Tuesday, November 17, 2026
Katherine Stapp
- Documents leaked this week to a civil society group show that the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has been conducting secret negotiations with agribusiness lobbyists to allow giant animal farms to pollute indefinitely without being prosecuted.
A draft consent agreement between the industry and EPA, sent by an anonymous source in the government agency to the Sierra Club, would exempt huge animal feeding operations, which emit toxins like ammonia and hydrogen sulphide, from complying with provisions of the Clean Air Act.
In return, the companies would pay a 500-dollar fine and 2,500 dollars per farm to participate in a study to monitor their emissions.
The EPA had previously denied that such a deal was being negotiated.
”As evidenced by the leaked agreement, we know that there have been ongoing discussions between EPA and the meat industry regarding enforcement of the Clean Air Act,” said Barclay Rogers, a Sierra Club attorney.
”Given the secrecy that has shrouded this deal, it’s possible they would have announced it with no time for meaningful public comment, and presented it as a fait accompli.”
Studies in the states of North Carolina and Iowa found increased symptoms of headache, runny nose, sore throat, excessive coughing, diarrhoea and burning eyes among residents living near giant hog farms.
The enormous lagoons of manure generated by the animals are also a significant source of methane, one of the greenhouse gases implicated in global warming.
Environmental groups say the deal is another sign of the EPA’s shift under the George W. Bush administration to a culture of placing corporate interests over public health.
”What’s going on reflects the neo-conservative philosophy that government should ease the regulatory burden on polluters rather than requiring their compliance with the law,” Brent Newell of the Centre on Race, Poverty and the Environment (CRPE) told IPS.
”The backroom deal is one chapter in a long chain of events during which the Bush administration has endeavoured to administratively exempt this industry from the Clean Air Act.”
”It is a very different type of regulatory philosophy, and is reflected in the way the administration has tried to dismantle a broad array of environmental protections, from the Clean Water Act to wilderness conservation,” Newell added.
Revelations of the deal come on the heels of intense criticism that the EPA misled New Yorkers about the air quality in lower Manhattan in the aftermath of the Sep. 11, 2001 terrorist attacks on the World Trade Centre.
Although EPA officials quickly assured people it was safe to return to their homes, a recent analysis determined that they lacked the scientific data to make this assertion but were pressured to do so by the White House.
Since Bush first took office, the agency has been at loggerheads with environmental groups and many Democrats over nearly every single policy decision, from easing limits on factory and car pollution to drilling for oil in a pristine Alaskan wildlife refuge.
A study last year found that the Bush EPA had brought nearly 50 percent fewer actions against polluters than were undertaken under the previous administration.
On Wednesday, the CRPE, along with the Sierra Club and the Natural Resources Defence Council, filed a lawsuit in Washington DC seeking further details about the farm emissions deal in hopes of pressuring the agency to back down.
The EPA describes the document, now posted on the Sierra Club’s web site, as "nothing more than a draft … of a potential voluntary agreement."
"It’s a way to get solid information on an industry that has not been regulated," an agency spokesperson told Reuters news agency. (IPS’ calls to the EPA were not returned).
But Ken Midkiff of the Sierra Club says ”EPA claims that environmental groups were kept informed are a damned lie”.
”We know people within the agency who said ‘there’s something going on now and you need to know about it’,” said Midkiff, referring to the leaked document. ”Previously, there was nothing in the public record.”
Sierra Club first got wind of the deal in May, when it obtained a copy of a confidential industry proposal that essentially mirrors the draft consent agreement.
The group’s attorneys then formally asked the EPA for more information about any ”safe harbour” deal. They were told no such agreement existed.
Sierra Club later discovered that not only were negotiations ongoing at that time, but that two associations of state and local air pollution control agencies had walked away from the talks in April and sent a letter of protest to the EPA expressing ”serious concerns regarding the direction the administration is taking with respect to agricultural air emissions”.
Since 1999, the poultry, livestock and dairy industries have paid out more than 19 million dollars in political contributions, about three-quarters of that to Bush’s Republican Party, according to the Centre for Responsive Politics.
Congress is now on the verge of confirming a new administrator for the EPA, since former chief Christie Whitman resigned her post in May.
Bush’s nominee, Utah Governor Mike Leavitt, has drawn fire from environmental groups for failing to enforce clean water laws and cutting closed-door deals with the administration to open Utah wilderness areas for oil and gas drilling, mining and off-road vehicle use.
Leavitt also has a poor record of handling complaints about factory farm pollution in his home state, they add. He helped to pass a law that bars citizens from bringing nuisance lawsuits against agricultural businesses, while a massive hog operation in Beaver County with a long history of manure spills and groundwater contamination has only paid nominal state pollution penalties.
”Leavitt has been pretty complicit in this entire thing,” said Midkiff. ”We don’t see any benefit in having him as administrator.”