Wednesday, November 18, 2026
Mark Bourrie
- Environmental groups are appealing to Parliament’s watchdog to force the federal government to clean up the country’s polluted air, which they say violates citizens’ human rights.
Despite Canada’s huge size and small population, large areas of the country were placed under air pollution advisories this summer. Much of the bad air comes from coal-fired power plants in central Ontario and Quebec provinces and from petroleum refineries in western Alberta.
The groups are claiming that the government fails to adequately regulate emissions that cause air pollution and to provide legally binding air quality standards. As a result, Ottawa is violating basic human rights, including the rights to life, health, and security of the person, they argue.
Rather than take their case to the government itself or to a committee of members of parliament, the group has appealed to the agency that monitors the government’s performance – the office of the auditor general.
“We’ve (previously) been able to get substantial action on the ground by using this process,” said Lynda Collins, the Sierra Defence Fund lawyer who organised the petition. “Even when the auditor general hasn’t ruled directly in our favour, we’ve been able to get government officials to take action.”
A similar petition about the national government’s standards on well-water contamination resulted in a community near Ottawa receiving devices to filter an industrial chemical from its water, she said.
“In this case, we believe it’s better to use this process than to spend a lot of time and money on a lawsuit. The auditor general has a commissioner for sustainable development, and this is the kind of issue that falls under that category,” Collins added.
“And the Canadian Environmental Protection Act allows the federal government to step in when local governments allow trans-boundary pollution.”
The auditor general is seen as a neutral, effective and sometimes harsh critic of government operations. The office’s annual reports garner heavy coverage in the Canadian media.
The groups, including Greenpeace, offered Auditor General Sheila Fraser several solutions to air pollution, including tougher standards on Canadian gasoline (now among the dirtiest in North America), a crackdown on large, polluting automobiles such as sport utility vehicles (SUVs) and more enforcement power for environmental officials.
“The only lack that we can see is a lack of political will,” said Collins. “The situation is so bad, (the government has) run afoul of international human rights.”
The environmentalists may find a sympathetic audience. Last year, former Auditor General Denis Desautels warned that Ottawa would not be able to live up to commitments made in the Kyoto Protocol to reduce greenhouse gas emissions to 1990 levels by the year 2010.
Instead, the emissions would increase at least 11 per cent by 2010 because of ineffective policing by Canada’s environment department, he said. It was the first time an auditor general had tackled a domestic environmental issue.
Canada has still not ratified Kyoto, though Prime Minister Jean Chretien said last week the government would “probably” do it before he retires in 18 months.
The Auditor General Act allows anyone to submit a petition on a matter of public administration. It is then passed to the relevant government minister, who must respond.
If Fraser is unhappy with the response, she can report her displeasure to Parliament.
Environment Canada issued 23 air quality advisories for southern Ontario in the summer of 2001, twice the number of any year since 1988. Since May 1 this year, there have already been 23 air advisory days for the region.
In neighbouring Quebec, Montreal had nine air quality advisories in 2001 – also its highest since 1988 – while greater Vancouver on the Pacific coast had three.
Conservative estimates place the number of deaths caused by air pollution in Canada at 5,000 per year – more than 10 times the number of murders, according to the Sierra Defence Fund.
The petitioning groups want the federal government to immediately enact binding national air quality standards that can be effectively enforced. They say standards should be set at levels that will protect children, the elderly, and people with respiratory illnesses.
The groups also want Ottawa to set mandatory fuel standards, with penalties for non-compliance, by 2006.
A spokesman for the auditor general said she does not comment on ongoing cases.