Thursday, November 19, 2026
Abid Aslam
- President George W. Bush drew fire from environmentalists Thursday after unveiling a homespun alternative to the international community’s plan to curb emissions of greenhouse gases blamed for global warming.
The Bush plan, much of which must be approved by Congress before it can be implemented, proposes goals for businesses to reduce their output of gases like carbon dioxide, which is emitted by motor vehicles, power plants, and industries that burn fossil fuels such as coal. By contrast, the 1997 Kyoto Protocol, endorsed by some 170 countries, insists on mandatory reductions.
Philip Clapp, president of the National Environmental Trust, took a swipe at Bush’s voluntary plan as “another faith-based initiative”, a reference to the U.S. leader’s penchant for letting churches, rather than the government, tackle social problems.
In this case, said Clapp, “we should have faith that major corporations will line up to volunteer cuts in their carbon pollution. That approach has failed for a decade now, since the president’s father set up the first voluntary programme. There is no reason to believe polluters are suddenly going to see the light.”
Bush, however, said his plan contained the most significant measures Washington had ever taken to cut emissions and would yield an 18 percent reduction in greenhouse gas intensity over the next decade.
“Greenhouse gas intensity” refers not to emissions as such, however, but to the ratio of emissions to U.S. gross domestic product. If the latter outpaces the former, the ratio will appear smaller even if emissions grow.
Thus, between 1990 and 2000, U.S. greenhouse gas emissions actually rose by 14 percent while greenhouse gas intensity fell by 17.4 percent, according to Friends of the Earth International.
“The administration plans to increase U.S. emissions by at least an additional 12 percent in the next 10 years,” said Chris Flavin, president of the Worldwatch Institute, a Washington think tank.
“This will leave the United States producing at least 35 percent more greenhouse gases in 2010 than would be permitted under the Kyoto Protocol,” he added. The Kyoto pact would require Washington to cut national emissions to around seven percent below 1990 levels within a decade.
Bush on Thursday reiterated his rejection of the Kyoto Protocol, approved by former President Bill Clinton but not ratified by the Senate, as threatening millions of U.S. jobs while exempting major industrialising nations like China and India.
The two Asian giants “already account for a majority of the world’s greenhouse gas emissions,” Bush said.
Flavin, however, countered that the United States is the leading emitter of greenhouse gases, accounting for fully one-fourth of the global total. Environmental researchers and advocates here also have said that China, contrary to Washington’s assertions, is making progress in reducing emissions and promoting cleaner industrial and energy technologies.
At the heart of Bush’s plan is a ‘cap and trade’ system that would set limits for emissions of three major air pollutants, but not carbon dioxide. Permits would be assigned for each ton of pollution. By cutting emissions, firms would save up these permits for use at a later date or to trade with other businesses.
Emissions covered by the scheme would be sulfur dioxide, blamed for acid rain; nitrogen oxides, found in smog; and mercury, a pernicious pollutant tied to a host of environmental and health problems.
The proposals also include tax and other incentives for research and development (R&D) and to encourage companies to adopt cleaner technologies.
This is a welcome start but “the administration is pushing off the hard decisions for another 10 years,” said Ray Kopp, a climate change expert at non-governmental Resources for the Future and a member of the U.S. State Department’s Advisory Committee on International Economic Policy. “In time, we are going to have to act more decisively to further slow the growth in greenhouse gas emissions if we really want to protect the global climate. Voluntary trading programs and R&D incentives only take us so far.”
Critics also scored Bush’s plan as pro-business but even some energy producers said it would be better to introduce mandatory measures sooner rather than later so businesses can factor them into investment decisions.
“The United States is policy-wise headed in one direction and the rest of the industrialised world is clearly headed in another direction,” Michael Bradley, spokesman for the Clean Energy Group, was quoted as saying by Reuters. “We think it’s inevitable that a similar programme will emerge here in the United States.”
The Clean Energy Group says it represents nine energy companies with 80 million customers.