Monday, November 16, 2026
Humberto Márquez
- The recent deaths of several soldiers in Venezuela, the victims of excesses in disciplinary punishment, have catapulted the debate on human rights in the armed forces into the headlines.
”They killed my son. This is vandalism, what the military and the government have done,” cried Ender Pedreáñez, the disconsolate father of Angel Pedreáñez, a young recruit who died Tuesday after 35 days of agony as a burn victim.
At his burial Wednesday in the western city of Santa Bárbara, Pedreáñez’s family refused to dress his body in military uniform, and only allowed his fellow recruits to attend, but no army officers.
In remarks to IPS, Marino Alvarado, legal coordinator of PROVEA, one of the leading human rights groups, said the military regulations on disciplinary punishment in force in Venezuela for six decades run counter to the 1999 constitution. He also deplored the political manipulation of such cases.
Alvarado said that ”rather than doing anything for the victims, the parties in conflict in Venezuela are merely trying to take political advantage” of these situations.
The activist was alluding to the political confrontation between the left-leaning President Hugo Chávez and the broad opposition movement that has been raging since late 2001.
On Mar. 30, a fire broke out in a punishment cell in Fort Mara, in the northwestern Guajira region on the border with Colombia, where eight soldiers were being held under arrest for reporting late to duty.
The eight burn victims were taken to different hospitals. One of them, Orlando Bustamante, died on Apr. 5.
That day, on his weekly radio and TV programme ‘Aló Presidente’, Chávez criticised the media for blowing the incident out of proportion to favour the opposition, when the soldiers had only suffered ”minor burns.”
Information Minister Jesse Chacón resigned, blaming himself for the faulty information that had reached the president. But a week later, Chávez himself assumed responsibility for the mistake, and reinstated Chacón.
In parliament and the media, the opposition is demanding an impartial investigation, and maintains that the responsibility of the military commanders in the western border region is being covered up by Chávez and Defence Minister Gen. Jorge García Carneiro.
García Carneiro and army commander Raúl Baduel were military school classmates of Chávez, a former lieutenant colonel who led a failed coup in 1992 against then-president Carlos Andrés Pérez (1974-1979 and 1989-1993), who was later charged with corruption.
The military justice system has accepted Attorney-General Isaías Rodríguez’s request that a civilian court handle the case involving the Fort Mara fire to establish who was responsible.
As the outrage over the fire continued to mount, reports came out that another soldier had died, in the western region of Zulia.
According to his family, he was thrown by his superiors into a pit of rotten-smelling water as punishment. However, García Carneiro said he drowned ”during swimming practice.”
”If someone would dedicate themselves to documenting reports of excesses in the punishment of recruits in Venezuela, they could compile an entire volume of human rights violations,” said Alvarado.
The human rights lawyer also said ”the rules on deprivation of liberty can only be established by law, not by regulations like the ones on disciplinary punishment, which openly contradict the constitution.”
With respect to the fire in Fort Mara, ”we cannot affirm that the armed forces violated human rights, as if they had the intention of burning the soldiers, but there was omission in their responsibility for taking care of” the recruits, said Alvarado.
For weeks, the ruling coalition and the opposition awaited Pedreáñez’s testimony and that of the six other soldiers who were injured in the fire.
Several of the recruits said Pedreáñez set the fire as part of an escape plan, according to testimony gathered by governing coalition lawmakers.
Two days before Pedreáñez died, Crispín Marín, director of the hospital where he was being treated, announced a slight improvement in his condition.
But on Tuesday, while doctors were treating him, he died of a heart attack, said Marín.
”It is a strange coincidence that this young man died of the same cause as Bustamante, cardio-respiratory arrest,” said parliamentarian Dianela Parra of the Democratic Action opposition party.
Ruling party legislator Rodrigo Cabezas lamented the soldier’s death and criticised the media’s handling of the case, ”in which the only thing missing,” he said, ”were headlines stating that President Chávez ordered the doctors to kill Pedreáñez.”
The lawyer representing the Pedreáñez family, Morly Uzcátegui, distributed to the press a statement that the soldier reportedly made shortly before he died, in which he stated that someone ”came up (to the cell) with a tube that shot out flames, and burnt us.”
Lawmaker Pastor Heydra of the Democratic Action party said a member of the military approached the punishment cell with a flame-thrower and aimed it at the soldiers.
But Baduel and ruling party legislators say that version is preposterous, and point out that flame-throwers are obsolete, and are no longer in use.
Heydra, however, told IPS that ”my sources are top quality, and their reports are based on an examination of the soldiers’ burn injuries.”
Uzcátegui encouraged the rumour that Pedreáñez was murdered, asking in front of the TV cameras: ”Who was interested in seeing Angel alive – or dead?”
The political backdrop to the situation is the polarisation and conflict between Chávez and the opposition Democratic Coordinator coalition, made up of the traditional political parties that ruled Venezuela for decades before Chávez was elected, business and labour groups, and civil society organisations.
The Democratic Coordinator gathered millions of signatures to activate a recall referendum to remove Chávez from power, and has been given three days at the end of the month to ratify hundreds of thousands of signatures that the electoral authorities called into question.
The opposition needs 2.4 million signatures to trigger a recall referendum.