Thursday, November 19, 2026
Tran Dinh Thanh Lam
- -Nguyen Thi No is 45, was once a guerrilla at Cu Chi the fabled tunnel bastion near this southern Vietnamese city used during the war against the United States in the 1970s – and now is determined to have a child.
It was the news last month, of the birth of Vietnam’s first baby conceived from a frozen embryo, at the state-run Tu Du Obstetrics Hospital here that galvanised No into action. "I must go to Tu Du to get help and deliver my own baby," she said excitedly, adding that she has neither the time nor the opportunity to marry and conceive.
No typifies a dilemma for health authorities and planners, and the medical infrastructure in Vietnam today.
A new population ordinance, issued in February and effective from May 1, 2003, permits only infertile couples and single women between 20 and 45 to turn to in-vitro fertilisation (IVF) – a process where fertilisation occurs in a laboratory after eggs and sperm have been collected – as a means of conception.
"It’s a very progressive ordinance," said Dr Nguyen Viet Tien, head of the IVF department at the Institute for the Protection of Infants and Mothers.
"The new ordinance has finally set a legal framework for IVF," said Dr Nguyen Thi Ngoc Phuong, director of Tu Du Obstetrics Hospital, where in August 1997 Vietnam’s IVF programme began. The success of that programme brought infertile couples flocking to the hospital, and when the waiting list for the treatment became too long for some, they turned to private clinics.
These were either not permitted to provide IVF or were inadequately-equipped to dispense it. Following several accidents at illegal clinics, the government suspended IVF in June 2001. In the interim, specialists at Tu Du improved their techniques, as became apparent with the birth from a frozen embryo.
The IVF programme at Tu Du has been a medical success with the births of 350 babies. The new procedure – which freezes unused embryos during the process of the initial IVF, for later implanting – is resorted to only if the IVF treatment proves unsuccessful. Tu Du Hospital now stores embryos which can be offered to sterile women like No.
That is only if No hurries. Upon turning 46, she will be prohibited from applying for sperm or ova to conceive using the IVF method. Dr Phuong says there is good medical reasoning to support the age limit. "It is difficult to take the ova of mothers over 45. The chance of success is small, and the rate of congenital defects among children of these mothers is high."
Yet according to data from the Ministry of Public Health, demand for IVF services comes from both infertile couples and middle-aged women. Le Thi Phuong Anh, a social worker at Ho Chi Minh City Women’s Union, explained the reason behind one source of that demand and provided a moral perspective.
"What happens to women over 45 who still hope to enjoy the unique experience of motherhood?" asked Anh. "There are currently thousands of veteran women (those who, like No, gave years of their lives during the war) of 46 or 47 who remain single after devoting their youth to the nation. They would all cherish a baby of their own. Our duty is to help them."
With a population of around 80 million, Vietnam is estimated to have between 1 million and 1.3 million infertile couples, who represent nearly 4 per cent of all the couples in the country. To this number is added the approximately one million single women who wish to have a baby.
Anh also raised the issue of the cost of IVF. "If the ordinance on IVF is good news, it’s only good news for middle-class people who could afford it," she said. Those who seek IVF treatment will find that it sets them back by about 15.4 million dong (1,000 U.S. dollars) – this is four times the combined monthly household income of the average couple, and at current rates of saving would take several years to accumulate.
And even for those who can afford it, the new ordinance places further conditions. Though permitting the donation of either fertilised ova or sperm, the use of surrogate mothers is banned.
This has generated much debate among health officials, law experts and sociologists. "The number of sterile women wanting to have a baby through the assistance of surrogate mothers is very high, higher than that of single women wanting to conceive via IVF," said Anh. "By banning the use of surrogate mothers, the new ordinance has deprived these women of their last hope to have a baby of their own."
The rationale for the ban, according to the Ministry of Public Health’s department of law, is to "avoid any possible controversy". There have indeed been disputes between "real mothers" and "surrogate mothers" over motherhood rights. The ban will end this, said the department, by applying the "principle of ‘who is pregnant is the mother of the child’ ".
Dr Phuong of Tu Du Hospital would however prefer that the issue be under review. "There are young women who suffer from uterus fibroma or have had their uterus removed, and therefore can no longer bear children," she said. Pending the resolving of IVF-related issues, she said "we could consider allowing the use of surrogate mothers on a per case basis".
Would-be mother No may beat the deadline yet, but it is Anh who places the issue in the context of a Vietnam that is still struggling with economic reforms of more than a decade now. "Poor people constitute the majority of the population and, like everywhere in the world, they usually have lots of children," she said. "Their priorities therefore are more food, better health care and fewer children."