Friday, November 20, 2026
Thalif Deen
- U.N. Secretary-General Kofi Annan warned member states Friday not to accept any “trade-off” between the fight against terrorism and the protection of human rights. Meanwhile, diplomats and rights officials kept up their tug-o’-war on the subject.
“I believe that in the long term, we shall find that human rights, along with democracy and social justice, are one of the best prophylactics against terrorism,” Annan told the Security Council.
Annan’s warning followed reports that several of the new anti- terrorism measures introduced in countries including Britain, Canada, Germany, and the United States violate or enable violations of human rights and the rule of law.
These include detention of non-citizens, tightening of immigration laws, electronic surveillance without court order, deportation of those overstaying their visas, and monitoring of mail and communications between prisoners and their attorneys.
Annan refused to identify countries by name but said the anti- terrorism measures now being adopted by some countries should “not unduly curtail human rights or give others a pretext to do so.”
Last week, Human Rights Watch (HRW) said the U.S.-led anti- terrorist campaign “is inspiring opportunistic attacks on civil liberties around the world.”
Some countries such as Russia, Uzbekistan and Egypt, are using the war against terrorism to justify abusive military campaigns or crackdowns on domestic political opponents, it said.
“In the U.S. and Western Europe, measures designed to combat terrorism are threatening long-held human rights principles,” HRW said.
Wally Bacre Ndiaye, director of the New York Office of the U.N. High Commissioner for Human Rights, says there is evidence that some governments are now introducing measures that may erode core human rights safeguards.
Last October, the Security Council unanimously adopted a resolution calling on member states to provide the Council with written reports on measures they plan to take to fight terrorism within their territorial borders.
Ndiaye warned that the misapplication of this resolution could lead to unwarranted infringements on civil liberties.
“In some countries, non-violent activities have been considered as terrorism, and excessive measures have been taken to suppress or restrict individual rights, including the presumption of innocence, the right to a fair trial, freedom from torture, privacy rights, freedom of expression and assembly, and the right to seek asylum.”
British Ambassador Jeremy Greenstock, chairman of the U.N.’s Counter-Terrorism Committee (CTC), told the Security Council Friday that 133 members had submitted reports to the CTC in conformity with the Council resolution.
“This is a welcome response, which demonstrates the excellent cooperation we have received. But there remain some who have not yet submitted a report. Please encourage your governments to do so soon because your action will be of direct benefit to the international community as we pursue our shared goal,” he added.
Asked about the possibility that some states might use the CTC to try to repress groups they did not like, Greenstock told reporters last week that other U.N. bodies would have to monitor the way states handled the process in a human rights context.
All countries, he said, would have to make legislative and other changes in their fight against terrorism. The United States, for example, would have to look at the way it has allowed groups to collect money for the Irish Republican Army (IRA).
Since Washington has threatened to retaliate against countries providing safe haven to terrorist groups and terrorist fund- raisers, Noam Chomksy, a professor at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, said last month that President George W. Bush should start by bombing the U.S. city of Boston, which is home to a large Irish community known to collect funds for the IRA.
U.S. Ambassador James Cunningham told the Security Council that after Sep.11, inadequate counter-terrorist programmes and infrastructures must not be tolerated.
“The U.S. has been gratified by the roll-up-your-sleeves spirit of the Counter-Terrorism Committee members, and U.N. members broadly. We are all tackling the difficult but essential job of analysing our anti-terrorism capabilities and identifying areas for improvement,” he said.
In its report to the Council, the U.S. says that every visa applicant, with very few exceptions, is subject to a name check through a database containing nearly six million records. Those subject to such checks are mostly from Arab or Islamic nations, including Egypt, Yemen, Algeria, Malaysia, Morocco, Syria, Libya and Jordan.
The report from Egypt says that it was a “pioneer among the countries of the world in adopting numerous stringent legal and security measures to abort the activities of terrorist organisations at home and abroad and destroy their organisational structure.”
Greenstock said the CTC will review and assess the reports submitted by member states during the next 90 days.
The CTC will write, in confidence, to the government concerned offering its comments. They may be a request for more information, or for clarification, he added.
“The CTC is not a tribunal for judging States. It will not trespass onto areas of competence of other parts of the U.N. system. It is not going to define terrorism in a legal sense, although we will have a fair idea of what is blatant terrorism; where necessary, we will decide by consensus whether an act is terrrorism. But it has no plans to issue lists of terrorist organisations”, Greenstock said.