Africa, Development & Aid, Economy & Trade, Headlines, Labour

DEVELOPMENT-SOUTH AFRICA: Inverting the Irish Coffee Labour Market

Farah Khan

JOHANNESBURG, Oct 11 2002 (IPS) - The effective implementation of affirmative action in South Africa’s jobs market is more a marathon than a sprint, say industry experts about to release the annual report on the policy.

The director-general of the Labour Department, Rams Ramashia, has coined the phrase to describe a labour market that still resembles an Irish coffee – a layer of white on top, but largely black beneath.

Because of apartheid, white men continue to dominate the top echelons. Last year’s employment equity report (South Africa’s term for affirmative action) found that over eight in 10 top and senior management jobs are held by white men. African men hold six in 100 such jobs; African women hold just over one in 100 positions.

Ramashia told IPS that this year’s report, out later this month, shows a slightly higher number of black representation, but says it will take decades to make the jobs market racially representative. "This is an historical legacy. White people were historically at the front of the queue and there were instruments to push them to the front," he says.

These instruments included job reservation and apartheid education where, until 1994, the state spent much less on black children than it did on white.

"It’s a legacy that will take a long time to be addressed and it will not be addressed through market forces alone," says Ramashia. It was for this reason that government passed the Employment Equity Act two years ago. It is a controversial law that has attracted criticism from largely white commentators who argue that it stymies South Africa from developing a meritocracy, and that it is racially divisive. This camp has argued that the law should be accompanied by a sunset clause – meaning it should not carry on forever.

It is not a view that Ramashia agrees with. "Any legislation which has served its purpose will be abrogated by disuse. If workplace culture and demographics change significantly, there shall come a time when there is no need for the legislation."

In centres like Johannesburg and Pretoria, the changes the law has brought in its wake are apparent on the streets. A black middle-class has quickly been formed, as signified by the increasing numbers of dark-suited, sedan-driving executives on the streets. Often, they are the beneficiaries of a new colour-blind labour market and of the effective implementation of the equity law in the professions, financial services and in the public sector. Cities like Cape Town and Durban do less well in the affirmative action stakes.

Arguably, it is in the 1.1-million strong public sector where the biggest strides are being made. While the ruling African National Congress (ANC) of President Thabo Mbeki inherited a largely white civil service, it is now a majority black civil service. "The public sector is leading by example," says Ramashia.

Employment equity is not the only answer to the imperative to make the labour market racially representative and to build up a layer of black skills. Another piece of legislation, the Skills Development Act, is equally important in the plan. This legislation sets up a complex network of training to provide opportunities to South African workers.

Particular attention is being paid to qualifying graduates in maths and science, since South Africa needs professionals like engineers, accountants and financial managers to fuel an economy that has changed its character from a manufacturing focus to a services bias.

Government is aiming at ensuring that this plan results in a graduate programme that is 85 percent black; half women and that there is a four percent representation of people with disabilities.

Employment equity consultant Urmilla Bhoola says there is an increased realisation in the private sector that the process is not a social responsibility act, but an economic policy imperative. Without the two laws, it is unlikely that South Africa will have the skills necessary to ensure that economic growth is a key ingredient of development.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags

Africa, Development & Aid, Economy & Trade, Headlines, Labour

DEVELOPMENT-SOUTH AFRICA: Inverting the Irish Coffee Labour Market

Farah Khan

JOHANNESBURG, Oct 11 2002 (IPS) - The effective implementation of affirmative action in South Africa’s jobs market is more a marathon than a sprint, say industry experts about to release the annual report on the policy.
(more…)

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags