Environment, Headlines, North America

ENVIRONMENT: U.S. Majority Seen to Shun Administration Energy Plan

Danielle Knight

WASHINGTON, Jan 26 2002 (IPS) - The U.S. administration and public are at odds over the core elements of energy policy, according to an opinion poll that is fuelling debate in Congress.

Most people in the United States prefer to achieve energy security by increasing efficiency and developing alternative energy sources rather than by increasing the supply of oil, the Mellman Group, a prominent Democratic polling firm, has found.

The administration of President George W. Bush, lawmakers from his Republican party, and some labour unions, have cast the president’s energy legislation – which encourages oil drilling in pristine areas and the construction of coal-fired power plants – as important to domestic security.

Bush has said his plan would reduce U.S. reliance on Middle East oil. The United States imports 60 percent of its daily oil consumption, up from 47 percent a decade ago.

According to Mellman, however, 71 percent of people polled do not buy the president’s argument. Only one in five voters say increased production is the best way to solve the nation’s energy problems. About 19 percent believe drilling for more oil and gas in the United States would increase energy supply, while 2 percent supported getting more oil from oil-producing allies.

A 63 percent majority of voters also rejected Bush’s argument that drilling in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge would enhance national security, oil independence and jobs. A near majority of 47 percent “strongly oppose” drilling in the Arctic. In comparison, 31 percent favour drilling in the refuge and 20 percent “strongly favour” it.

When asked if drilling for oil in the refuge would create more jobs, more than two-thirds (69 percent) say development of alternative energy would lead to more jobs. Only 18 percent polled believe drilling in the Arctic refuge would generate more jobs than investing in cleaner renewable energy.

Contrary to some official union statements about support for drilling in the refuge, 69 percent of households with people belonging to labour unions say they agree more with the alternative energy technologies message than they did with the administration’s pro-drilling argument.

Generally aligned with congressional Democrats, unions are split over their support of Bush’s energy plan and drilling in the refuge. While the International Brotherhood of Teamsters strongly supports drilling, the United Steelworkers of America and the Service Employees International Union (SEIU) have aligned themselves with environmentalists who oppose opening up the refuge.

The new poll results are being used to the advantage of Congressional Democrats who oppose Bush’s plan. In early August, the Republican-controlled House of Representatives approved a broad energy bill that would allow some oil drilling in the refuge.

Bush’s measure must still pass through the Senate, where the balance of power between Democrats and Republicans is delicate. Congressional aids expect the bill to be considered by lawmakers in mid-February.

Conservationists have warned that the Bush strategy would exacerbate global warming by encouraging the burning of fossil fuels and consequent release of heat-trapping greenhouse gases, including carbon dioxide.

Congressional Democrats believe that industry campaign contributions to Bush shaped administration energy policy in a way that is biased in favour of the fossil fuel industry. The lawmakers have been calling for the release of White House records detailing the development of Bush’s energy policy.

The administration has refused for the past nine months to provide meeting records of the White House energy task force, which was chaired by Vice President Dick Cheney and produced Bush’s energy policy.

Before terrorist attacks last Sep. 11, the U.S. General Accounting Office (GAO) had been poised to sue after Cheney’s office argued it was entitled to keep the name of the energy task force members private. The GAO has said it will decide in coming weeks whether it will take the administration to court.

Lawmakers speculate that the task force probe could merge with congressional investigations into the bankruptcy of Enron, the energy company that was part of the administration’s task force.

Democratic lawmakers, meanwhile, are pressing their own energy proposals that focus on investments in alternative technologies, including fuel cells, and renewable energy sources like wind, biomass, and solar power.

Senate Majority Leader, Tom Daschle, a Democrat, is proposing a bill that would boost efforts to reduce U.S. dependence on oil imports, moving toward conservation and renewable sources and protecting the unique Arctic refuge and other sensitive public lands.

“Senator Daschle’s bill could make dramatic, positive changes in this country’s energy future,” says Rodger Schlickeisen, president of Defenders of Wildlife, a Washington-based environmental group.

On Thursday, Richard Gephardt, the House Democrat leader, called on lawmakers to launch an “Apollo Project,” that would develop “environmentally smart, renewable energy solutions to make our nation energy independent by the end of the decade.”

The goal, argues Gephardt, who was addressing the Democratic Leadership Council, would be to reduce dependence on foreign oil, create growth in the energy sector of the economy, and create new energy sources that protect the environment.

Under the proposed project, the United States would expand its production of alternative fuel-cell vehicles to 2.5 million by 2020. Using tax credits, and spending on research and development, the plan would require that 20 percent of energy consumed in the United States would be derived by alternative and renewable sources of energy.

“It’s easy to get bogged down in the day-to-day details of the current debate that we never lift our eyes and look ahead to the decade – about how we want our country to look, not just in one year, but in ten years,” said Gephardt.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags