Headlines

UNITED NATIONS: U.N. Split Over International Criminal Court

Thalif Deen

UNITED NATIONS, Dec 21 1994 (IPS) - The United Nations has shelved a proposal to establish an international criminal court (ICC) to try hijackers, terrorists, drug traffickers, and crimes relating to genocide.

A U.N. source told IPS Wednesday the decision to delay the ICC was prompted by a sharp division of opinion.

Western powers, like the United States, which have veto rights in the U.N. Security Council, preferred the Council to create ad hoc tribunals to deal with international crimes on a case-by-case basis. The United States argued that the Council could then control the powers of such tribunals and the appointment of judges.

The Security Council recently set up two such tribunals to try those accused of genocide in the former Yugoslavia and Rwanda.

Secretary-General Boutros Boutros-Ghali named South African judge Richard Goldstone as the Prosecutor. But the Security Council has to finally approve Goldstone’s appointment.

Gerard Van Bohemen of New Zealand argued it was far better for the international community to have recourse to a single and established international criminal court than for the Security Council to engage “in the difficult process of establishing ad hoc tribunals.”

Such tribunals, he said, risked inconsistencies in the elaboration and application of international criminal law.

George Lamptey of Ghana proposed that the General Assembly schedule a conference for 1997 to finalise the ICC statute which has been drafted by the United Nations’ International Law Commission. But the proposal was put to a vote and defeated in the U.N. Legal Committee last week.

Given the disagreements, the 185-member General Assembly is setting up an ad hoc committee to discuss the administrative requirements for the proposed court. The committee is to hold its first meeting next August and present its report to the 50th session of the General Assembly in September.

Lamptey told delegates that if an ICC existed, many current difficulties would be eliminated. “Libya would not be suffering today because it refused to send its citizens for trial in a court in whose jurisdiction it lacked confidence,” he said.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags