Asia-Pacific, Civil Society, Development & Aid, Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines, Human Rights

Q&A: &#39China Paying a Reputational Price&#39

Interview with Human Rights Watch chief, Kenneth Roth

TOKYO , Apr 8 2008 (IPS) - Kenneth Roth has been executive director of Human Rights Watch (HRW) since 1993. In Tokyo to set up a new office for the rights lobby Roth discussed with IPS correspondent Catherine Makino such issues as China, the Olympics and hotspots like Darfur, Burma, Sudan and Bangladesh.

HRW&#39s Kenneth Roth Credit: Catherine Makino/IPS

HRW's Kenneth Roth Credit: Catherine Makino/IPS

IPS: Why is HRW opening an office in Tokyo?

Kenneth Roth: Judging by the aid it gives, the Japanese government has enormous potential influence, especially in Asia. Yet it rarely exercises that influence on behalf of human rights. By making available HRW research from throughout Asia and the world, the Tokyo office will seek to engage the Japanese government more regularly on behalf of the human rights of its neighbors.

IPS: When will you open it?

KR: We are currently raising the funds we need to open the office – about 400,000 US dollars annually. About half of this has now been pledged, and we are seeking the remainder. We believe it is important for these funds to come from Japan as a sign of commitment by the Japanese people to a more active human rights policy on the part of their government. As soon as the funds are in hand, we will open the office.

IPS: There are countries from Fiji, to Nepal, India and Europe turning their backs on the Tibetans.


KR: Many governments are deeply concerned about Chinese repression in Tibet, but given the economic clout of China, too few have the courage of their convictions to stand up firmly for the rights of Tibetans.

IPS: China is getting away with its support of countries such as Burma and Sudan?

KR: It isn’t. China has paid a considerable reputational price for its support of highly repressive regimes, particularly its support of Sudan despite Sudanese atrocities in Darfur. Beijing purchases two-thirds of Sudan’s oil, sells arms to Sudan, and blocks efforts to build pressure on Khartoum at the UN Security Council. As human rights groups have highlighted this deadly support, Beijing has become increasingly concerned, especially by efforts to link the Olympics to Darfur; some groups have come to call them the "Genocide Olympics." As a result, the Chinese government has started to play a modestly useful role in Sudan by helping to convince the Sudanese government to accept in principle a UN-led peacekeeping force to protect the people of Darfur. Unfortunately, this acceptance in principle has not yet translated into an acceptance in reality. The Sudanese government continues to obstruct deployment of the peacekeepers, even as the people of Darfur continue to be killed and raped. Much more intense Chinese pressure is needed.

As for Burma, China has done little to force the military junta to ease up on its repression of pro-democracy activists. That passivity will come back to haunt China, because the Olympics will open on Aug 8, exactly 20 years to the day from the launch of the pro-democracy movement in Burma that would then be so ruthlessly suppressed. So people will inevitably tie the Olympics to Burmese repression. The open question is whether, in light of that tie, Beijing will be seen to have helped pressure the junta to ease its repression or to have stood passively by. So far, it has mainly been passive.

IPS: Do you predict turmoil in the lead up to the Olympics or at the Olympics?

KR : Because of the intense spotlight put on Beijing, the Olympics will inevitably attract protestors who hope to highlight their plight and convince Chinese authorities to address it. But it would be a mistake to call these efforts to speak out and protest peacefully "turmoil". They are legitimate efforts to exercise fundamental human rights. The "turmoil" will come if the Chinese government insists on repressing those rights by breaking up demonstrations and jailing protestors.

IPS: Do you support a boycott of the Olympics – why or why not?

KR: HRW has not called for a boycott of the Olympics. We fear that would be counterproductive, since the Chinese people clearly want the Olympics to take place. However, we have called on governmental leaders (as opposed to athletes) to boycott the Olympics’ opening ceremony unless China takes certain steps such as releasing peaceful protestors, allowing an independent investigation of the recent events in Tibet, and permitting journalists to travel freely throughout China. We think it would be wrong for government leaders to give their blessing to Chinese repression by showing up at the opening ceremony if that repression hasn’t been ended.

IPS: Critics say you are not getting enough results in countries like Bangladesh, Burma…. How would you answer them?

KR : Many governments are tempted to violate human rights as a way of maintaining power and silencing dissent. The role of the human rights movement is to raise the cost of those violations by tarnishing an abusive government’s reputation, depriving it of free access to non-humanitarian international assistance, and in extreme cases, prosecuting its leaders. These methods of pressure take time, but we have seen repeatedly that when applied consistently, they yield results. But of course, they work more quickly when we are joined by powerful governments. That’s why it’s so important that Japan adopts a more consistent policy of promoting human rights in its relations with other governments.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags