Asia-Pacific, Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines, Human Rights

CULTURE: ‘Hitler’s Cafe’ Serves Up India’s Ugly Side

Praful Bidwai

NEW DELHI, Aug 25 2006 (IPS) - A controversy is brewing in India over the recent launching of a trendy new restaurant named “Hitler’s Cross” in Navi Mumbai (New Bombay). As it gathers momentum and attention, the controversy highlights the polar opposite of India’s image as a robustly democratic society which aspires to pluralism and tolerance, and is a role-model for many countries, especially of the Global South.

The signboard of “Hitler’s Cross”, which opened last week, prominently depicts the “o” in the word “cross” as a Nazi swastika enclosed in a circle. Its inauguration took place with a window display of a large photograph of Adolf Hitler in full military uniform, complete with a swastika armband. The café also showcased a pistol.

The opening of “Hitler’s Cross” first triggered a protest from Mumbai’s tiny Jewish community, which was once 40,000 strong, but has shrunk to just a few thousand. The Israeli consulate in Mumbai too registered a protest.

However, in the last few days, more and more non-Jewish Indians have expressed their outrage at the glorification of genocide and extreme authoritarianism implicit in the café-restaurant’s name.

Prominent among them was a state cabinet member and “guardian minister” of Navi Mumbai, Ganesh Naik, who says: “it’s totally wrong to have any place named after a horrible man like Hitler. Such a practice completely goes against our Indian culture.”

Under the protestors’ pressure, the restaurant’s owners, Satish Sabhlok and Puneet Sabhlok, removed Hitler’s poster from the display window on Aug. 23. And although they initially refused to change the name of the eatery, on Thursday they issued statement acknowledging that the name was ‘‘inappropriate”.

‘’Our intention was not to glorify Hitler or his atrocities or ideology in any way and we regret the anguish caused by the use of his name,” the statement said.

Yet, many civil rights activists are aghast that the restaurant has been doing fairly brisk business by using Hitler’s name.

“There is every reason why the protests should acquire the widest possible dimension”, says Kamal Mitra Chenoy, professor of political science at Jawaharlal Nehru University here, who is himself half-Jewish. “The name deeply offends the citizen’s democratic and secular sensibilities. The issue is not whether ‘Hitler’s Cross’ insults Jews, but that it conveys a lack of revulsion at Hitler’s crimes against humanity and his gross human rights violations.”

The restaurant’s name raises questions that go way beyond private property and the right of an individual to “own” a name or brand. But the café’s owners claim that they have a legal right to register “Hitler’s Cross” as a trademark. They have been quoted in the media as saying that there are 12 other establishments in India with “Hitler” in the title, including five in Mumbai.

Hitler’s name and image have certainly been used to sell and promote food in India’s capital, New Delhi. Here, a chain of restaurants called “A Slice of Italy” sells a special chocolate cake named “One for the Hitler”. According to a salesman of the restaurant, the cake’s sponge is soaked overnight in “Finlandia” Vodka and it is covered with Irish chocolate cream.

The cake’s top depicts a supposedly funny face of Adolf Hitler, with his trademark moustache. ”One for the Hitler” is priced at Rs 505 (11 US dollars) per kg including taxes. No order below 2 kg is accepted.

What may appall and shock democratic conscience is not just that some insensitive entrepreneurs have launched a cynical marketing operation centred on Hitler, but that many customers patronise it and see nothing amiss.

Argues Rajeev Bhargava, a political theorist attached to the Centre for the Study of Developing Societies in Delhi: “When you name something that’s in the public domain after a person, you do it because that person represents something good, or because you are fond of him/her. Naming a café after Hitler amounts to eulogising him and ‘normalising’ his disgusting legacy of genocide and butchery of innocent people.”

Hitler is not a universally hated figure in India. Ideological supporters of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh, the secret society-like all-male organisation which sponsored the Hindu-chauvinist Bharatiya Janata Party, and which still acts as its mentor, have long admired the German dictator.

The RSS’s longest-standing leader, M.S. Golwalkar, glorified Hitler and lavishly praised him for fearlessly pursuing his project of regenerating Germany through an assertion of Aryan “racial purity” and suppression of the Jews. Golwalkar held up Nazi Germany as a role-model for India. Hardcore RSS members have never disowned or criticised Golwalkar.

The RSS was founded in 1925 and continues to have a significant presence in India as an obscurantist political current. It’s dedicated to recreating the glory of ancient India.

Hitler’s admirers are to be found at the other end of the spectrum too -among the modern urban elite, which dominates corporate jobs, the professions and the administration.

For instance, applicants for admission to India’s top-rated college, St Stephen’s College in Delhi, are asked at the final interview who’s their hero or role-model. “A shocking 60 percent of the candidates say it’s Hitler”, college principal Anil Wilson told IPS.

The figure is astounding. The reason most students cite for their choice is Hitler’s fierce nationalism: he gave Germany “self-esteem”, lifting it from the humiliation heaped on it by the Versailles treaty; his butchery of six million Jews was so much “collateral damage”.

“This bears testimony to an authoritarian streak with the Indian elite, or at least its fascination with and admiration for strong-arm undemocratic methods of rule”, says Bhargava. “The danger is that events like the opening of ‘Hitler’s Cross’ might trigger a hysterical wave of authoritarian nationalism, reinforced by Hindu chauvinism.”

Many upper class Indians believe that a dictator alone can solve the country’s myriad problems. An eminent example is the late lawyer N.A. Palkhivala who contested Indira Gandhi’s Emergency rule of the mid-1970s. Towards the end of his life, Palkhivala advocated the “Singapore model”, or a strong dose of authoritarianism for India.

Sociologists relate this streak to the elite’s roots in India’s super-hierarchical caste system. Many upper-caste, upper-class Indians have not fully reconciled themselves to democracy, including the idea that their chauffeurs and cooks should have the same individual vote as them.

“This calls for a deep, critical reflection on Indian society”, says Chenoy. “There is something seriously wrong with eulogising Hitler. But this cannot be separated from the neo-liberal economic policies India is following. The temptation to cynically use all and any symbols to make money will grow under neoliberal policies even if it means spreading fascist forms of callousness towards the public good. The time has come to rethink the direction that India’s social, economic and political processes are taking.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags