Development & Aid, Headlines, Health, Human Rights, North America

RIGHTS-U.S.: Mentally Ill Packed Off to Death Row

Katherine Stapp

NEW YORK, Nov 6 2003 (IPS) - The planned executions of three mentally ill prisoners within a two-week stretch is drawing national attention to what public health experts and lawyers say is a pervasive and unconstitutional human rights violation in the United States.

Early Friday morning the state of North Carolina plans to execute Joseph Keel for the 1990 murder of his father-in-law. Although Keel suffers from brain damage and other psychological problems, his original lawyers failed to raise these mitigating factors at trial. He later missed a key deadline to claim ineffective counsel.

(A recent study found that one of every six death row inmates in North Carolina had been represented by lawyers who were later disbarred, suspended or otherwise disciplined by the state.)

“Keel has three layers of mental disability – retardation, mental illness and brain injury,” his attorney Jay Ferguson told IPS. “He is currently being treated for psychotic episodes.”

The U.S. Supreme Court barred the execution of mentally retarded offenders last year, but advocates believe many retarded prisoners remain on death rows across the country. Mental retardation is defined in most states as an IQ (intelligence quotient) of 70 or lower.

Severe mental illness – a separate issue – afflicts at least 370 other condemned inmates, according to the National Mental Health Association. This category includes schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, psychosis, major depression and suicidal thoughts.


Some people with mental illnesses, like Keel, suffer from both brain damage and a serious personality disorder.

“One problem is that the definition of mental retardation is different from state to state. North Carolina has an absolute cut-off of 70 IQ, and Keel’s actual score was 78,” Ferguson said. “At this point, the governor is the last chance.”

A spokesperson for Gov Mike Easley, the only person with the authority to halt the execution, said he met Keel’s attorneys Tuesday. A clemency decision is expected Thursday or Friday.

Easley will also decide the fate of John Dennis Daniels, scheduled for lethal injection Nov. 14, who psychiatrists testified has “the emotional and social development of an 11- or 12-year-old child”.

North Carolina ranks third in the United States in executions this year, after Texas and Oklahoma.

The third inmate, James Willie Brown, was executed in Georgia state on Tuesday. He had been diagnosed with paranoid schizophrenia 17 times, but was ultimately deemed competent to stand trial. He was the 58th prisoner put to death in the United States this year.

“The point is that we prohibit the execution of the mentally retarded, but people who are mentally ill can be even more disabled and yet they can be executed,” said Stephen Bright, director of the Southern Centre for Human Rights, a Georgia-based public interest law firm specialising in capital cases.

“Right from the start, most lawyers are not sophisticated, the courts don’t provide resources to hire competent expert witnesses to do psychological and neurological testing, and all of this is decided in the context of these very emotional trials where the passions of the moment so often seem to trump everything else,” Bright said.

Amnesty International estimates that five to 10 percent of condemned prisoners in the United States have a serious mental illness.

The problem is hardly confined to death row. According to a recent report by Human Rights Watch (HRW), one in six U.S. inmates is mentally ill. Many suffer from serious disorders such as schizophrenia and manic depression.

This means there are three times as many men and women with mental illness in U.S. prisons as in mental health hospitals. Very few receive any treatment, the group found.

“The justice system can’t properly identify people with mental illness,” said Hazel Moran of the National Mental Health Association. “There may not be qualified mental health professionals doing the assessments of whether the person has diminished mental capacity. It’s arbitrary.”

Moran told IPS that among juvenile offenders, about 80 percent show symptoms of mental illness.

“There really needs to be an expansion of available mental health facilities,” she said. “Unfortunately, budgets are being cut and social services are the last to get funding to expand, or just to continue the work they’re doing.”

Experts point to the evisceration of the country’s mental health system in recent decades – more than 90 percent of beds in psychiatric wards are gone – as one major reason prisons are filling with ill inmates.

“We need to educate the public about who is being executed,” said David Elliot of the National Coalition to Abolish the Death Penalty. “These are people who can’t be held culpable for their actions.”

“The Supreme Court set an incredibly low standard for execution of the mentally ill,” he said in an interview. “Basically, you just have to understand that you’re being executed.”

“You can be so far gone you can’t help your attorneys, you can’t remember your alibi, where you were, or what you were doing – but you’re still eligible for the death penalty.”

No state explicitly permits the execution of a mentally ill prisoner, but in practice, competency standards are so low as to permit severely ill people to be held fully accountable for their behaviour, legal scholars say.

Most death penalty opponents hope for a blanket moratorium on the practice, but concede that a piecemeal approach to abolition may be more practical.

For instance, the United States is under increasing international pressure to stop executing juvenile offenders.

Since 1994, Amnesty International has documented 20 executions of child offenders in five countries – the Democratic Republic of Congo, Iran, Nigeria, Pakistan and the United States.

Thirteen of those executions occurred in the United States, where nearly one-half of states permit capital punishment for a person who committed a crime while under the age of 18.

“The Supreme Court is very close to abolishing the death penalty for juveniles,” Elliot said.

“Then it will be a matter of getting the court to revisit the issues of severe mental illness, inadequate counsel, racism – it’s an incremental process.”

Whether or not a person is put to death in the United States often depends simply on where the crime was committed.

On Wednesday, a 54-year-old truck painter named Gary Leon Ridgway admitted to the murders of 48 women in the Green River area of Washington State, in exchange for a life sentence. The confession made Ridgway the most prolific serial killer in U.S. history..

“This system is supposed to be reserved for the most heinous and incorrigible crimes, but you look at the Green River case, where there was no death penalty because he pled guilty,” said Bright. “It doesn’t make any sense.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags