Wednesday, November 18, 2026
Kafil Yamin
- Thousands of village cooperatives in Papua, Indonesia’s easternmost province, are at risk of collapsing after being deceived by unscrupulous traders, whose way of extracting profits is also fuelling the widespread disappearance of high-value trees.
Thus far, activists here say, at least 450 village cooperatives in Jayapura city have already collapsed after foreign traders took off with timber that locals provided them,
Villagers’ troubles in this timber-rich district began in late 2003 when businessmen, mostly from Malaysia, started making timber deals with local cooperatives. Like others, these traders turned to Papua because forest resources elsewhere in Indonesia are dwindling rapidly.
Indonesian regulation stipulates that locals be represented by cooperatives when they engage in business deals to ensure that proceeds are distributed equitably. Villagers, with the help of the timber businessmen, established the necessary cooperatives in order to reach an agreement.
Officially, the cooperatives represent all villagers, but, in fact, they are usually controlled by two or three people who involved in the negotiations.
Agreements called for a 10 percent advance payment, with traders paying the balance once they had the timber in hand. Drawing on traditional skills to cut and remove trees, it took locals just a few weeks to meet their end of the deal. The traders, however, fulfilled their end. They took the ‘merbau’ logs and fled, without completing payment.
”All we got was just a small amount of money which is only enough for another month of surviving,” said Abner Korwa, a resident of Kerom village, Merauke.
Such criminal deceptions are common in Papua, according to Edison Giai, chairman of the Study on the Empowerment of the Traditional Community Institutions (SPMA). He said many local tribal leaders told of similar experiences at a forum he organised earlier in April.
In Ulim Sari district, for example, locals received only 15,000 rupiah (two U.S. dollars), a pack of salt and instant noodles for three months’ work cutting and removing timber.
”So, if we calculate the whole thing, the foul-minded businessmen actually got all the high-value timber for free,” Edison said.
Police in Jayapura estimate that, in the three-month period beginning in November, timber traders smuggled 60,744 cubic metres of merbau wood out of the district, most of it destined for Malaysia, China, Hong Kong and Thailand.
On Jan. 15 Malaysians were arrested by Papuan police for deceiving cooperatives and smuggling timber. They were caught with 10,124 ‘merbau’ logs. Another 32 Malaysian timber traders were arrested last year on similar charges. None of the suspects has yet been brought to court.
Most cases go unsettled or unreported because local authorities and legal institutions are unaware of the agreements. Justice is also stymied by the fact that many of the agreements between cooperatives and timber traders are not legally binding.
”The agreements are usually unwritten. They are just made through oral negotiations in very flexible circumstances,” Edison explained. ”By the traditional nature, the locals are easy to trust the businessmen’s words.”
The agreements are further undermined by the fact that cooperatives are often established hastily for a specific timber deal.
Collapsing village cooperatives are only part of threat to tribal ownership of forests. Villagers also face serious challenges from companies with logging concessions and those seeking to establish tree plantations. The native communities are most often on the losing side.
Outside companies come with legal equipment such as written licence, written contract and written agreements. However, the tribal tradition is for such things to be unwritten and executed in flexible ways.
”When a conflict arises between a company and tribe communities and they go to court, everybody can easily guess that the tribe community will lose,” Edison said. He added, ”What will happen next is that the people take the law into their own hands. They run amok and the security will put out the unrest on accusations that they make trouble.”
In effort to overcome these disadvantages, Edison works with local activists to develop a network to make tribes and their traditional institutions more powerful.
SPMA organises regular forums to discuss means for tribes to protect their communal lands and properties with area mapping, which includes traditional borders and tribal properties, a top priority.
The tribal assets are then registered, alerting local government administrators, businesses and the public to the fact that the listed lands belong to certain communities.
The forums also assist tribal leaders in learning to manage conflicts among themselves, according to Edison, who sees this as an encouraging development. He said that conflicts among tribes, which are usually triggered by overlapping claims on lands, have been reduced ”significantly” over the past five months.
”By nature they are good leaders,” Edison said, referring to community elders. ”They have charisma, self-confidence and wisdom. To me, they are more qualified for leading the society than the current politicians are.”
The only party that still needs to develop understanding and respect is the business community, according to Edison. ”I am not saying that all businessmen are cunning and foul,” he said, ”but many of them behave unfairly.”