Asia-Pacific, Civil Society, Development & Aid, Environment, Headlines, Human Rights, Indigenous Rights

INDIA: Consult on Big Dams, Northeast Locals Demand

Surendra Phuyal

YARZULI, Arunachal Pradesh, Jun 30 2005 (IPS) - Bengia Abo grew up in this lush, green mountain village sprawling on the banks of the Panyor River in upper Arunachal Pradesh State in Northeast India.

"Panyor is like our mother," the 32-year-old, who belongs to the indigenous Nishi tribe, told IPS as he stood on a ridge overlooking the snow-fed river on a recent afternoon. "It supports the lives of thousands of indigenous people in the area."

Its headwaters high up in the Tibetan Autonomous Region of China, the Panyor is one of the tributaries of the mighty Brahmaputra River, one of the major river systems originating in the Himalayan region.

But with authorities in India – as in neighbouring Nepal, Bhutan and China – floating more plans to dam and divert the free-flowing rivers, locals and tribal villagers like Abo are complaining that they are being negatively affected.

Worse still, "unscientific and unilateral moves" by the region’s governments are adversely affecting the fragile Himalayan ecosystems, rivers like the Panyor being at the heart of such webs of life, according to locals and experts.

On the Panyor, for instance, the North East Electric Power Company (NEEPCO), under the Government of India, built a 68-meter-high dam to generate 405 megawatts (mw) of electricity; the project was completed in 2002.


In the process, 200 families were uprooted, and hundreds of hectares of cultivable land were submerged. After local fish varieties started disappearing from the river upstream of the dam, dozens of fishermen reverted to June cultivation of rice paddy, according to Abo.

Before the company altered the course of the river, locals say, they were never consulted. "No villager was involved in the decision-making process, and no environmental impact assessment was done," said Kipa Raja, a Nishi youth and social activist.

The result: the run-of-river hydroelectric plant is up and running, the electric power is transmitted to well-off states like Assam, but poor farmers and fishermen in Arunachal Pradesh have lost their farms and traditional way of life and are left to fend for themselves.

Worse, the farmers – just like many of their brethren living near dams in other South Asian nations – still live in their un-electrified thatched houses.

With a population of a little over one million people, Arunachal Pradesh is home to 26 different tribes. Ninety-five percent of them live in rural areas, cultivating rice, wheat, potatoes and other crops.

The frontier state is one of the disputed areas between India and China.

A recent positive development here has seen the old dirt road linking the area with the state capital, Itanagar and neighbouring Assam state upgraded and in much better shape today.

Efforts are also underway to electrify local villages by developing micro- and small-hydro schemes in the area.

Yet at the same time, authorities have plans to build more big dams in the area. If the proposed Ranganadi Phase II (130 mw with a 117-m high dam) goes ahead, for instance, locals fear it could uproot more villagers and destroy the traditional way of life of thousands of families in the Subhansiri district.

With the potential to generate 63,000 mw from 168 hydroelectric (hydel) schemes, Northeast India – home to over 100 ethnic groups – has the potential to become the nation’s future powerhouse, say experts.

But activists fear "haphazardly planned" projects like the Ranganadi Phase I could spell disaster for the lives of local communities and the region’s pristine ecology.

Fiercely opposed to existing plans from India – as well as China -to dam and divert rivers, they are demanding that proper studies be conducted, and that the voices of the locals and the marginalized be heard before such mega-schemes are developed.

Since rivers like the Panyor and Brahmaputra are transnational bodies of water originating in China and emptying into the Bay of Bengal via Bangladesh, experts say regional consultations with concerned groups at all levels – governmental, non-governmental and grassroots – and at every stage of project development should be held.

"If this does not happen," warns Gopal Siwakoti ‘Chintan’, executive director of the Kathmandu-based Water and Energy Users’ Federation – Nepal, "the water wars we fear about, will start – over rivers, over riparian benefits and rights".

Equally important, authorities should not ignore the concerns of the locals, who must be involved in making decisions, said Roy Laifungbam of the Assam-based South Asian Solidarity for Rivers and Peoples, an anti-high dam movement.

"No less important are environmental impact assessment (EIA) and other scientific studies and transparency at every level and stage of the project development," he added, citing the landmark report of the World Commission on Dams.

In Yarzuli village, leaders like Abo and Raja are busy mobilizing would-be affected communities as authorities in New Delhi and Itanagar finalize the draft of the Ranganadi Phase II.

"There is a dichotomy and total lack of regulation in (the dam-building) initiatives being taken here," said local activist Kipa Raja. "They are out to ‘corporatise’ the power sector here."

But, added Abo, "we will continue to fight for our rights. We will not give up. If at all we have to, we will make sure that the affected people get enough compensation for what they lose."

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags