Monday, November 16, 2026
Katherine Stapp
- "Democracy," the rapier-tongued writer H.L. Mencken once observed, "is the theory that the common people know what they want and deserve to get it good and hard."
As the United States lurches into another election cycle, officials around the country are rushing to avert a replay of the debacle of 2000, when thousands of African American voters were rejected at polling sites, and fancifully designed ballots prompted hundreds of others to inadvertently choose a Holocaust revisionist over Democratic contender Al Gore.
Not to mention the infamous "hanging chads" and "pregnant chads" – those tiny pieces of paper shed (or not quite) by punch-card machines in Florida that inspired frenzied speculation over the voters’ true "intent" in an election that was won by a remarkable 537 votes.
Having received 3.9 billion dollars in federal aid to prevent such a spectacle from ever recurring, dozens of states are abandoning traditional paper ballots in favour of electronic systems that allow people to vote by touching a screen or flipping a switch.
In theory, computerised voting eliminates human error from the tabulation process, a problem that experts say is all too common. But many security gurus worry that the electronic systems are vulnerable to hacking, fraud and voter confusion.
And because the software code they use is considered "proprietary", outside programmers have been largely barred from performing independent evaluations.
"With many computerised systems, there is no recourse," he added in an interview. "We know that technicians at the county level have been known to rig mechanical lever voting machines."
"Why should we believe that technicians or programmers will not attempt similar fixes with direct recording electronic voting systems?"
A recent study one touch-screen system used in 37 states last year, sold by an Ohio-based company called Diebold, found problems with the vote-tallying software and a host of other loopholes.
"I’ve been teaching computer security for years, and my students would never design something like this," said Aviel Rubin, a professor at Johns Hopkins University who led the study. "You’re looking at Swiss cheese. There’s not much you can do to fix the system."
The chief of Diebold, Walden O’Dell, raised eyebrows in August when the press got wind of a George W. Bush fund-raiser invitation in which he declared: "I am committed to helping Ohio deliver its electoral votes to the president next year".
Diebold insists that the Johns Hopkins study was flawed and stands by its product, although a recent audit of the company’s voting machines in California found that it had installed uncertified software in all 17 counties that use its equipment.
With cries of foul play multiplying, the consensus among many elections officials and security experts is that voting machines should also print out a paper receipt, something California has promised to introduce by 2006.
Other states are following suit, and the issue has been taken up by the new federal Election Assistance Commission and the National Institute of Science and Technology, although it is unlikely printers will be in place in time for the November 2004 elections.
"Current touch-screen systems record votes in electronic memory," said David Dill, a computer science professor at Stanford University. "The recording process and the resulting records can’t be observed by anyone. If the computer records something different from what the voter wanted, no one knows about it."
"Each voter needs to be able to inspect the record that is made of his or her vote," Dill said. "Those records need to be saved for a later recount, if required."
But others are not so sure that creating a paper trail is the solution.
"Trying to retrofit an electronic voting machine with a paper roll and printer will undoubtedly result in printer jams on election day, which will delay voting and then folks won’t want to wait," Denise Lamb, director of elections in the state of New Mexico, told IPS.
"(Another) problem is that paper ballot systems are not accessible to the visually impaired or alternate language speakers," she said. "There’s the issue, for New Mexico and other states with Native American populations, of languages that are not written."
Felicia Davis, coordinator of the National Coalition on Black Civic Participation’s Election Protection Programme in Georgia, expressed concerns that voters could end up staying home because they lacked confidence in the new system.
"In the wake of the Florida fiasco, the public is seeking assurances which are difficult to translate into lay terms when applied to electronic systems," Davis said. "It is a fact that all systems can fail and the question that persists is, absent a paper trail how would such a failure be detected?"
In the last election, nearly 10,000 ballots cast by heavily Democratic-leaning black voters in Florida State were disqualified. These spoiled ballots had a crucial impact on the outcome since U.S. President George W. Bush won Florida by a handful of votes, giving him the presidency under the U.S. voting system although he lost the popular vote.
When they go to the polls to vote for president next November, more than one-half of Florida’s 9.4 million registered voters will be using touch-screen systems.
"Communities that have been systematically disenfranchised in the past must remain vigilant, and an important aspect is becoming knowledgeable about the new technology, asking questions and demanding verification," Davis said.
"Research is needed to determine that the technology does not suppress the vote."
In the end, experts say, no system is foolproof – but measures can and should be taken to minimise the chance of mistakes or deliberate vote theft.
"Examples like Enron and Worldcom provide excellent examples of what happens when accounting systems are allowed to run without adequate auditing oversight," said Jones.
"Accounting for votes is no less important than accounting for dollars, and I don’t see why we should not demand comparable standards of accountability," he added. "If they decide to start rigging things, they could have a state-wide or even a nationwide effect, posing the threat of wholesale fraud."