Development & Aid, Economy & Trade, Europe, Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines, Labour

LABOUR: Developing Countries ‘Trading Rights for Investment’

Stefania Bianchi

BRUSSELS, Dec 6 2004 (IPS) - Employers in developing countries are sacrificing workers’ rights to attract foreign investment, says a report launched Tuesday.

Workers’ rights in export processing zones (EPZs) are being violated as developing countries are forced to "employ tax breaks and a liberal labour policy" to draw investors in search of cheaper and more docile labour, says the Brussels-based International Confederation of Free Trade Unions (ICFTU) which represents some 148 million workers in 152 countries.

The report ‘Behind the Brands – Working Conditions and Workers’ Rights in Export Processing Zones’ was launched at the 18th world congress of ICFTU. The congress being held in Miyazaki, Japan, is examining the effects of globalisation on workers rights. It began Sunday and is due to conclude Thursday (Dec. 10).

EPZs are areas established by governments to encourage manufacture of goods for export. Since the 1970s the zones have become important instruments of economic policy. Governments seeking to attract foreign investors offer financial incentives and a liberal regulatory environment in return for employment creation and export earnings.

ICFTU says the number of EPZs grew from just 79 in 25 countries in 1975 to more than 3,000 in 116 nations in 2002. Employment in the zones has leapt from a few thousand to just under 42 million in 2004. The majority of these workers are women.

But ICFTU warns in its report that the increase in the number of EPZs has been matched by "a weakening of protection for workers who usually have no choice but to accept poverty wages, excessive working hours and abusive conditions" as EPZ employers are often either "exempt from employment and other legislation or benefit from lax enforcement."


Although EPZs are often held up as a way for countries to develop their economies ICFTU says "serious questions" remain over the real benefits of EPZs for development. "The value of EPZs to their host nations, particularly in the long-term, is unclear," the report says. "They are costly in terms of the infrastructure they require, use few local inputs, and provide little or no tax revenue for their host countries."

ICFTU also warns that the very nature of EPZ investment is precarious and that it can leave the country "at a moment’s notice" if more favourable conditions are on offer elsewhere.

"In no country has it been shown that free trade zones are a real path to development," Zwelinzima Vavi, general secretary of the Congress of South African Trade Unions (COSATU) is quoted as saying in the report. "Investment comes and goes, usually leaving little behind once it has gone."

ICFTU is urging the World Trade Organisation (WTO) to address violation of workers’ rights in the zones.

"The ICFTU wants to see WTO rules which would recognise the illegality of labour abuses in EPZs," spokesperson Barbara Kwateng told IPS. "We are yet to understand why this has not been done as yet, especially since the WTO acknowledges the illegality of tax subsidies."

The report points to a number of examples of labour abuses in countries such as Bangladesh, China, the Dominican Republic and Madagascar. Female workers often face a number of barriers at work including discrimination in hiring, wages and benefits, and sexual harassment, it says. The report documents cases of new women recruits in Central American zones being forced to take pregnancy tests. The report shows that while EPZs are often set up in countries that have ratified the core labour standards of the International Labour Organisation (ILO), in practice these standards are regularly flouted. The ILO is a Geneva-based UN agency that promotes social justice and labour rights.

ICFTU adds that many workers in EPZs are denied the right to form trade unions – a "flagrant violation" of international labour standards.

In Bangladesh, for example, six EPZs are exempt from laws which protect the freedom of association and the right to bargain collectively. Consequently, no trade unions are allowed in these areas. Elsewhere, dismissals are routinely used in Central American EPZs to get rid of workers who attempt to form unions. In the United Arab Emirates where 85 percent of the workforce are migrants – mostly from Asia – workers risk the sack if they try to form trade unions, the report says. In Egypt the report says most workers in EPZs are forced to sign letters of resignation before beginning employment so that they can be fired at the employers’ convenience.

In March ICFTU launched a "Unions for Women, Women for Unions" campaign aimed at improving the rights of women working in EPZs.

The group says that although the campaign has been successful, problems still exist because competition for foreign investment is growing among developing countries. ICFTU says it will address such continuing problems at the Japan congress, and that it plans to step up its campaign.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags