Headlines, Human Rights, Latin America & the Caribbean, Press Freedom

MEXICO: Drug Trade a Deadly Subject for Journalists

Diego Cevallos

MEXICO CITY, Apr 14 2005 (IPS) - In the space of less than a week, a Mexican reporter was murdered, another disappeared, and a third was shot nine times, yet miraculously survived. All three crimes were perpetrated by drug traffickers, who very likely had the help of police officers eager to silence damaging information.

The recent spate of attacks on journalists, between Apr. 2 and 8, is just the latest example of the dangers faced by those who practice this profession in Mexico, especially when they dare to dig into the world of drug trafficking. This ongoing threat has been the focus of repeated demands made of the government by trade unions and professional associations of media workers.

Since December 2000, when President Vicente Fox took office, the death toll has reached 11, with four journalists murdered in 2004 alone. A total of 19 reporters were killed during the term of Fox’s predecessor, Ernesto Zedillo (1994-2000), while 57 lost their lives during the administration of Carlos Salinas (1988-1994).

“We want our son back, we don’t even want to know who took him, we just want them to let him go,” said Alfredo Jiménez, the distraught father of a young journalist of the same name who has been missing since Apr. 2.

Jiménez junior writes for the local newspaper El Imparcial in the state of Sonora, along the U.S. border. The young journalist had written a number of articles about the violent drug trafficking gangs who operate in the state.

He is now being sought by over 100 federal police agents, while his parents go from one public office to another begging for every effort to be made to find him. “We’re desperate, we just can’t take it anymore,” his father told IPS by telephone from his home in Sonora.


Mexican traffickers, in conjunction with their counterparts in Colombia and other producer countries, are responsible for transporting 70 percent of the cocaine that is consumed in the United States – the world’s number-one market for illegal drugs – as well as large quantities of heroin, methamphetamines and marijuana.

It is presumed that journalist Guadalupe García, shot nine times on Apr. 5 in the northern Mexican state of Tamaulipas – also on the U.S. border – was yet another victim of violence perpetrated by drug traffickers, although investigations have failed to confirm a connection so far.

Although she survived the attack, García remains in critical condition.

Raúl Gibb, director of La Opinión, a newspaper in the state of Veracruz on the Gulf of Mexico, was less fortunate. He was shot on Apr. 8 while driving and died instantly.

These most recent crimes against journalists and the majority of those committed in the past remain unpunished, like almost all crimes committed by drug trafficking rings.

“Journalists are just one link in the chain of crimes committed by the drug mafias,” Leonarda Reyes, director of the non-governmental Centre for Journalism and Public Ethics (CEPET), commented to IPS.

“The problem is that police investigations are not properly carried out, and the laws are inadequate for guaranteeing the safety of reporters,” she added.

Journalists associations have called on the federal government to take over the investigation of these crimes, which are usually handled by state police forces, and to implement legal reforms to ensure that justice is administered by independent authorities at the national level.

The proposed reforms include granting the attorney general’s office jurisdiction over the investigation of crimes against journalists. There are also demands for an independent attorney general, a position currently filled by a presidential appointee, subordinate to executive power.

The Mexican government, which is generally viewed as respectful of the freedom of expression, has assigned a number of cases to federal prosecutors, but says the country’s laws limit federal involvement in the investigation of crimes considered to fall under state jurisdiction.

A number of initiatives have been put forward to reform the current legislation, including the two demands made by journalists, but these have little chance of making it through the Chamber of Deputies, where the ruling party does not have a majority. As a result the attorney general’s office remains and will likely continue to be fully dependent on the government.

Further complicating matters is the fact that the murders and other acts of violence against journalists often involve the complicity of police officers, and occasionally members of the armed forces, on the payroll of organised crime rings, as numerous investigations have revealed.

The government acknowledges that there are at least seven major drug trafficking rings in Mexico, all with enormous financial resources, powerful weapons and complex organisational structures.

After the most recent spate of attacks on journalists, as on previous occasions, the Inter American Press Association (IAPA) – an organisation of media outlet owners – called on the Mexican government “to investigate these acts thoroughly and promptly, as well as bring those responsible to justice.”

According to the Journalists Association of the central Mexican state of Zacatecas, those who work in the media “are in a state of total defencelessness, more than ever before.”

The ongoing protests by journalists associations against crimes like these do not appear to have any effect, although this could change at some point in the future, said CEPET director Reyes.

Scores of journalists took to the streets for the first time ever in October 2004, staging simultaneous demonstrations in 10 of the country’s 32 states to demand guarantees for the full freedom of expression and exemplary punishment for murders and attacks on journalists. A public declaration was also issued, with 232 signatures.

The Fox government responded by establishing a working group to study their demands. But in Reyes’ view, the initiative was essentially fruitless.

Talks were held on the demands made by the journalists, the efforts undertaken by the government, and its limitations with regard to the investigation of certain crimes, until “we reached a point where we weren’t making any further progress, and came to the conclusion that continuing to meet would not really serve any useful purpose,” she reported.

In the meantime, Mexican journalists continue to live under constant threat, and to risk their lives every time they dare to touch on the subject of the drug trade.

 
Republish | | Print |