Economy & Trade, Headlines, North America

ECONOMY-CANADA: Commission Urges Corporate Responsibility

Tavia Grant

TORONTO, Feb 27 2002 (IPS) - While the spectacular collapse of Enron Corp. is raising eyebrows across North America about financial accountability, a just published study recommends that corporate Canada become more socially and environmentally responsible.

Stock exchanges should make companies disclose their social responsibility practices, business schools should teach corporate responsibility and all clothes sold in the country should be tagged with their factory and country of origin, says the report by the Canadian Democracy and Corporate Accountability Commission.

The report makes 24 recommendations, many of them with an eye to the operations of Canadian firms overseas, says commission co-chair Ed Broadbent, in an interview.

“It’s abundantly clear that a number of people have not behaved properly overseas and many executives told us that in private hearings. The reason they said they didn’t is competitive pressure.

“Far from the market aiming them in the right direction, the market may be holding things back, especially in places where there are no human rights regulations, where companies can do what they want. Therefore, a ‘good’ company is at a competitive disadvantage. A company that wants to do the right thing can’t,” adds Broadbent.

During cross-country hearings last year, the commission found that Canadians also want more accountability. In January, it released a poll showing that 72 percent of people think businesses should pursue social responsibilities as well as profits.

Three-quarters of Canadian shareholders agreed that “business executives should expand their responsibilities to embrace a broader social ethic.” And more than half of shareholders said they prefer pension funds that invest in firms with ethical practices, rather than in funds than simply seek the highest returns.

Canadians have a vested interest in how their corporations behave. About one-half of them own stocks via pensions and direct investments.

“If the government acted on these recommendations, they’d have a wide support from Canadians and Canadian shareholders,” says Broadbent. “If these changes were made, then the globalisation concerns that many Canadians have would be considerably reduced.”

But a business spokesman says, left alone, companies are getting better at regulating their behaviour. “With the ability of people to get access to information and to share that information world-wide, markets are working better than ever to put limits on acceptable behaviour,” says David Stewart-Patterson, senior vice-president at the Canadian Council of Chief Executives.

“If a Canadian company does business in 83 countries and it does something in even one of those countries which violates somebody’s standards, knowledge of that alleged violation will make its way pretty fast back to investors,” adds Stewart-Patterson, whose Ottawa-based organisation comprises CEOs from Canada’s largest corporations.

He is not suggesting that free markets can prevent all bad behaviour, but he disagrees with the notion that government should be trusted more than business to regulate behaviour.

Above all, following an ethical standard simply makes good business sense, argues Stewart-Patterson. “When a company is engaged in ‘risky’ behaviour, whether it’s related to human rights or the environment, those activities can hardly be done in secret. Knowledge spreads rapidly and globally. That knowledge then affects the perception of risk to consumers and investors and that risk has an immediate impact on the stock price.”

Broadbent says markets cannot be left to regulate themselves. “Just because 90 percent of Canadians normally drive on the right side of the road, we’d never suggest you don’t need a law telling us which side to drive on.”

One of the greatest challenges for monitoring corporate behaviour lies in overseas operations. Canada’s economy is heavily resource based and Canadian companies have extensive mining, oil and gas operations around the world.

For example, in 1996 Canadian companies had interests in more than 8300 mineral properties world-wide, including the largest share of exploitation activities in Latin America, according to the Toronto-based group Probe International.

The commission says that part of the answer lies in attaching incentives to ethical behaviour. Companies that implement ethical policies should receive government grants and be invited on trade missions, while companies that don’t should be excluded, the commission says.

The commission’s report deliberately avoids naming specific corporations that have engaged in unethical behaviour. It does, however, praise efforts by oil company Shell Canada Ltd., aluminium firm Alcan Inc. and British-based The Body Shop to raise their ethical standards.

The commission has presented its report to various ministers in the federal government and hopes the study will influence changes to the Canada Business Corporations Act.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags