Environment, Europe, Headlines

ENVIRONMENT-SWEDEN: Pressure To Phase Out Nuclear Power

Greg McIvor

FORSMARK, Sweden, Nov 16 1995 (IPS) - From a hill near his log cabin home on the picturesque island of Graso, Mats Tornqvist can see the three cream-coloured nuclear reactors of Forsmark power station looming above the horizon 12 kilometres away on the mainland.

The sparsely-populated island on Sweden’s Baltic Sea east coast is a rustic idyll. But in Tornqvist’s eyes the pristine environment is degraded by the nuclear plant and its hundreds of tonnes of radioactive waste dumped offshore beneath the sea.

A former atomic scientist but now active in the Swedish People’s Campaign Against Nuclear Power, he feels uncomfortable living in the shadow of the reactors. Not because of the risk of a Chernobyl- type accident inside the plant — Sweden boasts one of the world’s safer nuclear industries — but because he fears leakage from the underground repository.

At present no alternative exists to dumping nuclear waste underground and the most radioactive materials take 100,000 years to become safe. Tornqvist sees dumping as a crime against future generations and believes inhabitants of the Forsmark region are sitting on an insidious time-bomb.

“We have no safe way of dealing with this waste. The industry only talks of the ‘best known method’. Unless we stop producing it we are taking a terrible risk with the future,” he said. “I feel moral indignation at the problems we are causing for future generations. I see myself as a criminal in their eyes.”

The fate of Forsmark and Sweden’s three other nuclear plants has risen to the top of the political agenda recently amid mounting pressure from the green movement to start phasing out all the country’s 12 reactors as agreed at a national referendum in 1980.

According to a decision by parliament, all reactors should be decommissioned by 2010. But no initial steps have been taken and environmentalists accuse the government of dragging its feet in the face of intense lobbying by the two big companies that together dominate the Swedish power industry.

Swedish Social Democrat prime minister Ingvar Carlsson has said he feels morally bound by the 1980 referendum but conceded this week that a new plebiscite might be necessary as many younger members of parliament do not view themselves as tied by a decision taken 15 years ago.

An example of the divergent opinions even at the highest level came last month when Energy Minister Jorgen Andersson suggested the 2010 deadline could not be reached due to a dearth of viable alternative power sources.

The statement, which also reflected government concern over the 15 billion dollar minimum cost of decommissioning, drew a stinging rebuke from environmentalists that Andersson was preparing to subvert the democratic process.

Opinion polls indicate a majority of Swedes oppose nuclear power, with memories going back to the widespread contamination suffered after the Chernobyl disaster in 1986. Yet many question the wisdom of a phase-out when few genuine alternatives exist.

Opponents claim that the nuclear power companies, encouraged by tacit government compliance, are deliberately neglecting development of other energy sources.

Certainly, the main electricity sources favoured by environmentalists — wind and solar power — cannot begin to compete with the capacity of even a single nuclear plant. Forsmark’s three reactors alone supply the power needs of Sweden’s three biggest cities, Stockholm, Gothenburg and Malmo.

Meanwhile, construction of new power stations fired by natural gas, oil or coal would not only drain the public purse but would drastically increase greenhouse gas emissions, in contravention of Sweden’s international commitments made at the Rio Summit.

Any shift towards hydroelectric power, which already supplies the other half of Sweden’s non-nuclear electricity, would mean the socially divisive policy of damming more big rivers in the arctic north – a move seen as politically impossible.

The idea was aired by Andersson this week but the Green and Liberal Party leaders Birger Schlaug and Maria Leissner accused him of environmental philistinism. “It is outrageous and astonishing that Andersson wants to discuss expanding hydro- electric power on undisturbed rivers that are protected by law,” Leissner said.

Yet although the opposition Greens and Liberals are both opposed to new hydro-electric schemes, they agree on little else.

Alongside the conservative Moderate Party, the Liberals believe a nuclear phase-out by 2010 is unrealistic. The Greens, together with the Left Party and Centre Party, insist the timetable must be respected.

Meanwhile the Social Democrats are divided. Observers believe even a compromise, perhaps involving partial decommissioning by 2010, will be difficult to reach in the current confused political matrix.

For heavy industry, which has for years prospered from cheap electricity, nuclear power is seen as an imperative. One leading industrialist, the chairman of car maker Volvo, Bert-Olof Svanholm, dismissed the pro-decommissioning lobby as “crazy”, saying the cost of building alternative plants would be crippling.

Dima Litvinov, Greenpeace Sweden’s nuclear campaigner, warned that people were swallowing industry propaganda. “Big companies are threatening to move their production abroad if they lose, and unfortunately that argument is being accepted,” he said

Organisations like Greenpeace and the Swedish Society for Nature Conservation advocate expansion of small-scale, local energy production based on solar power, wind power and bio-fuels.

But this solution is unpopular with the two big power generators, Vattenfall and Sydkraft, whose hegemony would be threatened by a decentralised market.

In the countryside and villages around Forsmark inhabitants view talk of a nuclear phase-out with foreboding. In a region of 35,000 people suffering 15 percent unemployment, the presence of an industry that directly employs 850 people and indirectly supports thousands more is seen as an economic necessity.

Pia Ekman, a young mother-of-two who lives two miles from the nuclear plant and owns a habadashery shop, said she hoped her children would one day find jobs at the power station.

“Without Forsmark I would be unemployed. The only thing that keeps this area alive is the nuclear plant.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags