Development & Aid, Headlines, Latin America & the Caribbean, Population

POPULATION-CHILE: Controversy and Novelties Mark New Census

Gustavo González

SANTIAGO, Apr 19 2002 (IPS) - Questions about the number of personal computers and Internet hook-ups will be the main novelty in Chile’s new National Census on Population and Housing. But the census has also given rise to controversy regarding the issue of religious affiliation, while a perhaps more far-reaching debate on ethnic identity has been sidestepped.

The new census will be carried out next Wednesday, which has been declared a holiday by the centre-left coalition government of Ricardo Lagos. On that day, 370,000 census-takers will compile information in cities and the countryside, the mainland and islands, and homes, hospitals and prisons.

“We All Count” is the slogan that the National Institute of Statistics has come up with to encourage everyone to participate in Chile’s 17th census on population and its sixth census on housing.

The last census, carried out in 1992, found that Chile had 13,348,401 inhabitants, divided in nearly equal parts between females and males. That total was lower than projected, reflecting a decline in the country’s birth rate.

Today, the Chilean population is projected at around 15.5 million. According to the last estimate, calculated in June 2001 on the basis of demographic projections, this Southern Cone country is home to 15,401,952 people, 7,775,470 of whom are women.

This week, the Secretary-General of the Government, Minister Heraldo Muñoz, criticised mayors who had threatened that they would not cooperate in the census, because they complain that their municipalities or districts have been left out of the government’s special job creation plans.

“The census is indispensable for planning the development of the country based on what we have in terms of population, housing and other resources,” said Muñoz, who stressed that it was precisely this information that would enable the government to design better employment policies.

The x-ray of the country to be taken on Apr 24 will reveal the number of inhabitants and their distribution by sex and age, while assessing the quality and conditions of people’s housing units and furnishings, in order to evaluate the deficits in those areas.

“Over the past 10 years, enormous changes have occurred in the country and in the world, which have had repercussions on the population’s lifestyles. Globalisation and the incorporation of computers, not only in the workplace but in Chileans’ homes as well, and the arrival of the Internet, are a few examples,” according to the National Institute of Statistics.

Thus, the next census will attempt to bring the database up-to- date in today’s globalised world, by seeking precise statistics on connectivity – the proportion of the population that surfs the information superhighway – to determine where Chile stands with regards to the global information society and the digital divide.

The new census will also include questions on the number of cars and other motor vehicles owned by families – another statistic that required little attention up to a decade ago.

The run-up to the census has been marked by loud complaints from the Catholic Church about a campaign urging Chileans not to declare themselves as Catholics when the pollsters ask about their religious affiliation.

Civil servants distributed e-mails from two public offices, behind the backs of their superiors, instructing people not to declare themselves as Catholics if they are not practicing churchgoers, even if they have been baptised in the Church.

The census will ask people if they define themselves as Catholic, Protestant, Mormon, Jewish, Muslim or a member of any other religion, Mason, agnostic or atheist.

In the last census, 74 percent of Chileans declared that they were Catholic.

Cardinal Francisco Javier Errázuriz, primate of the Catholic Church in Chile, claimed the e-mails formed part of a campaign aimed at minimising the Roman Catholic religion’s deep roots in this South American country.

The controversy is not a minor one, as the Catholic Church continues to wage its values-based “battles” against the passage of a divorce law – divorce is still illegal in Chile – the authorisation of sales of a contraceptive that the Church describes as an “abortion pill”, and the promotion of condom use by AIDS prevention campaigns.

Cardinal Errázuriz went so far as to state that he would find the results of the census questionable if the number of people declaring themselves Catholics were below 74 percent – a remark that triggered a storm of debate in which politicians, Protestant pastors and Masons chipped in.

A week ago, the Episcopal Conference of Chile attempted to calm things down by issuing a statement stressing the importance of, and the Church’s support for, the census.

But Lucía Sepúlveda, an independent journalist, noted that the commotion surrounding the question of religious affiliation has drowned out a debate that is perhaps even more necessary, regarding the census questions on ethnic identity.

The category on ethnic identity was introduced for the first time in the 1992 census, with the question “if you are Chilean, do you see yourself as belonging to any of the following cultures?: Mapuche, Aymara, Rapanui, none of the above.”

This time around, the questionnaire will include a greater number of options regarding cultural or ethnic identity: Alacalufe, Atacameño, Aymara, Colla, Mapuche, Quechua, Rapanui and Yamana – a list that represents all of the indigenous groups living in Chile.

Sepúlveda argued, however, that despite that advance, the new census could lead to the same errors which arose from the 1992 version, with respect to the estimate on the number of Indians in Chile.

The shortcomings of the questions on ethnic identity included in the last census have been pointed out in studies carried out by universities and international bodies, like the Latin American Centre on Demography.

The 1992 ethnic identity question was basically subjective, and asked people about their “cultural self-identification,” rather than their ethnic origin.

The Liwen Centre on Indigenous Research pointed out that many Chileans with no Mapuche ancestry declared that they felt culturally identified “with” that indigenous community.

(The Liwen Centre makes a clear distinction between identifying oneself “with” a group instead of “as” a member of that group).

Meanwhile, many Mapuche Indians who experience discrimination in their daily lives refused to admit their indigenous ancestry, and instead identified themselves “with” the Chileans.

According to Sepúlveda, a similar thing happened with the Aymara, in northern Chile, the second largest indigenous group in the country after the Mapuches, a community that is spread out over three southern provinces as well as Santiago.

The Liwen Centre researchers maintained that the census should include more precise guidelines for gauging the size of Chile’s indigenous population (previously estimated at around one million).

Rather than merely asking a question about cultural identity, the census should find out if people have preserved Mapuche last names, for instance, or if they have adopted Spanish surnames in an attempt to escape discrimination.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags