Wednesday, November 18, 2026
Mark Bourrie
- Most of the world sees Canada as a vast area of unspoiled wilderness, but a government-appointed environmental commissioner paints a picture of a nation careless with industrial and mine wastes.
This week, federal environmental commissioner Johnanne Gelinas released a report showing the country has at least 3,600 toxic waste dumps and 17 abandoned mines that are leaking contaminants into the environment.
Gelinas says arsenic, cyanide and other toxins are leaking into Canada’s soil and groundwater, both in populated areas, and in some of the most isolated places on the planet.
One of the worst pollution sites in the country is in the Atlantic coast city of Sydney, Nova Scotia, where large ”tar ponds” of toxic waste are polluting the air and the groundwater.
The federal government has promised to clean up the tar ponds, but Gelinas says continued financing for the project is far from certain.
"Federal department officials informed us that the federal government has not yet decided on the extent of its future contribution, if any, for the costs associated with the next cleanup phase of the Sydney tar ponds site," she said in a report tabled in the Commons.
Gelinas later told reporters that the time is over for talking about cleaning up thousands of toxic sites like the tar ponds.
"We have to go beyond dialogue now and act," she said. "These problems are there, people are exposed to health risks, the environment is contaminated and we have to stop talking and move ahead with solutions."
The Sierra Club of Canada says they’re pleased the commissioner has shed some light into ”a dark corner of Canada’s record in managing toxic waste, abandoned mines and radioactive sites across the country”.
Executive Director Elizabeth May says the government may be managing its finances to benefit future generations, but it is leaving the trash and waste for those same future Canadians.
The Sierra Club calls for a ‘Clean Canada’ fund, similar to the United States’ SuperFund, to organise the cleanup of polluted sites.
May said Ottawa should also take charge of the tar ponds cleanup.
"This report will be a shock for a number of people to realise that the federal government has not yet decided if any of its funds will go into the ultimate cleanup," she said.
Environment Minister David Anderson said the government does not have billions of dollars to spend on the Sydney tar ponds and thousands of other toxic sites across Canada.
"There’s no question the department of environment is not well funded," he said. "We’re trying hard to make sure we do the very best job we can with limited funds."
In the past 20 years, the federal government has spent over 250 million Canadian dollars (160 million U.S. dollars) on the tar ponds site and nearby areas, the environment commissioner’s report says.
That includes more than 66 million dollars on environmental studies and cleanup attempts since 1993.
John Morgan, mayor of the Cape Breton Regional Municipality that includes the tar ponds, said the commissioner’s report echoes his view that Ottawa has not revealed the costs or made a commitment to a final cleanup.
Gelinas concluded that Ottawa is floundering on ecological issues and lacks clear priorities. "No one appears to be in charge," she told a news conference.
Her report said the federal government ”is not investing enough – enough of its human and financial resources; its legislative regulatory and economic powers; or its political leadership – to fulfil its sustainable development commitments”.
Gelinas works out of the office of the auditor-general and reports directly to Parliament.
Her report comes at a time when the federal government of Prime Minister Jean Chretien is fighting publicly with oil and gas producing Alberta province, as well as the business community, over ratifying the Kyoto Accord, the international treaty to limit the amount of ”greenhouse gases” that are released into the air.
Ottawa is also criticised by environmentalists for having failed to pass a law protecting endangered species, despite three attempts.
Mark Bourrie
- Most of the world sees Canada as a vast area of unspoiled wilderness, but a government-appointed environmental commissioner paints a picture of a nation careless with industrial and mine wastes.
(more…)