Monday, November 16, 2026
Bob Burton
- On the second anniversary of the Australian government’s blocking of a Norwegian container ship from bringing rescued asylum seekers to land on Australian soil, activists remain appalled at the government’s hardline policy toward refugees.
Amnesty International refugee coordinator, Dr Graham Thom, is dismayed that the Australian government is refusing to allow nine Iraqi and Afghan women and 14 children, held in an Australian government funded immigration prison on the Pacific island nation of Nauru, to be re-united with their husbands and fathers in Australia.
”There is no real justification for doing this,” Thom said.
While the husbands and fathers of those held on Nauru have been accepted by Australia as refugees and granted three-year ‘temporary protection visas’, the government refuses to adopt the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) practice of granting ‘derivative’ status to family members.
Such status would ensure that if a family member is accepted as having a legitimate fear of persecution, this would extend to other family members – and the family would be reunited.
When the Nauru immigration prison was established in late 2001, the Australian government insisted it would operate to UNHCR standards. ”However, they have now turned around and say no we are not going to recognise derivative status à and so it is using that to keep these women and children separated,” Thom said.
If the women and children decide not to voluntarily return to Afghanistan or Iraq, they will be detained indefinitely amongst the 402 asylum seekers, including 108 children, being held on Nauru.
On Aug. 26, 2001, Australian Prime Minister John Howard refused permission for the MV Tampa to land the 438 asylum seekers on Christmas Island, even though they were rescued from a sinking boat at the request of Australian search and rescue authorities.
Three days later, Howard directed Special Air Services (SAS) officers board the Tampa to prevent it from landing on Australian shores even though it had issued a mayday call.
Instead, the Australian government hastily cobbled together what it dubbed the ‘Pacific Solution’ – the creation of special immigration prisons on Nauru and Manus Island in Papua New Guinea to accommodate those forcibly relocated from the Tampa, and from later boats that were intercepted in Australian waters.
The U.N. Convention on the Rights of the Child, ratified by Australia in 1990, requires that signatory nations shall not deprive children of their liberty unlawfully or arbitrarily. It further specifies that detention should only be used only as a last resort and for as short a period of time as possible. On Monday – in what is regarded as a landmark legal case – the full bench of the Family Court of Australia ordered that five children, who cannot be named for legal reasons, be released from the Baxter immigration detention centre in South Australia.
The court order brought an end to a 14-month legal battle of the two teenage boys and their three younger sisters who had been imprisoned for nearly three years.
The court had been told that one of the boys attempted to hang himself while imprisoned and his brother had participated in a hunger strike.
In announcing their decision, the judges took a swipe at the refusal of Minister for Immigration Philip Ruddock to release the children. ”The minister’s interest in detaining them in unlawful detention seems somewhat curious,” the judges said.
The decision has angered Ruddock, who will appeal against the decision to the High Court of Australia.
”We believe that a government is elected to govern, and a government is elected to make decisions about who is or is not able to enter Australia and settle permanently, and that these decisions should not be essentially removed from the government of the day’s hands through judicial activism,” Ruddock said on Tuesday.
The national director of A Just Australia, Howard Glenn, welcomes the decision but acknowledges the magnitude of the challenge to overturn the government’s policy. ”It is great that these five kids are taken out of detention, but there are another hundred and ninety six to go,” he said.
While the legal win has buoyed refugee advocates, the forced deportation of two Iranian men last weekend was a sobering reminder of the government’s determination to expel those it has refused to accept as refugees.
Amnesty International has expressed alarm that those deported may be at great risk of human rights violations on their return to Iran. ”We are concerned there is not going to be any monitoring as to whether these people encounter human rights violations,” Thom said.
A further hundred Iranians – currently held in detention centres – are likely to be deported in coming months.
In the two years since the Tampa was turned back, refugee support groups have made some headway in whittling away at the government’s refugee policies. Protests inside and outside the Woomera detention centre, located in the South Australian desert, forced its closure.
The opposition Labour Party – which two years ago backed the government’s hardline policy against refugees – on Tuesday announced a major policy switch, embracing proposals from community groups to expedite decisions on asylum applications of the approximately 400 still held in detention.
Glenn also senses that the belligerence of the Howard government is slowly waning too. ”It is no longer a situation where the government is proud of and boast about, but a situation where they have to continually justify their policy in the face of all sorts of international and domestic criticisms,” he said.