Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines, Human Rights, Population

REFUGEES: Australian Senate Wants Immigration Jail Closed

Bob Burton

CANBERRA, Jun 20 2005 (IPS) - The Australian Senate has backed a motion that would result in the closure of the government-funded immigration prison on Nauru, where 46 mostly Afghani people, including four children, have been held for almost four years awaiting decisions on their application for refugee status.

The motion, moved by Australian Greens Senator Bob Brown, proposed that the asylum seekers remaining on Nauru at the behest of the Australian government be brought back to mainland Australia. While the government backs keeping the Nauru centre open, its senators did not speak against the motion.

“Nauru remains a terrible scar on Australia’s reputation. We hope that this motion will help persuade the Howard government that it is time to close the centre there,” a spokesman for Brown told IPS.

Last Friday Australian Prime Minister John Howard sought to defuse a rebellion by several of his own backbenchers by announcing a series of procedural reforms to speed up decisions on applications for refugee status from up to 10,500 people, including over 900 still held in immigration prisons in Australia.

Asked why the reforms had not been implemented before if they were desirable, Howard told a media conference Friday, “I suppose with the benefit of hindsight we have to confess that that’s one of the many failings of this government”.

While the prime minister conceded there had been failings in how the Department of Immigration and Multicultural Affairs handled asylum seekers, he vehemently defended his hard-line policy, which was developed ahead of the 2001 election to undermine political support for the ultra-conservative One Nation Party led by Pauline Hanson.


“Mandatory detention will remain, we will maintain our strong position on border protection à the maintenance of offshore processing and in the unlikely event of it being needed in the future, the policy of turning boats around,” Howard said.

Refugee seekers who arrive in Australia by boat – in the past decade mostly Iraqis and Afghans – are held for an indefinite time period under what is called the ”mandatory detention” policy.

A month ago, several Liberal Party parliamentary backbenchers led by Petro Georgiou and Judi Moylan announced they would introduce two private members bills in defiance of opposition from Howard and the overwhelming majority of the government’s party room.

The bills would have limited the duration of mandatory detention and overturned the policy that those found to be valid refugees were only granted a three-year “temporary protection visa”. These visa holders are denied access to social welfare and health care benefits and at the expiry of their visa are required to argue why it would still be unsafe for them to be returned to their homeland.

According to Moylan, the proposed bills “go to the heart of the preservation of human life and human dignity, and those matters include putting an end to indefinite detention à locking people up for indefinite periods of time without any charges being laid”. = 06200821 ORP002 NNNN ZCZC ORP003 QS SPAM ROMAIPS AP HD PR IP REFUGEES: Senate Wants Australian Immigration Jail Closed(2-E)

With the prospect of an embarrassing confrontation on the floor of parliament coinciding with World Refugee Day on Monday, Howard opted to make concessions. Instead of indefinite detention, he pledged that the department of immigration will make a decision on “protection” visas within three months and that those who appeal to the Refugee Review Tribunal would have a decision within a further three months.

In addition, new oversight procedures would apply for those held in detention longer than two years.

Bowing to growing public opposition to the current detention of over 60 children, Howard promised that the Migration Act would be amended to state, “the parliament affirms as a principle that a minor child shall only be detained as a measure of last resort”.

This follows an April 2004 report by the Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission, which found that imprisoning children contravened Australia’s obligations under the international Convention on the Rights of the Child.

Defending his changes, Howard insisted last week that his government was not going “to abandon temporary protection visas”.

Amnesty International Australia welcomed the changes, but argued that people determined to be refugees should not have to prove their status a second time. “The changes do not guarantee permanent protection for temporary protection visa holders,” Amnesty said in a statement.

In return for Howard’s procedural reforms, Georgiou and Moylan have agreed to drop their private members bills. But for those imprisoned on Nauru, the announcement will make no difference as the reforms apply only to Australian territory.

The immigration prison on Nauru was established in late 2001, when the Australian government was desperately seeking other countries willing to take asylum seekers intercepted by a naval blockade of asylum seekers boats in its waters.

In September 2001 the government negotiated a memorandum of understanding (MOU) with the Government of Nauru under which Australia would fund the establishment and running costs of the prison, located in a desolate former phosphate mine, in return for additional aid funding for the near-bankrupt nation.

Since then the asylum seekers deemed to be genuine refugees have been slowly repatriated to third countries (and more recently Australia) by the United Nations refugee agency and the International Organisation for Migration (IOM).

Refugee support groups have mixed feelings about the Howard reforms. “This package offers the prospect of very welcome relief for the thousands of asylum seekers that came in 2001. However it does nothing for those still imprisoned on Nauru,” Executive Director of Rights Australia, Howard Glenn, told IPS.

Brown, of the Australian Greens party, has also hinted that when the government introduces its amendments to the Migration Act he will seek to amend them to incorporate the proposals of Georgiou that Howard rejected.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags