Wednesday, November 18, 2026
Katherine Stapp
- As more and more products display labels designed to appeal to socially conscious buyers, environmentalists and consumer advocates say it is time to find ways to weed out dubious claims.
An ”eco-label” is a seal or logo that indicates a product has met a set of environmental or social standards. Many are ‘earned’ after independent third-party certification, but others are not, and it is unclear if consumers can be confident of their claims, industry watchers say.
”It is imperative that standards are transparent, that organisations and businesses avoid lingo that means nothing – for example, ‘natural’ – and that every action or message is consistently dependable in order to reinforce credibility,” said Cynthia Barstow, author of The Eco-Foods Guide.
For example, some products bear labels proclaiming them ”earth smart”, ”non-toxic”, ”eco-safe”, ”environmentally preferable” or ”environmentally friendly”. None of these phrases is based on any meaningful, accepted standard, according to the Consumers Union, which runs a website (www.eco-labels.org) that posts report cards on dozens of eco-labels.
The Union notes that the U.S. Federal Trade Commission frowns on these kind of vague claims, but says they pop up on cleaning and personal hygiene products regardless.
”There are a lot of different eco-labels out there,” said Jason Clay, of the Centre for Conservation Innovation at the World Wildlife Fund. ”Few have been developed in an open, transparent way.”
”The next stage of eco-label and certification work will be to revise them to make them more science-based and objective, or eliminate them,” Clay said.
The U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) just waded into the fray with an official ”organic seal” promising consumers that a product is at least 95 percent organic.
The standards, which came into effect last month, bar the use of synthetic pesticides and fertilisers, antibiotics, genetic engineering, irradiation, sewage sludge, artificial ingredients and many other practices.
Products whose ingredients are 70-95 percent organic can say so on the label (”made with organic fruit”, for example), but they cannot display the circular, green and white USDA seal.
While the seal excludes genetically modified ingredients, it is not connected to the ongoing controversy over mandatory labelling of GM foods.
Environmental and consumer groups give the USDA certification high marks for reliability and transparency, although they note the process had its drawbacks – like taking 10 years to get off the ground.
”If we’ve learned anything from the USDA organic label experience, it’s that partnering with government means losing control, accepting bureaucracy, and enduring delays in implementation,” said Kathleen Merrigan, director of the agriculture, food and environment programme at Tufts University.
”It’s more work for those of us trying to change the world through market innovations, but we have no choice,” she said.
”Now we need to figure out what works and what doesn’t,” said Merrigan, who co-organised a conference this week in Boston on eco-labelling. ”What labels work for consumers and why and how do we protect people from meaningless or fraudulent claims?”
The move to certify organic goods is due in part to rising demand for healthier food. Retail sales of organic produce have grown by 20 percent or more annually since 1990, with the market now estimated at more than 10 billion dollars each year.
> 1997 to 2001, certified organic farmland in the United States nearly doubled, from 1.3 million acres to 2.3 million acres, according to the most recent USDA estimates.
”In many cultures, the relationship with food is strong and the desire for authentic, quality foodstuffs is prevalent,” Barstow said. ”Different groups of people have different motivations in terms of eco-foods, and to understand them and communicate appropriately is key.”
She said that the demand for organic products has become more widespread.
”No longer are we speaking directly to upper-income baby boomer Caucasian women who graduated from college or graduate school,” Barstow added.
Charles Benbrook, who runs a consulting firm in Idaho that specialises in sustainable agriculture issues, expects the organic market to keep growing.
”Between two-thirds and three-quarters of consumers voice strong or very strong concerns over pesticide residues in food,” said Benbrook. ”The way eco-label programmes deal with pesticide use and their risks will be a decisive factor in gaining consumer trust and brand loyalty.”
”Experience to date with U.S. eco-label programmes suggests that consumer recognition and trust is hard to win and easily lost,” he added.
Besides environmental claims, some goods boast ”social responsibility” labels, which focus on labour issues and farmers’ rights.
”Governments around the world have so far failed to adequately address workplace injustice and exploitation,” said Richard Mandelbaum, of the Farmworker Support Committee.
”As a response, people have been increasingly using their purchasing power to buy products such as fair trade coffee and sweatshop-free clothing.”
”Unfortunately, more and more labels are appearing on the market that are diluted – these labels confuse the consumer, undermine workers’ struggles for justice, and undermine as well those labels that legitimately represent the sector they claim to,” Mandelbaum said.
”It is crucial as this movement goes forward that it is workers themselves, and their organisations, that define the meaning of workplace justice,” he stressed. ”Trade unions and workers’ associations need to be the leading voice in this particular brand of eco-label.”
All of these issues and more are being debated at the conference at Boston’s Tufts University, which runs through Saturday.
Katherine Stapp
- As more and more products display labels designed to appeal to socially conscious buyers, environmentalists and consumer advocates say it is time to find ways to weed out dubious claims.
(more…)