Europe, Headlines, Human Rights

/CORRECTED/ RIGHTS-CZECH REPUBLIC: Public May Gain Full Access to Secret Files

Brian Kenety

PRAGUE, Feb 13 2002 (IPS) - Ordinary citizens will be allowed almost complete access to the vast archives of the StB, the former Czechoslovak secret police, under a bill expected to sail through the upper house of the Czech parliament next month.

Nearly twelve years after the ‘Velvet revolution’ led to the fall of communism and nine years after Czechoslovakia split into the Czech Republic and Slovakia, debate over how to handle access to the StB dossiers, and whether to fully disclose their contents, is close to an end.

While many former political dissidents want the files made public, others are concerned the dossiers might contain deliberately false information, which could harm the reputations of innocent people.

Jiri Dienstbier, a former political dissident under the Communist regime who went on to become Czechoslovak Foreign Minister, believes that releasing the StB files could potentially do more harm than good.

“In all the files – and I have spoken with many people who read their files – there is not only information. There are lots of lies, lots of inventions of people who collaborated with the secret police and because they had nothing to report on, they just invented their stories,” Dienstbier told Czech Radio this week.

Currently, a person may only view his or her personal secret police file and references to third persons are blacked out, or otherwise censored.

To date only about 60,000 personal files – half of what is believed to have escaped the post-1989 shredding frenzy by former state security agents and functionaries – have been made available to alleged collaborators and their victims.

The bill that cleared the lower house of parliament last week, based on a draft by centre-right politicians in the Senate, or upper house, would permit adult citizens to file written requests to view almost any StB file, including comprehensive lists of agents and alleged collaborators.

“If the files are accessible to everybody, people will not learn the truth, but they will learn nonsense, and it will be the final victory of the defeated secret police,” said Dienstbier.

The former Czechoslovakia’s communist regime tried and convicted some 280,000 people on political charges, forcibly confined around 7,000 in mental institutions, executed more than 230 persons and sent tens of thousands to labour camps or denied them the chance to higher education.

Collaborators were often blackmailed or otherwise forced into working for the secret police. The StB also had quotas to fill, and names of collaborators were often falsified, warns a member of the Bureau for the Documentation and Investigation of Communist Crimes (UDV).

“There is an inherent danger in taking the dossiers at face value. We should never forget who compiled them,” said the official.

Although accusations fly, few high-ranking StB or Communist Party officials have been prosecuted for their alleged crimes.

However, on Monday, two former rank-and-file StB members each received suspended sentences of three years in jail for employing physical and psychological torture during the ‘Asanance’ (Slum Clearance) operation which ran from 1977 to 1985, the main goal of which was to intimidate signatories of the anti-Communist human rights manifesto, Charter 77, into leaving the country.

“The early years of Asanance were almost unbearable,” Petruska Sustrova, a Charter 77 signatory told IPS.

“After the Solidarity movement began in Poland and the declaration of martial law in 1981, the repression here eased up, but I was still followed by StB agents everywhere and ‘invited’ to their headquarters for interviews, some of which lasted for 48 hours at a time.”

Sustrova, now an author and political commentator, said her own secret police file had probably been destroyed in the first weeks of December 1989, along with tens of thousands of others.

“My only concern about the new law is that it is not possible for foreigners to view their files. Many of them put themselves at great risk to help us (Czechoslovaks),” said Sustrova, who said she had herself considered emigrating due to the pressure under Asanance.

Those who left Czechoslovakia due to secret police harassment include Karol Sidon, who became chief rabbi for the Czech Republic after the 1989 end of Communism. Others, like writer Pavel Kohout, were stripped of their citizenship and not allowed back into the country upon returning from trips abroad.

The issue of the secret police files returned to the forefront of political debate this week.

A trial of three former Czechoslovak Interior Ministry officials and secret police members accused of masterminding the Asanance campaign ended Tuesday, with the men found guilty of intimidating and torturing dissidents.

On Monday, a Prague district court found 48-year old Jiri Simak, who now owns a hotel in Prague, guilty of strangling a political dissident with a wet towel, knowing that his victim had heart problems Prosecutors argued that Simak’s colleague, Zbynek Dudek, beat the same man and poured ice-cold water on his head, probably to induce a heart attack. Both received three-year sentences.

Collaboration with the StB was a particularly sensitive topic shortly after the 1989 anti-communist revolution when unofficial lists of alleged police agents were released.

In 1992, in the absence of any relevant comprehensive law, one former dissident published a list of 160,000 names he had received on floppy disks from a source close to the StB. The names were published in a crude tabloid called ‘Rude Kravo’ (Red Cow), a take-off on the Communist-era newspaper Rude Pravo (Red Truth).

Petr Cibulka is still compiling and publishing lists containing personal information on nearly 200,000 alleged StB collaborators and officers, now in a bi-weekly paper, ‘The Uncensored News,’ distributed on his Internet site .

The bill passed by the lower house of parliament would make it easier to confirm or refute the information Cibulka and others have been distributing.

“It’s important for the health of society to know … what kind of people have political and economic power in this country today,” said Cibulka in a recent interview.

The ruling Social Democratic Party’s (CSSD) vote on the bill was split, with party chairman Vladimir Spidla voting against and Prime Minister Milos Zeman absent when the vote was taken Friday.

The bill, sponsored by the centre-right Civic Democratic Party (ODS), was adopted by 102 votes against 53 in the 200-seat chamber. Twenty deputies abstained from the vote and 27 were absent.

Only the Communist Party (KCCM) and some CSSD members of parliament voted against it.

To become a law, the bill must be adopted by both the Senate and President Vaclav Havel, a former playwright who was hounded by StB agents during the time of Asanance, but did not flee the country.

While CSSD Deputy Premier Pavel Rychetsky interpreted the law as giving access only to those on whom files were kept by the StB, centre- right Civic Democratic Party (ODS) parliamentary deputy Marek Benda said the bill would allow free access to the files to any person aged 18 and over.

Files on foreign nationals as well as files whose content is deemed a possible threat to national security or human life will remain classified.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags