurred 70 years ago that illustrates the continuing paradoxes of the country’s navy and which official history has chosen to ignore.

The book has been reborn in post-dictatorship Chile nearly 30 years after it was first published in 1972, and now includes an invaluable historical document as an appendix: excerpts from the diary of Admiral Edgardo Von Schroeders, one of the protagonists of the events.

It was Sep 2, 1931, when Chile was struggling with the social and economic crisis triggered by the Great Depression in the United States, that petty officers and sailors in the navy mutinied, taking over the fleet.

More than 20 vessels anchored in the bays of Coquimbo, 460 km north of Santiago, and Talcahuano, 520 km to the south, were occupied by navy troops, who overpowered the higher ranking officers and held them prisoner on the ships.

The insurrection, which lasted six days, was detonated by the navy’s refusal to accept a 30-percent salary cut, decreed for the entire country by the provisional government of Manuel Trucco in a bid to prevent the Chilean state from going bankrupt.

The rebellion was “a social revolution – leftist, democratic and peaceful – with absolute respect for the officers. Only one was wounded, and he had tried to resist arrest,” says Manns.

In contrast, the response from the Trucco government, with support from the top brass of the navy, army and air force, was particularly bloody, especially in Talcahuano, where the rebelling troops were virtually massacred.

Manns describes the clash between the navy and the army troops in Talcahuano as the largest battle waged in Chile in the 20th century.

Some 1,000 men were taken prisoner, but the death toll was never revealed, neither by the authorities nor by the press of that era.

Manns’ book is a step-by-step reconstruction of the negotiations that Von Schroeders, the government’s representative, held with the mutineers, who were led by Corporal Manuel Astica Fuentes and petty officer Ernesto González Brion.

After four days of talks in Coquimbo, the negotiations were broken off and the government forces attacked the ships anchored there from the air. There was little danger for the pilots because they dropped their bombs from altitudes of more than 2,500 metres to avoid being hit by fire from the rebels aboard the navy vessels.

Manns’ book reveals that while Von Schroeders was at the negotiating table Interior Minister Luis Izquierdo had won a commitment from the United States to put an end to the rebellion if the Chilean government failed to do so.

The negotiator’s delay tactics ultimately eroded the unity of the mutineers, leading the troops to desert two ships in Coquimbo. Meanwhile, a military offensive was being prepared against the naval station in Talcahuano.

The navy uprising had broad popular support, especially among the communities surrounding Chile’s northern saltpetre mines, which had been shut down as a result of the economic crisis, and among the coal mining communities of Lota and Coronel, in the Talcahuano region.

The Workers’ Federation of Chile began preparing a national strike in support of the navy mutineers, who, in turn, had adopted the unionists’ demands as their own. However, the government suppressed the rebellion before the planned strike could take place.

The uprising and the military response were capable of changing the course of Chilean history, which in part explains the official veil of silence about the episode, said journalist Mónica González at the presentation ceremony of the new edition of the book on Nov 27.

“La revolución de la escuadra” portrays what is considered the most troubled period of Chilean history in the first half of the 20th century.

Trucco headed a provisional government following the 1930 overthrow of the Carlos Ibáñez del Campo dictatorship. A year after the navy rebellion, in June 1932, Chile experienced a short- lived socialist republic – 12 days – led by air force commodore Marmaduque Grove.

It was Grove who issued pardons for González Brion, Astica Fuentes and other navy-men condemned either to death or to life imprisonment for their roles in the 1931 uprising.

The United States was ready to intervene in 1931 to prevent others from following the examples of the 1917 Bolshevik Revolution in Russia. But in Chile at the time, the Communist Party, founded in 1922, was still very small and the Socialist Party would not appear until 1933.

According to Carlos Altamirano, former senator and former socialist leader, the ferocious attack against the navy rebels is yet another indicator of the exclusive and conservative character of the highest echelons of the Chilean navy, officers who had believed the chances of mutiny were non-existent.

But the petty officers and marine privates, who faced discrimination in a navy force that is considered a legacy of the British school, have historically identified with popular social movements.

Comparisons of the Chilean incident with the battleship Potemkin in the failed Russian revolution of 1905, immortalised by the famous film by Serguei Eisenstein, or with the Bolshevik marines in 1917 are inevitable, says writer and former communist senator Volodia Teitelboim.

Altamirano pointed out that in August 1973 the navy accused him of sedition because he made contact with petty officers who sought to denounce the coup plans against the leftist Popular Unity government, plans that were carried out a month later in the overthrow of President Salvador Allende.

When Manns published the first version of “La revolución de la escuadra” in 1972, he also became the target of charges of sedition from the Naval Prosecutor General, prompting him to flee Chile in 1973 to avoid arrest.

“That saved my life because by the time the coup occurred in September I was no longer here,” said the author, whose noteworthy writing career also includes historical essays on social struggle, novels and popular songs.

Teitelboim describes Manns as “a one-man band, a multifaceted creator and a fighter who shoots words from his weapon of truth.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags