Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines, Human Rights, Population

RIGHTS: Australia Set to Back Down on Refugee Policy

Kalinga Seneviratne

SYDNEY, Dec 12 2001 (IPS) - After a new round of criticism of its policy of sending asylum seekers intercepted in the high seas to poor Pacific Island countries, Australia is admitting that its so called ‘Pacific Solution’ may not be a solution to the refugee crisis after all.

Australia began implementing this policy in September, when the Norwegian freighter ‘Tampa’ rescued more 400 people from a sinking ship between Indonesia and Australia. Most of those on board were from Iraq.

Australia refused to let the ship offload them in a local port. In the end, it negotiated with the Pacific Island nations of Nauru and Papua New Guinea (PNG) to house them in makeshift camps until their claims are assessed by U.N. High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) and Australian officials.

Since then, the Australian navy has intercepted more boats, and one has sunk in the high seas with the loss of many lives. None of those rescued were allowed to set foot in Australia.

Most have been flown to Nauru and PNG, while some have been based in the Australian territory of Christmas Island. In September, as the refugee issue became a subject of national debate, the Australian government passed legislation declaring those who arrive in Christmas Island ineligible to apply for asylum as “on-shore” applicants.

But in recent weeks, waves of objections have been rising over the continuation of a policy that some call plain bribery of more and more smaller countries – from Tuvalu to Palau — that Australia has been asking to take in asylum seekers it intercepts.

Meantime, Australia’s immigration minister Philip Ruddock, who had taken a tough policy, also appears ready to concede that there may be a need to change this if it does not stem the tide of asylum seekers.

In the end, Max Lane, chairman of the newly formed Action Solidarity with Asia Pacific (ASAP), argues: “If the Australian government really values these neighbours of ours, it would not be insisting on and bribing them to do things that it is not prepared to do.”

“The reality is that none of the rich countries want to solve this (asylum seekers) problem,” he adds. “No rich country takes more than they can avoid. Putting more and more refugees into prison camps in the Pacific Islands is telling those countries to take them permanently.”

“Even after they (UNHCR) declares them refugees, many will not find countries that will take them,” he explains.

Last month, Tuvalu and Fiji rejected requests by Australia take in these ‘boat people’, and Kiribati and Palau are believed to be still considering Canberra’s request.

There are 700 asylum seekers housed in Nauru, 216 in PNG and another 540 in Christmas Island. New Zealand took 150 of the asylum seekers from the ‘Tampa’ but is not willing to take any more.

On Nov. 23, Fiji rejected a proposal to house up to 1,000 asylum seekers after opposition from local politicians and paramount chiefs.

Australia has allocated 75 million U.S. dollars to the ‘Pacific Solution’ policy, describing it as a “burden sharing” exercise to a regional problem.

In late August, when the ‘Tampa’ crisis began, Australia offered cash-strapped Nauru 10 million dollars in financial assistance — a 20 percent boost to the GDP of the tiny island of 11,000 people.

Nauru was also offered 5 million dollars worth of diesel fuel to end its chronic power blackouts. PNG, which receives more than 150 million dollars of Australian aid each year, was offered a further 10 million dollars to take in the 216 people and it was followed up in October by a request to take in another 1,000 asylum seekers.

The tough policy on asylum seekers had been a major factor in this month’s re-election of Prime Minister Howard, but Ruddock himself is now expressing doubts about his Pacific solution. In comments to media last week, he for the first time admitted misgivings about it.

“In relation to the Pacific solution, if we continue to see reduced numbers of arrivals, I suspect it will be perfectly manageable,” he told the ‘Sydney Morning Herald’. But he added: “If you saw a very marked increase in arrivals, one would have to change one’s approach according to those changed circumstances.”

The Howard government’s policy also came in for stringent criticism from most speakers at an international refugee conference here last week.

“The asylum seekers are traumatised by the events and many show clear signs of vulnerability. It is often difficult to interview them,” said John Pace, director of the Australian Human Rights Centre at the University of New South Wales.

He recently visited refugee camps in Nauru to interview asylum seekers and wrote a report for the international rights group Amnesty International (AI).

Pace added that clear signs of traumatic disorders have been observed among the asylum seekers, such as nervousness, anxiety, aggressive attitude, muteness, distrust, withdrawal, lack of focus and concentration, frequent shivering of hands during interviews and outbursts of crying.

In the AI report, Pace argues that in situations where post- traumatic stress disorders are evident, it may not be appropriate to perform refugee status determinations.

For its part, the UNHCR has confirmed that very few countries are opening their doors to the asylum seekers. Officials say the only other country interested in taking refugees from the Pacific camps is Ireland. But it would take only 50, which is less than 5 percent of those awaiting assessment in Nauru and PNG.

“A substantial proportion of these (people) are in need of protection and would be granted refugee status. This means Australia would be under pressure to take them”, says Michael Gabaudan, the UNHCR’s regional representative for Australia and the South Pacific.

Australia’s policy is expected to come in for strong criticism in Geneva this week, when the 142 nations which signed the 1951 U.N. Convention on Refugees gather to celebrate its 50th anniversary.

Ironically, Australia, one of the first countries to sign it, would be singled out for criticism for trying to undermine the convention. At the meeting, UNHCR is expected to push for “core reception standards” for asylum seekers.

To protect the country’s self-proclaimed claim to be a compassionate nation promoting human rights, Australia may be forced to concede that Howard’s promise to the electorate in November of absolute control over Australia’s borders may not be possible.

Howard himself may be clearing the ground for a backdown. In a marked departure from his election campaign rhetoric, he said in a Melbourne radio interview last week that turning asylum seekers’ boats back to sea was “completely inhuman”.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags