Europe, Headlines, Human Rights

RIGHTS-FRANCE: Give a Little, Take a Lot

Julio Godoy

PARIS, Oct 29 2002 (IPS) - It’s a dance of half a step forward and two steps back in setting out new rights for minorities, human rights activists say.

The half-step forward comes with the announcement by minister of the interior Nicolas Sarkozy that he is ready to partially revoke the so-called double sanction against immigrants convicted of a crime. The convicted first serve their sentence, and then they are expelled.

Legal experts say the convicted are being punished twice over for one crime. They have been pleading for years for an end to these double blows, particularly on immigrants who have strong family or social ties in France.

Sarkozy said in a radio interview Saturday that the double sanction could be applied only to convicted immigrants with short-term residence.

"It is very difficult to expel people, even those with a large police file, where they have built strong social and family links," Sarkozy said. "But all foreign criminals with a residence permit issued less than a year before the committing of a crime should be expelled after they have served their sentence."

Sarkozy clarified that these were his views, and that he had not discussed a revision of the double sanction either with Prime Minister Jean Pierre Rafarin or with Minister for Justice Dominique Perben. But following Sarkozy’s comments the ministry of justice announced it would review the practice of expulsion of immigrants.

Legal experts and human rights activists called Sarkozy’s announcement "a considerable improvement." Bernard Bolze, president of One Sanction who has been campaigning against this practice for years said: "This is very good news. We have been waiting for such an improvement for long."

The campaign against double sanctions has peaked over reports of imminent expulsion of two Algerians, Chérif Bouchelag, 32, born in Algeria, but who has lived in France since he was 11 years old, and Mamar Douani, 40, who was born in France and has lived all his life here, but with Algerian nationality.

Bouchelag was convicted for drugs trafficking and Douani for several other crimes. Both have served their prison sentences. Douani has spent 17 years in jail. His wife is expecting their first child.

Novelist Nancy Houston has written to Sarkozy that Douani will face ruin if he is expelled. "During his prison years, Mamar Douani took lessons to learn a job," she wrote. "Armed with an uncommon will, he successfully passed his bachelor’s degree, and became a renowned cook. Having paid his debt to society, all he wants is the chance to take part in French life as a normal citizen, with his wife and his child."

Film-maker Bertrand Tavernier has presented similar arguments on behalf of Bouchelag. "A French citizen who has committed the same crime as an immigrant is not punished with expulsion," Tavernier said. "Expulsion of a convicted immigrant is discriminatory and therefore unacceptable."

The apparent concessions announced have not stopped human rights and legal groups from protesting against other laws against immigrants.

"The government, and especially Nicolas Sarkozy are performing a macabre dance on legal rights," says Michel Tubiana, president of the Human Rights League. "They are moving half a step forward but after taking two steps back.."

A new law on internal security approved by the council of ministers last week particularly targets minority groups. It envisages strong sanctions against gypsies, foreign beggars and prostitutes, and children of immigrants..

The new law that is due to come into force before the end of the year makes parking vehicles by gypsies in open spaces a crime. What it calls "abusive" meetings in social housing projects and "aggressive" begging will also become crimes.

Bruno Marcus, leader of the French Lawyers Union, called the bill "a regression without precedent in the defence of liberties in France." Several demonstrations are being planned against the bill, including a protest march by prostitutes Saturday.

Sarkozy has defended the proposed law on the grounds that "French citizens are tired of criminality." The law will restore "the authority of the state in the whole country, and answers to the cry of desperation raised by French people during the electoral campaigns in the spring."

More than six million voters out of a total 41 million supported neo-fascist presidential candidate Jean-Marie Le Pen in May. Both Le Pen and rival candidate President Jacques Chirac condemned what they called the vacillations of the former Socialist government in fighting crime.

The new law means that "France is putting in practice Jean-Marie Le Pen’s programme under a so-called democratic government," said Marcus.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags

Europe, Headlines, Human Rights

RIGHTS-FRANCE: Give a Little, Take a Lot

Julio Godoy

PARIS, Oct 29 2002 (IPS) - It’s a dance of half a step forward and two steps back in setting out new rights for minorities, human rights activists say.
(more…)

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags