Wednesday, November 18, 2026
Ferry Biedermann
- A Palestinian security chief cannot find a house to live in since the Israelis bombed it, the apocryphal story goes, because the landlord would fear the Israelis will bomb it again, that he may not be able to pay the rent, and because he is seen as a traitor who extradited fighters to Israel.
The story of Jibril Rajoub, head of the Palestinian Preventive Security, is an uncertain one. But then so is the story of Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat.
Rajoub is one of two security chiefs to have been moved out by Arafat as a part of security reforms prompted by the U.S. and Israel. He is due to switch jobs with the Governor of Jenin, Zuhair Manasreh.
Analysts say that faces may change, but the system will not, despite President George Bush’s call for more Palestinian democracy.
The other security chief Ghazi Jabali, head of police in the Gaza strip, is said to have received an order to step down. He had refused at first to leave his post but he is now said to have backed down, declaring that he will contest elections against Arafat.
The story about Rajoub suggests among other things that he may not be all that popular among people on the West Bank. He did, however, enjoy the confidence of the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) for a long time.
A shift in the U.S. position may have led to the current efforts to get rid of him. New minister of Interior Abdel Razek Yihiye who plans to oversee unified Palestinian security services is said to have demanded the resignation of Rajoub.
The spat over Rajoub highlights the difficulties with reforms of the Palestinian Authority (PA). The attempt is so wrought with contradictions that it is hard to see a democratic form of government emerging from it.
Ironies abound in the Middle East. Countless commentators pointed out last week that President Bush had called upon decidedly undemocratic Arab regimes to help Palestinians found a democratic society.
A bigger contradiction might be that the U.S. is still expecting meaningful reform under the leadership of Yasser Arafat, the man they hold responsible for the undemocratic state of affairs in the PA. The U.S. is expecting Arafat to reform the security services after blaming him for much of the violence. The U.S. administration has said it will not deal with Arafat even if he is re-elected, because he is “tainted with terror”.
Another irony pointed out by both Israeli and Palestinian analysts is that the very demand for democracy by President Bush will make reforms harder. Palestinians who had become critical of Arafat have rallied around him as a result of the blatant attempt by Bush to unseat him.
The confused U.S. bid to bring democracy to the Palestinians seems more like another delaying tactic to allow the U.S. administration to avoid dealing with the conflict for some time to come, commentators say. Peace, not democracy is at stake here.
Israeli political analyst Yossi Alpher says about Bush’s speech: “His call for a new constitution which separates the powers of government ignores the fact that such a constitution exists – it was drafted in the mid-90s with the advice of American non-governmental organisations – and several weeks ago was finally signed by Arafat, under pressure from liberal Palestinian activists, along with additional reforms.”
The Palestinians are preparing to choose their own leaders and their own standards of governance. Both are likely to be vastly different from what the U.S. and Israel would like to see.
With the rest of the world continuing to see Arafat as the legitimate representative of the Palestinian people, he has enough diplomatic breathing space to survive. Arafat led the Palestinian Liberation Organisation for decades while he was virtually an international pariah. His position now is a lot better. The Palestinians still see him as the symbol of their national struggle, and he is resourceful enough to maintain a grip on power even from behind the scenes. There is little indication that Arafat will be replaced or ‘reformed’.