Thursday, November 19, 2026
Belinda Robinson
- Civil liberties advocates decried Wednesday the treatment of a defence attorney indicted Tuesday on charges she helped to pass messages between her Egyptian client and terrorist organisations in the Middle East.
U.S. Attorney-General John Ashcroft announced the charges against Lynne Stewart in New York. He alleged that Sheik Omar Abdel-Rahman used privileged conversations with Stewart, his attorney, to pass messages from his prison cell to direct terrorist activities in the Middle East.
None of the activities mentioned in the indictment are connected with last September’s terrorist attacks in the United States, Ashcroft said.
Civil liberties advocates criticised the indictment. Michael Lerner, president of the Centre for Constitutional Rights (CCR) in New York, said it was a “most serious attack on our civil liberties, and we are very worried.”
Stewart’s indictment could make other lawyers reluctant to take on clients charged with crimes such as Abdel-Rahman’s, according to the CCR. The blind Muslim cleric was convicted in 1995 of conspiring to blow up New York landmarks including the World Trade Centre. He is serving a life sentence.
“It definitely has the potential of deterring lawyers from taking on these types of cases, because if everything is wire-tapped, everything is circumspect and you can’t really tell to what extent you’re being tapped,” Lerner said.
Authorities taped Abdel-Rahman’s jailhouse conversations under the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act. One of the conversations allegedly implicated Stewart.
The veteran lawyer pleaded “emphatically not guilty” to the charges at her arraignment.
“I do think that this will become, hopefully, a touchstone case, as many of my cases have, something that points out the limits the government can go to in prosecuting people they don’t like,” Stewart told reporters afterward.
More than 40 lawyers attended the arraignment in a show of support for Stewart, a well-respected attorney who has often taken high-profile and controversial clients.
“It has sent a chill through the legal community,” Lerner said.
Jayne Weintraub, a criminal defence attorney and former federal prosecutor from Miami, told CNN she was “troubled” after reading about Stewart’s case and is waiting to see how the government presents its case.
The indictment is “not evidence, and we all know that,” she said. “These are merely allegations that the government has set forth.”
The accusations against Stewart include that she knowingly helped Abdel-Rahman to pass information to the Islamic Group, which has taken credit for the killings of 58 tourists and four Egyptians in 1997. Prosecutors said Stewart distracted jail guards in May 2000, while an Arabic translator took instructions from Abdel-Rahman for the Islamic Group.
“Sheik Abdel-Rahman has learned al-Qaeda’s lessons well,” said Ashcroft, referring to the network allegedly run and sustained by Osama bin Laden, suspected by U.S. authorities of masterminding the Sep. 11 suicide hijacking of four U.S. jetliners.
Abdel-Rahman “”is determined to exploit the rights guaranteed him under the U.S. system of justice to pursue the destruction of that very system,” Ashcroft told a New York news conference.
Also charged were the translator, Mohammed Yousry, and two others accused of helping Abdel-Rahman to pass messages to his followers.
Stewart has been released on a 500,000-dollar bond, with the stipulation that she does not speak to Abdel-Rahman. Her lawyer, Susan Tipograph, could not be reached for comment Wednesday.
Stewart remained adamant about her innocence. “Prove it, prove it, prove it,” she said of the charges against her. “I am a lawyer. I fight for my clients. That’s what my job is.”