Europe, Headlines

POLITICS-RUSSIA: The Kremlin Opens a Dialogue with NGOs

Sergei Blagov

MOSCOW, Nov 24 2001 (IPS) - The Kremlin has for the first time opened its doors to members of non-governmental organisations (NGOs).

An NGO Forum held last week marked another significant departure from the days when the State was all. The State “realizes a need for dialogue and partnership between the authorities and civil society”, Russian President Vladimir Putin told the NGO gathering on November 21.

There can be “no strong state or prosperous society” without such partnership, Putin said. The authorities are not trying to dominate non-governmental organisations, which “can only grow from the spirit of freedom,” he said. Putin pointed out that many critics of the government had joined the forum, and described their criticism as “very useful”. He promised a “most favourable environment” for the development of non-governmental organisations.

Organisers of the Civic Forum held November 21-22 said delegates represented more than 350,000 non-governmental organisations with a membership of about a million. These NGOs interact with some 20 million Russians – an evidence that Russia already has strong groups independent of government control, organisers said.

The congress was initiated last summer by several groups with links to the Kremlin such as the Public Opinion Fund and the Efficient Policy Fund run by Gleb Pavlovsky. The move was backed by about 250 regional NGOs. Pavlovsky came up with a schedule to help dialogue. “Every Russian citizen must have a communication channel with the authorities,” Pavlovsky told the gathering.

The forum was not easy to organise and it took weeks of negotiations before the country’s most high profile NGOs, often seen as critical of President Putin’s policies, agreed to participate. And despite Putin’s “NGO-friendly” remarks, not all were convinced. “No regime will ever stop attempts to control its citizens,” human rights advocate and State Duma deputy Sergei Kovalyov, told RTR television.

Some critics warned that the event might be an attempt by the Kremlin to control Russia’s non-governmental sector. But independent NGOs, including the Moscow Helsinki Group, secured conditions that would keep the congress from becoming an instrument to push Kremlin policy.

“We were treated as equals by the authorities,” Lyudmila Alexeyeva, head of the Moscow Helsinki Group said at the conference. Alexeyeva, one of the country’s most respected human rights advocates, said in her opening remarks at the Kremlin Palace of Congresses that there would be no presidium, no voting and no resolutions. The groups would be left free to go their own ways.

Seven representatives of “opposition” NGOs set up a working group to plan the congress after Kremlin officials accepted their conditions. Their most important demand was that there should be no representative body elected after the congress. The conditions also included transparent financing of the congress. Once these conditions were met, there was no reason for refusing a dialogue, Alexeyeva said.

The 21-member organising committee that finally planned the forum included seven government officials, seven members of pro-Kremlin NGOs and seven members of “opposition” NGOs, including Alexeyeva.

The forum brought together NGO activists who often dislike each other. Regional NGOs were particularly agitated that their voices are not heard in the Russian capital.

Sergei Markov, head of the organising committee and director of the Institute for Political Studies made it clear that one of the aims of the congress is to give more support to regional groups. The Kremlin is interested in interaction with all social organisations in Russia, and “not just in the 500 people that monopolise Western grants,” Markov said.

Critics argued also that a crowd of social workers, human rights advocates, stamp collectors, pet protectionists and others was far too diverse for the purpose of a viable dialogue with the government.

The Forum went on, however, to address a range of issues. Following the opening session, participants divided into more than 20 discussion groups covering topics such as the Chechen conflict, health, women’s issues and environment protection. Discussion groups of about 300 people each were further divided into roundtables of 100 people. Eventually, the roundtables picked about 15 people to discuss concrete issues with government officials.

For instance, representatives of 44 associations of the disabled gathered at a round table to discuss their problems. Vladimir Krupennikov, head of the group Strategy complained that Russian disabled people face “insurmountable difficulties” in getting a university degree or a decent job. At the Kremlin Palace of Congresses itself there were no wheelchair facilities.

In line with promises, the authorities opened the account books of the Forum for inspection. Deputy Prime Minister Valentina Matviyenko revealed that the Forum had cost the rouble equivalent of 1.5 million dollars. She said the money came from “sponsors” and not the government. But the main sponsors include state-controlled banking giant Sberbank and the powerful Alfa-Bank, also seen as close to the Kremlin.

Despite the warnings by sceptics, however, most NGOs saw the Forum as a significant step forward.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags