Development & Aid, Economy & Trade, Headlines, Latin America & the Caribbean

VENEZUELA: Gov’t Distances Itself from Golf Club Expropriation Plan

Humberto Márquez

CARACAS, Aug 31 2006 (IPS) - The mayor of the Venezuelan capital has kicked up a storm by stating that two of the city’s three golf courses will be subject to “forced acquisition” for the purpose of building low-cost housing.

However, the government of President Hugo Chávez has distanced itself from Mayor Juan Barreto’s decision.

In a communiqué released Wednesday, Vice President José Vicente Rangel stated that “The national government does not share the decision adopted by” the mayor, which “could affect constitutional and legal norms.”

The government “rejects any attempt, from any quarter, aimed at undermining the state of law.” And although it does not “worship the right to private property,” it considers that “legal security must exist for all citizens, without discrimination.”

According to Barreto, “Maintaining one square metre of grass on a golf course consumes what 20 familiesàneed for survival for an entire week. Instead of 185 club members playing (golf), we could solve the housing problem of 25,000 families.”

The mayor, a staunch Chávez ally, also lashed out at the centre-right authorities in the districts where the clubs are located, saying they represent “the putrid middle-class.” In addition, he said that if it were necessary to solve the acute housing crisis, he was prepared to “expropriate not only the golf courses but an entire district.”

In Caracas “1.5 million people live in precarious conditions,” and if low-income housing for 25,000 families can be built on the golf clubs’ property, “in another phase of acquisitions and expropriations, we could benefit up to 100,000 families.”

Venezuela, a country of 26.5 million people and 6.3 million households, has a housing shortage of 600,000 units, while another million dwellings are in need of upgrading, expansion or repairs, reports a local human rights group, PROVEA.

Included in the one million units in need of “upgrading” are tens of thousands of dwellings in crowded shantytowns and slums covering more than 1,000 hectares of hills and gullies surrounding Caracas.

The National Institute of Statistics (INE) reported that in late 2004, 942,000 homes – 16 percent of the nationwide total – suffered critical overcrowding.

The Venezuelan Construction Chamber estimates the national housing shortage at 1.8 million units.

The Homeless Movement, a local non-governmental organisation, has received some 350,000 applications for housing solutions from poor families, the group’s spokesman Máximo Hernández told IPS.

The housing deficit is seen as the Achilles’ heel of the Chávez administration’s social policies. In July, the president removed housing minister Luis Figueroa, who served just 10 months in the post. In 2005 only 41,000 housing units were built, compared to the 120,000 that were projected.

The plan for 2006 was to build 150,000 dwellings, according to the new housing minister, Ramón Carrizález, who was appointed after a successful stint as minister of infrastructure. But as of July, only 35,000 had been built.

José Núñez, author of a PROVEA study, pointed out to IPS that since 2004, occupations by squatters of empty lots and uninhabited buildings have intensified “as a social mechanism” to combat the housing problem.

Early this year, Barreto carried out compulsory purchases of dozens of unoccupied, partially vacant or unfinished buildings in Caracas to provide housing for homeless families. But on several occasions he had problems with residents of middle-class neighbourhoods where buildings were expropriated, who complained about their new neighbours.

His announcement to forcibly acquire the land belonging to the Caracas Country Club and Valle Arriba golf club took both the opposition and government supporters by surprise. In the ensuing debate, no one has discussed the possibility of moving the golf courses to another location.

Fernando Zozaya, president of the Caracas Country Club, said that “along with the residents of the area, 9,000 direct or indirect jobs would be affected.” He also stated that “the courses include rainwater runoff areas, and there is neither the infrastructure nor the services to build housing units there.”

The eight-decade-old Caracas Country Club occupies 80 hectares of land, and the newer Valle Arriba club covers 43 hectares.

The head of urban planning in Caracas, Mikel Menéndez, said “not one single tree would be cut down, the wind passages would be preserved, and the buildings would be only four to six stories high.”

The compulsory purchase of the two golf courses could cost 240 million dollars, based on current property prices in that upscale area – an amount that was not planned for in the city budget, and that would be roughly equivalent to half of the city’s total annual expenditure.

José Luis Betancourt, president of the Fedecámaras business chamber, said the mayor’s decree was “an irresponsible and sensationalist bid to gain supportàwhich could cause further problems for a city that is already overcrowded.”

Ruling coalition lawmaker Calixto Ortega also criticised Barreto’s decision, saying that “if a golf course is expropriated in Caracas, it should be to make public parks, in order to give the city some breathing room.”

Interior Minister Jesse Chacón said “this is not the way to resolve problems; the best route is through dialogue.”

Henrique Capriles and Leopoldo López of the centre-right Justice First Party, the mayors of the districts where the golf clubs are located, suggested building low-income housing on the former military airport La Carlota in eastern Caracas and on the land occupied by the Fuerte Tiuna military base, which is located on 5,600 hectares on the southwest side of the city.

(Caracas is divided into five municipalities, each of which has its own mayor – Capriles and López are two of them – although Barreto is the top authority).

Barreto, who clarified that Chávez had nothing to do with his decision, said he would take his case to the Supreme Court.

He also said the compensation for the golf clubs would come from the money that the five Caracas municipalities owe his office.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags