Wednesday, November 18, 2026
Katherine Stapp
- A new tool for sustainable development is set to take effect with the Kyoto Protocol, but it is uncertain if investors will get on board, and environmentalists are already warning it could be abused.
Kyoto’s Clean Development Mechanism (CDM) will let industrialised countries that are bound to limit the amount of greenhouse gases they produce offset their emissions by investing in clean energy projects in less developed countries.
Some environmental groups, like Greenpeace, strongly object to the scheme, saying it will not lower overall global pollution, while most experts agree that the CDM offers a way for poorer countries to benefit directly from Kyoto, assuming investors find the scheme cost-effective.
The CDM is one of the “flexible” aspects of Kyoto, similar to the emissions swapping permitted under the treaty.
Under swapping, the government of a country that emits less carbon dioxide (CO2 – one of the greenhouse gases most scientists say is responsible for climate change) than its target can sell the ‘leftover’ pollution to another nation.
Likewise, under the CDM, a coal plant in Britain can gain CO2 credits by funding a greenhouse gas reduction project overseas.
“The CDM has the potential to promote sustainable development,” says Rebecca Carr of the Edinburgh Centre for Carbon Management. “The key will be making the CDM accessible to rural communities in developing countries.”
While the Mechanism will officially begin only once Kyoto takes effect – likely in the next few months – projects have already been proposed for the CDM, which is operated through the United Nations Convention on Climate Change.
But potential host countries in the South – non-industrialised nations that have signed Kyoto but are not bound by emissions caps – have reacted slowly.
“Developing countries are currently not taking full advantage of the CDM, largely due to the uncertainties about the rules for participation,” Carr says. “Each project has to develop its own systems and standards for producing, calculating and managing its carbon, which is a complicated and expensive business.”
Jeff Fiedler, a climate policy specialist with the Natural Resources Defence Council, anticipates 100-200 CDM projects will be proposed in the first year. Already, a number have been put forward, including a biomass (turning plants or animal waste into fuel) project in India, hydroelectricity projects in Panama and Uganda, and a natural gas scheme in Brazil.
The process begins with a proposal from an investor, which is then forwarded to the host country, the CDM executive board and an independent auditor, who must validate the project.
All proposals will have to include a breakdown of how much CO2 will be saved, along with a monitoring plan.
They will be subject to a 30-day public comment period, but critics complain the process does not ensure that citizens of potential host countries can participate in the decision-making. Rather, hosts have broad discretion to green-light projects with little oversight, Fiedler says.
“Groups like the Indigenous Peoples Caucus (a U.N.-affiliated non-governmental organisation or NGO) are very concerned about this,” he adds.
“They’re worried that people with a lot of money will come into lands they rely on and start doing stuff that they have no control over.”
“Essentially, both sides (host country and investor) want to do as little as possible to get credit,” Fiedler says. “It’s just human nature. There’s the potential for a rush to the bottom.”
But he agrees that a new World Bank fund, which stresses local involvement and eschews controversial mega-projects, could set the standard for the low-cost projects needed to attract investors.
The fund, available to 64 developing countries, will emphasise projects on: renewable energy, energy efficiency, solid waste to energy conversion and agro-forestry. An example of such a project could be replacing kerosene lamps with solar panels.
Lidia Brito, Mozambique’s minister of higher education, science and technology, says the fund “will mean real improvement in the lives of the poor”.
“Until now, countries like mine have been bypassed by the growing market in carbon emissions credits,” she points out. “This will enable private capital seeking carbon credits to reach deep down into the poorest areas of the developing world.”
Some experts are pessimistic that the CDM will prove as popular – or be managed as well – as emissions trading, especially because the United States refuses to ratify the Kyoto treaty.
“So far, the lacklustre behaviour of industrialised countries is a big disappointment,” says Axel Michaelowa, head of the International Climate Policy Programme at the Hamburg Institute of International Economics.
He fears that “only large projects in favourable circumstances are going to be feasible. Small projects will be burdened by high costs to get them through the CDM approval process – even if they get special treatment.”
“Many governments just pay lip service to climate policy but do not introduce policy instruments that would give clear financial signals to emitters,” Michaelowa notes.
“Often, emitters get away with ‘voluntary agreements’ that are just business-as-usual,” he says, adding, “consequently, there are no incentives for emitters to look for CDM credits”.
Another sticking point of the Mechanism is that proposed investments must have “additionality”, a fancy way of saying the projects would not have been done regardless. Some experts wonder how they are supposed to gauge this “parallel universe” scenario.
The World Wildlife Fund (WWF) says that under current CDM rules, such “free-rider credits, awarded spuriously to projects that would have happened even without the CDM, could be as great as 600 million tonnes of carbon”.
The upshot would be a net increase of CO2 emissions under the CDM, the group says, turning it into profit-driven exercise rather than an instrument for sustainable development.
Most independent climate and development experts are willing to wait and see.
“There are often barriers to the initial implementation of any new programme, including this one,” says Richard Morgenstern, a senior fellow at the Washington-based think-tank Resources for the Future.
“Experience is key,” he adds. “Spreading information on how the programme works is essential to its success. This information, in turn, will allow entrepreneurs in both developed and developing countries to develop creative projects that generate both global and local benefits.”