Headlines, Human Rights, North America

RIGHTS-COLOMBIA: Group says Attorney General Sabotaging Probes

Jim Lobe

WASHINGTON, Nov 8 2002 (IPS) - In a rare attack against a specific individual, Human Rights Watch on Friday charged that Colombia’s Attorney General, Luis Camilo Osorio, has ”severely undermined” his office’s ability to investigate and prosecute human rights abuses by the armed forces or right-wing paramilitaries.

In a 14-page report based on interviews with current and former employees of the attorney general’s office, as well as Osorio himself, the New York-based group cited a series of purges undertaken by the attorney general that have resulted in ending well-advanced investigations and prosecutions of paramilitary leaders and senior military officers.

It also charged that Osorio, who took office on Jul. 31, 2001, has failed to adequately protect investigators and prosecutors assigned to key cases from threats and retaliation by paramilitaries.

In fact, the report says, Osorio appears to have exposed them to greater danger by publicly criticising their handling of cases, questioning the seriousness of threats against them, and by removing their security details immediately after firing them. As a result, many have fled the country after receiving death threats.

The report, A Wrong Turn: The Record of the Colombian Attorney General’s Office, called on Colombia’s new president, Alvaro Uribe, to take urgent steps to restore the competence and independence of the attorney general’s office.

It also urged the administration of U.S. President George W. Bush to make clear that Washington will not provide more aid unless Osorio stops undermining human rights prosecutions.

”The aid was meant to strengthen human rights prosecutions,” said Jose Miguel Vivanco, the head of HRW’s Americas Division. ”But as long as the political will to pursue these cases is absent, no amount of money, training or equipment will improve the institution’s record.”

Among other duties, the attorney general’s office in Colombia is charged with investigating human rights abuses, a mandate for which it founded a special human rights unit (HRU) in 1995. Over the following six years, the HRU made significant progress on a wide range of important and, in some cases, notorious, cases involving the army, police, paramilitaries, and guerrillas, says the report.

The HRU’s performance was considered especially important by Washington, which approved a 1.3-billion-dollar package of military, economic, and judicial aid for Colombia, including 25 million dollars for special training and equipment for the unit. At the same time, it made the military aid conditional on the Colombian army’s co-operation with civilian justice officials prosecuting human-rights cases.

Yet all of the progress made by the HRU, as well as much of the aid that Washington has provided, has been lost during Osorio’s 15-month tenure, according to the document.

Within days of taking office, ”Attorney General Osorio forced the resignations of the director and former director of the specialized (HRU),” it noted. ”Over the following months, he continued purging the office of officials who had worked on sensitive human rights cases and sent a clear message to those who remained that efforts to prosecute human rights violations committed by army officers would not be welcome.”

After Osorio took office, at least nine prosecutors and investigators working on human rights cases were fired, while 15 others, most of whom also worked for the HRU, were either forced to resign or felt compelled to do so under pressure, adds the report. Almost all of them have since left Colombia due to death threats.

Many who left had received special training under the U.S. aid programme yet were replaced by relatively inexperienced and untrained personnel, says HRW. As a result, many cases have stalled, and some have not been undertaken at all. Morale has plummeted.

The report focuses on several key cases involving assassinations or mass killings in which senior military officers were implicated or even charged by the HRU.

The unit, for example, collected evidence in a case against Gen. Rito Alejo Del Rio, head of the army’s notorious 17th Brigade in the mid-1990s, including the testimony of his bodyguard and chief of staff about his collaboration with paramilitaries responsible for raids and executions in the Uraba region.

The evidence was so compelling that President Andres Pastrana cashiered del Rio in 1998 and the U.S. government cancelled his visa. He was arrested on orders from a HRU prosecutor in July 2001. But within days of his arrest, Osorio publicly criticised the prosecutor and forced the resignation of Pedro Diaz, the HRU’s director who had overseen the case.

Osorio has subsequently removed several prosecutors who were pursuing other investigations against high-level military officials before they were able to arrest or indict the suspects, jeopardising the future of the investigations.

After interviewing Osorio about such cases, HRW found that his version of events often conflicted with those of other members of his staff and, in some cases, flatly contradicted the available documentary evidence.

In the case of prosecutor Luis Augusto Sepulveda, who had worked for over a year on the attempted assassination of a prominent union leader and was preparing an indictment against Army Maj. Cesar Maldonado when Osorio abruptly dismissed him last April, the attorney general told HRW that Sepulveda had missed a deadline. But the documentary record indicated that no deadlines had been missed, the report says.

Particularly alarming to HRW is Osorio’s failure to protect his staff. Since July 2001, five Colombian prosecutors and investigators have been killed in the line of duty, and a paramilitary death list containing the names of HRU personnel has been circulating since last April.

But Osorio has failed to provide his staff with adequate protection, going so far as to suggest at one point that they had ”victimised themselves”.

Earlier this year, members of the staff petitioned the Inter-American Commission of Human Rights (IACHR) for help in gaining security, an act roundly denounced by Osorio who complained – incorrectly – that they had failed to gain permission from the superiors to apply to the commission. The IACHR called on the government to urgently provide the protection sought.

”Colombia’s struggle to uphold the rule of law begins with its attorney general,” said Vivanco. ”Colombia cannot credibly say that it is making progress on protecting human rights if the attorney general is not doing his job.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags

Headlines, Human Rights, North America

RIGHTS-COLOMBIA: Group says Attorney General Sabotaging Probes

Jim Lobe

WASHINGTON, Nov 8 2002 (IPS) - In a rare attack against a specific individual, Human Rights Watch on Friday charged that Colombia’s Attorney General, Luis Camilo Osorio, has “severely undermined” his office’s ability to investigate and prosecute human rights abuses by the armed forces or right-wing paramilitaries.
(more…)

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags