Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines, Human Rights, Population

RIGHTS: ‘Stranded’ Biharis Forgotten by Pakistan, Bangladesh

Qurratul Ain Tahmina

DHAKA, Jul 25 2002 (IPS) - Squelching up the muddy narrow path, peering into the overcrowded, dark hovels and breathing in the stench emanating from the cramped existence of hundreds of humans huddled together, it is easy to forget that normal life in the Bangladeshi capital goes on outside these ‘camps’.

“What have you come to see? This is pure hell!” asks one woman. The words, spoken in Urdu, ring sharp.

Dhaka is home to many slums, but there is more than poverty here: It is home to people left to rot in makeshift camps ever since the 1971 Bangladesh ‘war of liberation’, which resulted in its breaking away from Pakistan.

Some of these people call themselves ‘stranded Pakistanis’, others claim they are the ‘linguistic minority’ of Bangladesh. Commonly called Biharis, they are scattered in 66 camps across the country. At last count, they were around 240,000 in 1993.

Their plight goes back to the partition of India and Pakistan in 1947. When persecuted in bloody communal riots and lured by the promise of a Muslim homeland, these Urdu-speaking Muslims from India flocked to eastern Pakistan – later to become Bangladesh — at the time of partition.

They came largely from the poverty-ridden state of Bihar in India, but also from others including Uttar Pradesh in northern India.

Sheikh Maksud, now 80, had come with one of the first batches of ‘Biharis’. “Jinnah (the architect of Pakistan) came to our town in Uttar Pradesh and invited the Muslims to the new country,” says Maksud in broken Bangla.

A skilled employee of the railways, Maksud secured a good job and settled down in a northern town of erstwhile east Pakistan.

Many of the Urdu-speaking migrants were skilled factory workers and technicians, who came with firm faith to the country formed on the basis of religion – Islamic Pakistan, partitioned from mainly Hindu India.

The central government of Pakistan welcomed them and favoured them over the Bangla-speaking majority in its eastern wing, whose loyalty they were doubtful of.

Linguistic affinity – Urdu, which is spoken is Pakistan — and core allegiance bracketed the Biharis with the Pakistani forces in 1971, when cultural and economic oppression by the non-Bengali-western part of Pakistan led the Bengali east, allied with India, fight a bloody war of independence.

By the end of that year Bangladesh came into being, breaking up Pakistan. Not all the Biharis had supported the genocide of the Bengalis by the Pakistanis, but in new Bangladesh their entire population symbolised the oppressors and the Biharis became victims of bloodthirsty vengeance.

The Biharis were taken into protective camps during the war and afterwards, in facilities run by the International Red Cross. According to their relief cards, 735,180 had taken refuge in these enclaves in 1972. A total of 539,669 of them applied to be taken to Pakistan when they were offered an option.

Maksud had lost his job by 1972. Penniless, he took refuge in a Dhaka camp in 1973-1974. “Everybody wanted to go to Pakistan in 1972,” explains Maksud’s wife Asma. “We were on the run for our lives.”

But nearly 30 years of camp life has disillusioned this family, like many others, about someday going to Pakistan.

Ahmed Ilias, a journalist in an Urdu-language newspaper published from Dhaka, was originally from Bihar and had come to this part as a student in 1950.

Ahmed had been one of those few Biharis who supported the cause of Bangladesh but “desperate, I decided to opt for Pakistan”. But by 1974, he became convinced that repatriation to Pakistan was neither possible nor sustainable.

Pakistan initially took back around 150,000 Biharis, including ‘divided families’ with members already in Pakistan. The U.N.-supervised repatriation ended in 1974, leaving most of the Biharis who had opted for Pakistan in the camps.

A considerable number made it to Pakistan unofficially. A few more drives repatriated less than 20,000, and the effort petered out in 1993.

Pakistan claimed that it had fulfilled its commitment of taking the eligible lot, off and but also kept on fanning the hopes of the remaining Biharis. Bangladesh conveniently evaded any real responsibility.

“In fact, both the countries continue to play the issue up according to their internal and external political interests,” says Ahmed. “These people are used and then left in the same lurch.”

The camp dwellers still get a wee amount of wheat per head per month, now provided by the government’s relief ministry.

The Geneva Camp in Mohammadpur, Dhaka, the largest of the camps, is home to 18,000 to 20,000 people who survive by selling labour and technical skills, needlework, or by running petty businesses.

Ten to 12 people per family live in each of the eight-feet by 10-feet shacks. Some 240 toilets and 36 bathing facilities, 31 of them open-air, serve the camp population.

Children are not allowed to play in the local playground and high schools do not accept students from the camp.

“The only way out for these people is their gradual integration into the mainstream Bangladeshi society;” believes Ahmed, whose ‘Al Falah’ group provides health care and rehabilitation but is running low on funds.

“What they need most is education to help them get rehabilitated. Given proper opportunities here, nobody would go to Pakistan. Their present confusion and a visionless leadership keep them open to exploitations by anybody,” he points out.

The leaders of the Stranded Pakistanis General Repatriation Committee (SPGRC), formed in 1976, still hold that given the chance, all the Biharis would go to Pakistan.

“How will you keep them here in such conditions,” asks Abdul Jabbar Khan, its president. Gesturing at squalor around, he adds, “We worked for Pakistan and that’s why we demand their support. If we are to remain in Bangladesh grant us citizenship, all the rights and total rehabilitation.”

But a weaver’s community of Urdu-speaking people elsewhere in Dhaka is integrating into the community, and many show no interest in moving to Pakistan.

“This is my home,” says an old woman. “I have once changed my country after 1947. I know the hardship of settling down in a new place. I only want our life here to be a bit easier.”

In 2001, for the first time the Bangladeshi population census counted the Biharis in Geneva Camp.

“The few of us who have managed to get some education realise that if we go to Pakistan now, we will be as misfits as our fathers were here after 1971,” says Mohammad Hasan, convenor of the group Association of Young Generation of Urdu-Speaking Community and like many young Biharis, is fluent in Bangla.

“Most of us have been born in the camps and now we want our places in the larger society,” he says.

Several young people have filed a writ petition with the country’s highest court, demanding voting rights in Bangladesh.

M I Farooqui, a senior advocate in the Supreme Court and of Urdu-speaking origin, is moving the writ and had earlier won a case securing citizenship and property rights of a Bihari man.

“‘They are all legal citizens of this country either by domicile or by birth. You do not lose your citizenship merely by applying for repatriation to another country. There have been quite a few favourable and decisive verdicts,” he explains.

“They cannot be termed refugees nor can they strictly be called stateless,” says C R Abrar, professor of international relations at Dhaka University. “While the issue of their being Bangladeshi citizens sparks off debates, there can be no debate about their state of misery. And at least those born after 1971 deserve their rights as Bangladeshi citizens.”

Abrar says university studies have found that except for some male adults, the overwhelming majority of Biharis want to stay in Bangladesh with citizenship rights.

“The civil societies in Bangladesh and Pakistan should now raise the humanitarian concerns and lobby their respective governments to end the plight of these people,” he argues.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags