Development & Aid, Headlines, Health, Human Rights, North America

HEALTH-CANADA: Groups Push for Mandatory Labels on GM Foods

Mark Bourrie

OTTAWA, Mar 14 2003 (IPS) - A coalition of environmental and consumer groups wants Canada’s national government to introduce mandatory labelling rules for genetically modified foods.

The group says that three years after it started discussing rules on labels, the general standards board is deadlocked about how to establish a voluntary system and may dissolve.

The move comes just as wheat farmers are trying to block a bid by agricultural giant Monsanto to begin testing genetically modified (GM) wheat. Farmers claim that government approval of GM crops would taint non-GM wheat, making it virtually unmarketable in Europe and parts of Asia.

The Canadian activists’ call for government action came two days before World Consumer Rights Day (Mar. 15), when environmentalists in Europe, Africa and Asia will stage protests and workshops to apply pressure to governments to stop the production of GM food crops.

Canada and the neighbouring United States ”stand out among industrialised countries in refusing to label GM foods”, says Paul Venditti, a researcher with Greenpeace. Consumers in many countries will not buy GM food and are afraid that all food products from countries with pro-GM policies is contaminated with altered genetic material, he adds.

”The production of genetically-engineered crops hurts Canada. Sales of canola to Europe have dropped by about 300 million (Canadian) dollars a year. There’s hesitancy among Asian countries to purchase products from Canada, and we’ll really feel the heat if Canada approves the planting of genetically-engineered wheat,” said Venditti.


”That would mean several billion in lost trade,” he added. ”Consumers in those countries are simply not willing to buy GE foods.”

In a recent poll, the activist added, nine out of 10 Canadians wanted labels on GM foods.

Producers of GM seeds and food have used the three-year negotiation time on labelling to try to sway public opinion with advertising, says Lucy Sharratt, an advocate with the Ottawa-based Polaris Institute, an environmental protection group.

”The voluntary labelling process has given time for powerful trans-national biotechnology corporations to start their advertising blitz,” she said.

”The three-year-old committee has given governments enough time to spend public money on their own communication strategy, including 3.3 million dollars on promotional material. The Canadian Food Inspection Agency has continued to promote biotechnology, while regulating (during) this time period," she said.

As well, Sharratt said, major Canadian food store chains have told manufacturers to remove labels that identify food as GMO-free.

The Canadian Council of Grocery Distributors claims products should not carry those labels until standards exist but, says Sharratt, ”after three and a half years, industry could not agree on a standard. It’s time for the government to step in. This committee has had its day. In fact, it’s had 1,275 of them.”

She says Canadian rules concerning organic foods state clearly that organic food certified by Ottawa cannot contain genetically-modified organisms, and that producers wanted to advertise that to consumers.

”There were many products, including cereals, salad dressings and hot chocolate mixes, that were certified organic to make it clear to customers that those foods do not have genetically-modified organism ingredients. Those manufacturers want that on the labels, and they were forced to remove those labels.”

At least 35 countries have adopted mandatory labelling for any product that has been genetically modified.

The European Union (EU) introduced measures three years ago that include strict labelling and monitoring of GM foods, feeds, seeds and pharmaceuticals.

The government’s Health Canada has said that GM foods are just as safe as conventional foods.

Neighbouring Washington continues to back corporations that produce GM seeds and crops. U.S. Trade Representative Robert B. Zoellnick recently called the EU position on GM foods "Luddite" and "immoral". David Byrne, the EU’s health and consumer protection commissioner, called Zoellnick’s remarks "unhelpful", "unfair" and "wrong".

The U.S. agricultural biotech industry opposes labelling. "Labelling is a sham," said Mary Kay Thatcher, lobbyist for the American Farm Bureau. "It would be so expensive, it would shut down our exports."

Labelling "implies that there is something wrong with genetically modified food", said Elsa Murano, the U.S. agriculture department’s undersecretary for food safety. "It would be another kind of trade barrier."

Saturday’s consumer actions will take place in countries ranging from Nigeria to Ecuador, Vietnam, Trinidad to Ukraine.

In Jamaica, protesters will launch a study into the prevalence of GM foods in the local markets and will lobby for regulations to protect consumers, while in Vietnam, actions will take place in 18 different provinces.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags