Headlines, Human Rights, North America

RIGHTS: Bush Abortion Ban Could Echo Overseas, Says Activist

Miriam Kagan

WASHINGTON, Nov 7 2003 (IPS) - As President George W. Bush signed into law the most far-reaching restrictions on abortion in three decades this week, pro-choice activists turned to the courts to block the move and warned of the danger the new law posed to women’s rights overseas.

The ban, thrice passed by Congress and twice vetoed by former president Bill Clinton, bans all late-term abortions using the dilation and extraction (D&X) procedure, dubbed ”partial birth abortion” by the right-to-life community.

D&X has been particularly controversial because it is usually performed after the fifth month of pregnancy, and involves partially removing the foetus from the womb.

Signing the bill Wednesday, Bush proclaimed, ”today at last the American people and our government have confronted the violence and come to the defence of the innocent child".

The right to life "cannot be granted or denied by government because it does not come from the government. It comes from the creator of life", he added.

Pro-choice supporters saw the ban in a different light.


"In signing this law, President Bush has demonstrated his willingness to sacrifice women’s health and legitimate medical science to appease anti-choice hardliners," Planned Parenthood Federation of America President Gloria Feldt said in a statement.

"It represents one more step in this administration’s efforts to undermine reproductive rights, with the ultimate goal of overturning ‘Roe v Wade’ (a 1973 Supreme Court decision legitimising abortion) and abolishing safe, legal abortion," she added.

Pro-choice activists are particularly concerned because the ban does not have an exception that will allow the procedure to be performed if the mother’s health is at risk.

In 2002, a federal court struck down a similar ban by the state of Nevada because it lacked a woman’s health exemption.

Pro-choice activists also worry because the broad language of the bill could be interpreted as not being limited only to D&X.

Most estimates show that of the 1.4 million abortions performed in the United States in 2000, at most 4,000 were D&X abortions.

Pro choice supporters argue that the pro life community will not be satisfied with prohibiting less than one percent of abortions and will seek to expand the ban.

Concerns also abound that the law violates basic civil liberties.

A statement by the American College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists says, "the ban violates the fundamental principle at the very heart of the doctor-patient relationship: that the doctor, in consultation with the patient, based on the patient’s individual circumstances, must choose the most appropriate method of care for the patient".

The bill’s opponents also note that Bush’s numerous references to God and the creationist theory of life tread on the separation of church and state provided for in the U.S. Constitution.

Pro-choice activists vowed to fight anti-abortion support with renewed energy and commitment.

"We will not allow Bush and his buddies to erode our rights. We will take our case to the courts, to the streets to the ballot box," promised Kim Grandy, president of the National Organisation for Women.

Their first victory came when federal judges in Nevada, New York and San Francisco blocked or stayed the ban on Thursday and Friday.

Despite that temporary relief at home, activists say the ban could have serious global repercussions.

"We are very, very concerned about how this action will be interpreted overseas," Barbara Crane, director of IPAS, an international organisation dedicated to ending unsafe abortion, told IPS.

"The fine points of the ban will be lost in the translation overseas and will open the door for continuing efforts to restrict abortions," she argued.

Each year an estimated 46 million abortions occur worldwide, of which over 20 million procedures are obtained illegally.

One women die each day in Asia alone from unsafe abortions, according to the World Health Organisation (WHO).

Pro choice activists argue that taken in conjunction with the Mexico City policy – a global gag order prohibiting any groups that receive funds from the U.S. Agency for International Development or the State Department from providing, informing, or discussing abortion with their patients – the new ban is part of the Bush administration’s global strategy to pressure and bully countries and NGOs from providing abortion services to women.

According to Crane, those policies are "affecting agencies, for example the World Health Organisation and the U.N., who are intimidated by the political force they see behind the Bush policies".

”The only thing that will help women overseas is a change in government in the U.S.," she added.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags