Thursday, November 19, 2026
Danielle Knight
- For more than 20 years, tens of thousands of metric tons of high-level radioactive waste from commercial nuclear energy plants and government weapons facilities in the United States have been searching for a permanent home.
In Washington this week, lawmakers have been arguing over whether the waste stored now in temporary concrete-encased pools at more than 130 nuclear plants and military sites should be sent to Yucca Mountain, a remote and sparsely populated location in the south-western state of Nevada.
Similar quandaries confront decision-makers in Russia, South Africa, South Korea and other countries that have proposed the construction of new nuclear power facilities.
The nuclear power industry has long supported burying the waste at Yucca Mountain, located 130 km northwest of the gambling city of Las Vegas. In February, Energy Secretary Spencer Abraham recommended that 70,000 metric tons of the waste be buried at the proposed site, despite fervent opposition from the state. He argued that storing the waste at one site, rather than throughout the nation, would be safer and more secure.
Proponents of the plan — including the nuclear industry and the U.S. Chamber of Commerce — say the waste would be safely buried, using a combination of natural barriers and hardened steel storage casks, for at least 10,000 years without it leaching into underground water or escaping into the environment.
The site is scientifically sound and suitable, said Abraham, whose aim is to open the site in 2010, if it is approved.
Lawmakers in Nevada, however, warn that the 58-billion-dollar project would risk the health and safety of people in the state and potentially drive away tourists and lower property values.
Critics point to how the Nuclear Regulatory Commission recently identified 293 unresolved technical issues, ranging from the extent of fracturing of rock over time to the speed with which water can seep through rock and corrode the storage canisters. The Commission must issue a license before the repository can be built.
If waste from a storage tank leaks, radiation could be carried by an underground aquifer beneath the mountain to nearby communities, argue critics. Environmentalists also worry that if an earthquake occurs in the area, storage canisters could break or get damaged.
The groundwater could also rise, submersing the stored waste, say critics. More than 600 seismic events of a magnitude greater than 2.5 have occurred since 1976 within an 80-mile radius of the site.
Last week, Nevada Governor Kenny Guinn, a Republican, filed a veto against Abraham’s decision. Congress had granted Nevada in 1982 an unusual power to challenge any presidential decision about Yucca. Lawmakers must now approve or reject Guinn’s veto. The House is expected to back the administration, while the Senate vote remains uncertain.
“I am outraged, as are the citizens of Nevada, that this decision would go forward with so many unanswered questions,” said Guinn.
Opponents of the Yucca dump also argue the proposal threatens the environment and safety of the entire nation because it will involve massive shipments of radioactive waste.
Dubbed “Mobile Chernobyl” by environmental activists, the plan to move the waste to Yucca would involve about 100,000 shipments by truck, train and barge that would pass through about 44 states – and within one mile of more than 50 million people – over the next 30 years. Opponents to the Yucca site, instead, advocate storing radioactive waste as close as safely possible to the reactors whence it came.
“It’s not just a Nevada problem, it’s a problem our whole country faces,” Senator Harry Reid, a Democrat from Nevada said at a protest rally here Tuesday. He urged fellow Senators to reject the proposed nuclear dump.
The Department of Energy, in an assessment of the Yucca proposal, projects there could be 210 to 354 crashes involving nuclear waste as it travels across country to the Nevada site.
“An accident involving a truck transporting massive levels of radiation, and a school bus carrying forty kids is a very real possibility,” said Carl Pope, executive director of the Sierra Club, a national environmental organisation. Television advertisements against the dump targeted at Republican Senators are expected to start airing soon in Northeast states, he said.
Joan Claybrook, president of Public Citizen, a national advocacy group founded by consumer advocate turned politician Ralph Nader, said terrorists could also target the shipments.
“Nuclear waste transportation casks have not been properly tested to ensure they won’t release radiation in a crash,” she said.
Activists say the administration’s energy policy — which calls for more nuclear power plants — will only exacerbate the problem by creating more radioactive waste in need of safe storage.
“We need an energy policy that doesn’t lead to a legacy of waste,” said Chris Williams, executive director of Citizen Action Coalition, an advocacy group in the state of Indiana, which recently successfully thwarted plans to construct two nuclear power plants.