Development & Aid, Headlines, Human Rights, Indigenous Rights, Latin America & the Caribbean

GUATEMALA: UN Mission Wraps Up – Without Fulfilling Its Goals

José Eduardo Mora

SAN JOSE, Nov 15 2004 (IPS) - The United Nations mission in Guatemala comes to an end on Wednesday, even though its assignment of ensuring compliance with the peace accords signed after 36 years of civil war has not been completed, analysts and activists told IPS.

The dire poverty faced by the country’s indigenous majority, land redistribution, rising crime rates, and respect for human rights are all pressing issues that have been left unresolved, said Sandino Asturias with the Guatemalan National Revolutionary Unity (URNG), the former guerrilla umbrella group that became a political party after the peace deal was signed on Dec. 29, 1996.

Mario Polanco, with the Mutual Support Group, a local human rights organisation, and Francisco García at the Central American Institute of Political Studies agreed that the United Nations Verification Mission in Guatemala (MINUGUA) was leaving before its mandate was fulfilled.

All three said MINUGUA had played an essential role in Guatemala, but that many areas must be further strengthened before the objectives outlined in the peace agreements, whose compliance MINUGUA was to oversee, can be fully met.

The 12 main points of the accords included respect for human rights in general and for the rights of indigenous people in particular, and the resettlement of populations displaced by the armed conflict.

Other points were the creation of a Historic Clarification Commission, social and economic measures aimed at achieving social equity and development, including agrarian reform, a strengthening of civilian institutions, and a redefinition of the role of the army.


One of the great achievements since the peace accords were signed, for example, was the reduction of the army from 50,000 to 15,000 members.

But the head of MINUGUA, Tom Koenigs, acknowledged at an international congress on peace in Guatemala in late October that a wide range of socioeconomic, ethnic and political problems, which were at the very roots of the armed conflict, have not yet been overcome.

Among the biggest pending challenges that “require special attention” are the fight against racism and discrimination, the consolidation of a state of law, and the eradication of poverty, since Guatemala remains one of the poorest and most unequal countries in Latin America, he said.

MINUGUA recommended that the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR) open an office in Guatemala.

Guatemalan President Oscar Berger, who took office in January, pledged to redouble efforts to meet the objectives laid out by the peace agreements, after progress towards that end virtually dragged to a halt under his predecessor, Alfonso Portillo (2000-2004).

MINUGUA’s work has provided important support for achieving respect for human rights in this impoverished Central American nation, but “we are still a country in construction, with constant violence, and huge social inequalities,” said Asturias.

Human Rights Watch (HRW) and other international rights groups have warned of a rise in political violence in Guatemala in the past few years.

According to a Jan. 14, 2004 HRW news release, “The most pressing obstacle to progress on human rights cases has been the country’s climate of political violence and intimidation. Rights activists, justice officials, journalists and others who have promoted accountability (for past human rights abuses) have faced scores of threats and attacks over the last three years.”

Human rights organisations have also drawn attention to numerous cases of lynching of suspected criminals by mobs.

MINUGUA opened its offices in Guatemala in 1994, two years before the government of Alvaro Arzú (1996-2000) and the URNG signed the peace accords in Norway.

The Historical Clarification Commission, coordinated by Christian Tomuschat from Germany, found in its 1999 report that more than 200,000 (mainly unarmed indigenous) people were the victims of murder and forced disappearance during the armed conflict, and that the army was responsible for 93 percent of all human rights violations.

Another three percent of the abuses were attributed to insurgent groups, and no specific perpetrators were identified in the remaining four percent of cases.

“It is obvious that the transformation process on which Guatemala embarked in the wake of the peace accords will take at least 20 or 30 more years to be consolidated,” said Asturias, who lamented that the country’s indigenous people continue to suffer from dire poverty and discrimination.

According to U.N. statistics, 60 percent of Guatemala’s 12 million people are indigenous. Meanwhile, the World Factbook 2004, published by the U.S. Central Intelligence Agency, estimates the poverty rate at 75 percent, while non-governmental organisations put it as high as 90 percent.

Asturias, García and Polanco agreed that parliament will be reluctant to back the proposal to open an OHCHR office in Guatemala.

But Asturias said “I am confident that international pressure will force parliament to approve” the initiative.

Polanco stated that although MINUGUA has played a decisive role in helping to consolidate peace in Guatemala, it also toed the government line on a number of occasions, which limited its scope of action.

But, he added, “Despite the mission’s shortcomings, we fear that when it leaves, there will be setbacks in terms of respect for human rights.”

According to García, only 25 percent of the goals agreed to in the peace accords have been met.

“Among the achievements of the last 10 years is the significant reduction of the army and the dismantling of the Estado Mayor Presidencial (the Presidential Guard), which was implicated in extrajudicial executions,” he said.

“Since 1871, the army had enjoyed absolute power in Guatemala, and today that power is shifting towards the business elite,” said García.

However, the re-emergence of the Patrullas de Autodefensa Civil or Civil Self-defence Patrols – paramilitary bodies accused of committing atrocities during the civil war – in 2003 was “a grave setback” for the country’s progress towards peace and reconciliation, García added.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags