Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines, Human Rights, Population

NEPAL: Key Bill on Women’s Rights Passed, Critics Not Satisfied

Suman Pradhan

KATHMANDU, Mar 15 2002 (IPS) - Nepal’s women won an important victory this week when parliament passed a revolutionary bill granting them rights to parental property and allowing them conditional rights to abortion, but activists say the measure does not go far enough.

The House of Representatives, Nepal’s Lower House of parliament, adopted the bill on Thursday with an overwhelming majority. The bill will be the law of the land once King Gyanendra, the constitutional monarch, grants his seal of approval shortly, a mere formality.

Called the Bill to Amend the Civil Code, the legislation for the first time provides conditional rights to abortion for women. More significantly, it also establishes for the first time a daughter’s rights to parental property, hitherto only granted to sons by the decades-old and discriminatory Civil Code.

But women’s rights groups say that lawmakers failed to go as far as they had wanted.

“We welcome the passage of the bill,” said Dr Shanta Thapaliya, a lawyer and women’s rights activist. “But it still has many loopholesàlike it requires daughters to return property once they are married which is not fair. We will still continue our fight for equality.”

Activists are angry that the bill, while establishing property rights for daughters from birth itself, takes away that right once they are married.

According to traditional Hindu beliefs enshrined in the old Civil Code, daughters had to wait until the age of 35, and that too without getting married, to win their share of parental property. The property had to be returned to her brothers once she married.

The new amendment does away with the 35 year age bar in favour of rights to property from birth itself, but still requires daughters to return such property to her brothers once she is married.

The government says that is only fair because a daughter, once married, has equal rights to her husband’s property and wealth, according to prevailing laws. “Getting to keep her share of parental property would amount to ‘double benefit’ for daughters,” argues a government attorney who did not want to be named.

But this kind of thinking angers women’s groups. “This still shows that government thinking, and also political parties, are still discriminatory against women in general,” argues Sapana Pradhan Malla, a well known activist. “They want to be modern, but cannot take the needed steps out of political expediency.”

Indeed, the issue of property rights for women has been an intensely controversial one in Nepal, a impoverished and deeply patriarchial society steeped in conservative Hindu customs and beliefs. When the bill was first drafted six years ago, lawmakers within the ruling Nepali Congress party opposed it with gusto.

At the time, Congress lawmaker Jaya Prakash Gupta, who is a Cabinet minister at the moment, told parliament during debate that granting such rights to women “would disrupt the social make-up of society.”

Conservative Hindus in large numbers rallied against the bill, arguing that the provisions would poison the relationship between brothers and sisters.

On the other hand, communist groups, who wanted more liberal provisions in the bill, was opposed to the legislation on grounds that it was not radical enough.

Despite the debate around it, the bill cleared the Lower House last year, but was voted out in the Upper House after communist lawmakers opposed it. They sent it back to the Lower House with suggestions to make the bill more radical.

One year later, that is on Thursday, the bill finally cleared the Lower House for the second time. During voting yesterday, the communists also supported the bill though it was not as far-reaching as they initially wanted.

Analysts here feel that the opposition communists decided to throw in the towel after realising that “something is better than nothing at the moment”.

One day after the passage of the controversial bill, the conservatives have not reacted, and media comments so far have been positive. “A historic decision,” blared ‘The Kathmandu Post’ newspaper.

The other provision of the bill, that of abortion, has been no less controversial. In Nepal, abortion is illegal in any circumstances, and women convicted of abortion-related crimes are invariably charged with murder, often ending up in prison on 20-year sentences.

But the recently passed bill ensures that women can now have abortions under certain conditions.

According to the bill, foetuses of up to 12 weeks can be aborted legally with the consent of the husband. Foetuses of up to 18 weeks can also be aborted if the conception was due to rape or an incestuous relationship. Besides, doctors can abort a foetus irrespective of its term, if they determine that the woman’s life is in danger due to the pregnancy.

The provisions are a far cry from established norms in Nepal, and is truly historic, say many analysts and activists.

“So many women die prematurely because they have to seek unsafe abortion due to fear of getting caught,” says Malla, the activist. “At least now, women will come out of the closet and seek legal medical attention. But like everything else, it all depends on how the legislation is implemented and enforced.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags