Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Economy & Trade, Headlines, Human Rights, Labour, Population

LABOUR-VIETNAM: Use, Abuse of Child Workers Growing

Tran Dinh Thanh Lam

HO CHI MINH CITY, Vietnam, Sep 2 2003 (IPS) - Le Thi Kim Duyen, 13, was used to working to help her parents and earn money for her tuition, but nothing prepared her for the accident she met at the wood processing factory last month.

Duyen was rushed to the city’s Pediatric Hospital after her right arm was trapped into a grinder, and doctors had to take skin from her thighs to graft into her arm.

”It was the first time that I operated the machine,” Duyen said. Before that, she never received any training or instructions on how to operate the wood processing tool in the factory.

”The boss told me to take the place of a worker who happened to go on holiday,” explained the schoolgirl from Long An, a province 20 kilometres from this southern Vietnamese city.

Increasing cases of accidents like Duyen’s, officials say, show that as business people look for ways to cut production costs and increase profit margins, they are also hiring children and youngsters to do what used to be adults’ jobs.

Often, economics is a reason why youngsters like Duyen take on these risky jobs, with little protection or benefits.

Born into a poor family, Duyen spent all her summer vacation this year working at the wood processing enterprise at Go Vap district here in order to have money to pay for her tuition next schoolyear.

”When I started work two months ago, the owner promised to pay me 18,000 Vietnamese dong a day. However, I have not received a cent since then,” Duyen said.

Still, she considers herself luckier than a 15-year-old girl named Minh Tam, who had to work from 7 p.m. to 6 a.m. at a food processing factory at Lai Thieu, on the outskirts of Ho Chi Minh City.

On Jul. 22, she fell asleep out of exhaustion, fell on a food mixer – and severed her left arm. Orthopaedic surgeons undertook a six-hour operation on her afterwards.

Yet after she woke up from surgery, Minh Tam had no other concern than to resume her job. Asked whether she intended to file any claim against her employer, Tam said, ”I wish my boss would allow me to work again.”

All she wanted, she said, was to keep her job. ”It’s far better than selling lottery tickets on the streets,” Tam said.

Like Tam, many children who are victims of labour accidents never think of asking for any form of compensation. All they want is to keep their work, which to them offers at least a chance to make break out of the poverty trap.

According to the estimates by the Ministry of Labour, War Invalids and Social Affairs, some 22,000 children have had to enter the workforce to earn a living in the country.

More than 50 percent sell postcards, offer shoeshining services, or wash dishes for a living. The rest had to do manual work from eight 12 hours a day at private enterprises, earning an average of 64 cents a day.

Their bosses do not sign any labour contract with them, which means the youngsters can be sacked any time without any compensation.

Officials put the estimated number of working children in Ho Chi Minh City at 10,500, of which some 6,200 are boys. More than half of these children are from families that migrate to the southern economic hub in search for jobs and a better life.

”Around 3,800 children currently working in the city exploited by their bosses,” said Nguyen Tam, an official at city’s Department of Labour, War Invalids and Social Affairs.

On Jul. 1, police officers at District 6 arrested the owner of a private plastic enterprise for exploiting child labour. A dozen children aged from 10 to 15 years old were forced to work 12 hours a day there, and fed no more than two bowls of rice a day.

”We are severely beaten if we failed to fulfill our task. The boss refuses to give us salary in order to prevent us from leaving and abandoning the job,” said Nguyen Minh, who did not receive any payment after two months of work.

Minh and two other children managed to escape, and reported their case to the police.

”Obviously, these business people are breaking the law,” said Le Ban, a lawyer. Vietnam’s Labour Law prohibits child labour and reserves severe penalties for owners of enterprises who hire children to perform work reserved for adults.

”In the case of Le Thi Kim Duyen, her boss will be held accountable for three major penalties. He will be penalised for hiring children to do the job of skilled workers without providing them any training and safety measures,” Ban said.

In the past two years, around 20 businesses have been brought to face charges in the courts for child labour and abuse, but officials say the penalties seem not to have discouraged other employers.

Then there is the fact that they know that many children need economic means to survive, and will do take up jobs anyway even if the law says otherwise – a dilemma for officials.

”If we tightened the rules, poor children would find it hard to get a job and to earn a living. But if we did nothing to enforce the law, these children could become easy prey for rapacious employers,” Tam said. For now, authorities have allowed businesses to hire ”old children”, those from 16 to 17 years old, and train them to become skilled workers.

Businesses however, must register their junior labour force with local officials. ”This is a way to assist young migrant workers coming from rural areas,” Tam explained.

In particular, light industry sectors like seafood processing, garments and footwear manufacturing – require large numbers of young workers, and owners of private enterprises prefer to hire young migrant workers who ask for nothing more than to have a stable job.

”We know that many private enterprises have employed ‘old children’ but did not register them with the authorities. But we would keep our eyes shut, as if nothing (no incident) happened,” Tam confided, calling this an informal way of helping young workers make some kind of living.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags