Friday, November 20, 2026
Thalif Deen
- U.N. Secretary-General Kofi Annan’s wide-ranging plans for a radical restructuring of the United Nations received a political setback when he was forced to withdraw two of his proposals aimed at reducing the powers of the U.N.’s influential 191-member administrative and budgetary committee and shifting decision-making to a smaller group of select countries.
Caving into strong pressure from the 132-member Group of 77, Annan said Thursday that while his sole purpose was to propose more efficient working methods for the intergovernmental process at the United Nations, “I recognise that these two proposals have provoked concern and resistance.”
Annan asked delegates “to set aside” his two proposals so that a divisive vote could be avoided.
Still, the United States and the 25-member European Union (EU) stood by Annan who, in his restructuring plans, had called for “smaller select working groups of limited membership” from among the larger U.N. administrative and budgetary committee to take financial decisions.
The existing administrative and budgetary committee, which sits in judgment of all financial matters, was considered unwieldy because it consisted of all 191 member states.
Annan wanted to “examine ways to allow strategic discussion to be held in meetings of manageable size, possibly through dividing up the workload”.
The whole debate came into the open Thursday when the administrative and budgetary committee discussed a G77 draft resolution which, in effect, rejected some of Annan’s proposals for management reform. A decision on the resolution is expected later this week.
Ambassador Dumisani Kumalo of South Africa took a passing shot at Western nations, invoking his country’s fight against apartheid when a small group of whites ruled a predominantly black population in his home country. He implied he was aware of what it is to see an organisation to be in the hands of a privileged few.
While accepting Annan’s decision to withdraw his two proposals, the G77 wanted to ensure that the proposals “will not be pursued any further” in the context of the secretary-general’s overall plan to restructure the world body “or in any other context”.
But both the United States and the EU refused to accept the new G77 language in the draft resolution. “This is not acceptable,” U.S. Ambassador John Bolton told delegates Thursday. “We cannot take the two proposals off the table. We are prepared to continue with the discussions.”
Some members of the G77 have already complained that the proposed radical changes in the U.N. reform process, as envisaged by Annan, have been driven primarily by one country: the United States.
Since the United States is the largest single contributor, accounting for 22 percent of the U.N.’s regular budget, Washington has insisted it should be able to dictate much of the proposed reform agenda of the world body.
On Wednesday, Ambassador Emyr Jones Parry of Britain was quoted as saying that some of the major financial contributors to the U.N. budget, including the United States, Japan, Germany and Britain, should have a greater say in budgetary matters.
“They should realise we pay 82 percent of the budget, and we’re not going to have this sort of imposition on us by the draconian tactics of the G77 at the moment.” He also warned: “If they want to play with fire, they’re going to get their fingers burned.”
On Wednesday, Ambassador Kumalo told reporters that the U.N. membership was assessed according to each member states’ ability to pay – not according to their wealth and opulence.
“We thank them for paying 82 percent of the budget, but we are saying that doing so does not entitle them to have a larger voice and to then decide for the rest of the membership, because that goes against the (U.N.) Charter,” he said.
He also said that the Group of 77 “disagreed profoundly” with a proposal that would enable a small representative group of states to make all key decisions on budgetary matters. It was not clear who had decided who was representative and who was not, he added. “The Group of 77 and China strongly believes that the right of every member state to have an equal say in the decision-making of the organisation must be upheld,” Kumalo said. “This right is not dependent on the financial contributions of member states to the budget of the organisation,” he argued.
He said those with the means to fund the United Nations were forcing the rest of the membership to give up their rights under the Charter.
“We think that is not right. We are saying that the Charter, which we all believe in, says we have the right to pronounce on this organisation. What’s wrong with us wanting to pronounce?”
Kumalo also said the United States, Japan and the European Union had said they were putting a “spending cap” on the organisation, because they wanted it reformed according to their wishes and, if that was not done, the United Nations would have no money by Jun. 30.
“That was the sword hanging over the organisation, and the Group of 77 would fight the budget cap,” he warned.