Thursday, November 19, 2026
Danielle Knight
- A key international climate body risks being hobbled in its work following the controversial ouster of its chairperson, say scientists.
The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) has provided assessments of climate change that have helped shape international treaties including the Kyoto Protocol, which calls for cuts in emissions of heat-trapping greenhouse gases.
Robert Watson, the U.S. scientist who chaired the panel, was removed last week. Critics say the body’s integrity was jeopardised by the manner in which Watson was ousted and because the atmospheric chemist was replaced by an economist.
Critics claim that the George W. Bush administration launched a campaign against Watson in favour of Indian economist Rajendra Pachauri, on behalf of ExxonMobil, the world’s largest oil company. The White House and ExxonMobil have denied the allegation.
In a ballot last week, with one vote per country, Pachauri, currently one of five vice chairpersons of the panel, won 76 votes to Watson’s 49.
Scientists and environmentalists criticised Pachauri’s appointment, arguing an economist cannot adequately chair a scientific panel.
“My concern is that it will be far more difficult to attract the very best scientists into this endeavour if we do not believe that we have the same calibre of leadership at the top,” said James McCarthy, scientist and co-chair of one of the IPCC’s working groups.
“I’m obviously extremely disappointed,” Watson said. “But my job now is to maintain the integrity of the IPCC.”
Chief scientist at the World Bank, Watson has been outspoken about how fossil fuel emissions contribute to worldwide climatic disruptions including droughts, floods, and storms.
Under Watson, the panel has released several assessments that industry groups and some scientists have assailed as overly dire. Many experts, including a global warming panel convened by the U.S. National Academy of Sciences, have endorsed the panel’s scientific and economic findings, however.
Ironically, Pachauri and some of his activist critics appear to share much in common, including opposition to emissions trading and other market-based approaches to dealing with climate change.
For their part, scientists interviewed by IPS said they had no serious disagreement with the Indian on substantive questions. Rather, his lack of scientific credentials appeared to be the main issue. Pachauri heads India’s Tata Energy Research Institute.
The IPCC chairperson has always been chosen by consensus but this year the position was put to a vote after the issue had become politicised.
“We’ve passed into a new era of the IPCC which I think will be very challenging for our colleague Pachauri because he doesn’t have the full support of all the delegates,” said McCarthy.
Ross Gelbspan, author of several books on climate change, said the Bush administration sold the idea of choosing Pachauri by telling developing countries that it was opening some leadership space for them since Pachauri is from India.
“The administration did something very clever,” said Gelbspan, “In one stroke, the White House jeopardised the scientific integrity of the IPCC and it attempted to gain some favour from the developing world.”
William Moomaw, professor of international environmental policy at Tufts University and lead author of the IPCC report on emissions reductions, said the administration’s backing of Pachauri might actually backfire because in the past he has been quite outspoken against the U.S. approach to climate change and energy policy.
“I am not a toadie of the U.S.,” Pachauri told Science magazine earlier this month. “I was very critical of the U.S.” for opposing the Kyoto Protocol.
“I’m not sure the U.S. is entirely sure of what is has wrought,” said Moomaw.
Environmentalists said the manoeuvres demonstrate industry’s power over the administration.
“Oil and gas interests had too much to say in the removal of Dr. Watson as chairman of what should be an impartial, scientific body,” said Jennifer Morgan, director of the World Wildlife Fund’s climate programme.
The Natural Resources Defence Council, a Washington-based advocacy group, said the White House’s Council on Environmental Quality received a letter in February 2001 from Arthur Randol III, senior environmental adviser for ExxonMobil, who asked: “Can Watson be replaced now, at the request of the U.S.?”
The memo, which the group said it obtained through the Freedom of Information Act, also recommended that the administration “restructure the U.S. attendance at upcoming IPCC meetings to assure none of the Clinton/Gore proponents are involved in any decisional activities.”
The White House said the letter had no bearing on decisions about the panel.
“We’ve never taken any kind of public or private position on the subject of Dr. Watson or the leadership of the IPCC,” said ExxonMobil spokesperson Tom Cirigliano.
Environmental activists said they remained unconvinced because ExxonMobil denies the existence of human-induced global warming despite global scientific consensus that the burning of oil, gas and coal releases heat-trapping emissions that cause climate change.
ExxonMobil is prominent in the industry-backed Global Climate Coalition (GCC), which launched a 13-million-dollar advertising campaign in 1997 that painted politicians who voted in favour of the Kyoto treaty as harming U.S. consumers and businesses.
Other energy companies, including Royal Dutch/Shell and British Petroleum, have left the GCC, acknowledged the dangers of global warming, and begun working to reduce emissions.