Wednesday, November 18, 2026
Katherine Stapp
- Genetically engineered canola plants can pass on their insect-killing genes to offspring with wild varieties, researchers have found.
It is thought to be the first hard evidence that the insect-resistant Bt gene may move from GM crops to such a hybrid.
According to the New Scientist magazine, which published the experiments by researchers at the University of North Carolina, ”the finding will fuel fears that ‘superweeds’ containing foreign genes making them immune to insect attack might spread rapidly”.
Of 11 crosses between GM oilseed rape (canola) and a wild relative, five produced stable hybrids containing the Bt gene, the researchers reported.
”This demonstrates that hybrids can and will be formed and that they will have insecticidal activity,” said Brian Johnson, biotechnology adviser to English Nature, a government-funded conservation group that urges more investigation of the environmental consequences before GM rape is released.
GM critics say the finding is worrisome because crops growing in open fields are notoriously hard to contain.
Friday, the Texas-based biotech company Prodigene agreed to pay a 250,000-dollar fine to settle government charges that it had contaminated half a million bushels of soybeans with corn genetically engineered to produce medicine.
The experimental bio-corn is designed to produce trypsin for diabetes and another compound to treat diarrhoea.
Besides the fine, Prodigene will reimburse the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) for the cost of buying the contaminated crop in storage in Nebraska, destroying the beans and cleaning the facility.
Prodigene also agreed to a one-million-dollar bond and higher compliance standards, including additional approvals before field testing and harvesting genetically modified material.
The company neither admitted nor denied any violations of the U.S. Plant Protection Act, and the soybeans never reached the human or animal food supply.
”This is an example of how biotechnology safeguarding regulations are working to ensure the integrity of the system,” said Bill Hawks, USDA’s under secretary for marketing and regulatory programs.
Others were less sanguine. ”The government clearly knew about this contamination weeks ago and chose not to reveal the information to the public, but instead worked behind closed doors with the industry to try to cover this up,” said Joseph Mendelson, legal director at the Center for Food Safety.
Matt Rand, biotechnology campaign manager for the National Environmental Trust, said the Prodigene incident should spur the USDA to halt all experimental genetically engineered crops grown on farms.
”If the government continues to develop policies for the biotech industry instead of for the safety of the U.S. food supply, it is just a matter of time before one of these experimental crops ends up on our dinner plates,” he said.
Under the Plant Protection Act, USDA’s Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service (APHIS) regulates the movement, importation and field release of genetically engineered plants.
Responding to public concerns that foreign genes would infiltrate the food chain, a group of companies belonging to the Biotechnology Industry Association agreed in October to stop growing such crops in corn-belt states in 2003.
But the group has since backed off its promise. Its new policy says that ”detailed scientific and regulatory analyses confirm that plants that produce pharmaceutical and industrial products can be safely planted, grown and harvested in an agricultural region where all of the appropriate production, confinement and handling practices are implemented”.
As for Prodigene, the government says it can continue to experiment with ”pharming” – engineering plants to produce drugs and other chemical compounds – under tighter regulations.
In an interview last year, Prodigene CEO Gene Laos told IPS that the company was working on edible plant-based vaccines, whose cost-effectiveness could be a boon for poorer countries.
”It will definitely benefit the underdeveloped countries, since the carrier for the antigen would be a seed,” he said. ”Although edible vaccines have to be administered by a doctor, other factors – transportation, refrigeration – are negated for poor countries, as well as the cost of needles and other supplies.”
”We’ve had a vaccine stored in a corn seed for five years without degradation,” he added.
Most ”pharming” is still in the early stages, and its usefulness – and hazards – is hard to gauge.
Michael Rodemeyer, head of the Washington-based Pew Initiative on Food and Biotechnology, an independent research group that says it takes a neutral position on biotechnology, said that ”biotech has changed the way we think about plants”.
”Corn is a wonderful protein factory that could be of value for pharmaceuticals, diagnostics, and industrial applications,” he said. ”Plants are a renewable resource, with environmental and energy advantages. This technology may offer a way to do things that couldn’t be done otherwise.”
”The question is how do we make sure that the (GM) versions – particularly for non-food uses – do not get into the food crops, and that’s something the regulatory agencies here are looking at,” Rodemeyer added.
Meanwhile, farmers say they are finding canola plants that are now resistant to two or three chemicals.
”Now, after growing canola, possibly none of these chemicals can be used without some other chemical added to be sure to kill the volunteer canola. Our problem is that there aren’t many other chemicals that will do an effective job on canola weeds, let alone the added cost that the farmer now has to bear," said a Canadian grower quoted on www.agriculture.com.
Katherine Stapp
- Genetically engineered canola plants can pass on their insect-killing genes to offspring with wild varieties, researchers have found.
(more…)