Thursday, November 19, 2026
Ed Holt
- The Slovak government has lost the support of many NGOs within days of the election of a former communist as the country’s first ombudsman.
The election in parliament of an independent human rights watchdog March 19 gave Slovakia an institution almost all western states have. It was expected to be greeted as a major step forward in defending the rights of citizens. But the election of Pavel Kandrac, an active member of the communist party between 1971 and 1989, has left many NGOs unwilling now to work with the government.
Kandrac, proposed by the opposition HZDS (Movement for a Democratic Slovakia) party, was supported by 68 MPs. Coalition government candidate Jan Hrubala, a lawyer who has worked on human rights got 46 votes. The vote had been expected to go in favour of Hrubala, who was backed by 260 NGOs.
It emerged after the surprise result from the secret ballot that some MPs from the SDL (Party of the Democratic Left), the former communist party that is a member of the ruling coalition, had voted with the opposition. That
broke an agreement among coalition parties on cross-party cooperation made at the formation of the government three-and-a-half years ago.
“This involved political interests and we can no longer talk of cooperation between the third sector and the government,” says Luba Blaskovicova, spokesperson for the Third Sector Gremium, an umbrella grouping of NGOs. “The third sector was convinced that the government would keep its promises, and Jan Hrubala was one of them.”
Miroslav Kusy, president of the human rights group Slovak Helsinki Committee says “this is the biggest debacle of the government’s four year term.” The decision is unacceptable “and the consequences of this will be absolutely dreadful,” he says.
Slovakia is the last country in central Europe to get an ombudsman. Kandrac, elected for a five-year term, can report to parliament on its performance, file complaints, or initiate prosecution in cases where he believes human rights are violated. He will have the power to submit evidence and access confidential data.
But Kandrac’s credentials in defending citizen rights are being questioned by NGOs concerned with his links to a party he had until recently represented as MP.
The HZDS party, of which Kandrac was a member, was led by the authoritarian Vladimir Meciar in government between 1994 and 1998. The Meciar government became a pariah in Europe over suspected human rights violations.
The secret service in the Meciar government had been directed to carry out a covert campaign to discredit other countries’ attempts to join NATO. Following concerns over Meciar’s rule, Slovakia was not invited to join NATO at the 1997 Madrid summit, nor was it invited to open negotiations on joining the EU that year.
The HZDS government had opposed the creation of an ombudsman, and Kandrac himself said months before his election now that he saw no need for an ombudsman.
“This man was a very active communist, he had never worked in human rights at all, and the HZDS, which has not proved itself on human rights
issues, has never supported the institution of an ombudsman,” says Kusy. “This will massively damage Slovakia’s image abroad.”
Foreign diplomats have been reserved in their reactions to the appointment. U.S. Ambassador to Slovakia Ronald Weiser says the election is an internal affair, but “we will follow the effectiveness of his work very closely.” The European Commission delegation in Slovak capital Bratislava said merely that it welcomed the appointment of an ombudsman.
But the HZDS says its candidate will do well in his post. In the parliamentary debate before the vote, HZDS members expressed doubts on Hrubala’s willingness to defend the rights of former communist party members.
Kandrac said immediately after the vote that he would work to restore
respect for the law. “With the help of my colleagues, the media and other institutions I will carry out the office of ombudsman in accordance with the law and my conscience,” he said.
But NGO representatives remain sceptical. “We do not support Pavel Kandrac as ombudsman and have concerns about how the ombudsman institution will turn out,” says Sarlota Pufflerova of the Citizen and Democracy Foundation. “A lot depends on the type of person building the institution from the start.”